8 cant be trusted, he came in, asked for a pair, said he didnt read, and then never came back.
I think this is fair.
Less than 2 days people. Chop chopIn post 1916, FakeGod wrote:All replacements have been filled.
Pre-dance lasts 8 days. (count from post #1)
OH SHIT THAT REMINDS ME. 1 SECIn post 1923, Lady 5 wrote:Nice, did you copy my format or make that yourself?In post 1875, Gentleman 6 wrote:If I can get Lady 4 to commit to leaving that will make all this easier. Otherwise I guess I have to try to make a case.
What all that adds up to, G5, is that you have no slots that you are unwilling to lynch and you're trying to use a read on a slot that isn't even mine as a shield against my scumread.
Like, my reads are
G1 is probably town
G2 is town
G3 is probably town
G4 is probably town
G5 is scum
G6 is known town
G7 is probably town
G8 is unknown-scum
L1 is leanscum
L2 is leantown
L3 is unknown
L4 is probably town
L5 is maybe scum with you? idk. i'm not actually trying to read her right now.
L6 is probably town
L7 is leanscum
L8 is -blanked-
L9 is leantown
see how i have townreads?
G8 is Unknown Scum? What dose that mean?
Time to see how much you pay attention with the next question.
Why do you townread Gent 2?
Is L1 lean scum because they aren’t giving that much content?
I love how you blank L8 but yet wanted to be with her so much.
This never got answered, it was actually interesting cause G6 seemed to waiver on if his pair on L8 was town recentlyIn post 1441, Gentleman 5 wrote:That was fast. In fact thats the first thing L8 mentions: making sure shes going to the next round.In post 1270, Lady 8 wrote:I'm reading. I'm trying to commit to at least one catchup a day.
In post 1005, Gentleman 6 wrote:Whatever disregard correct play dance with the hottest girl.
Lady 8, will you dance with me?I accept.
G6: You mentioned it after you made the proposal but Id like to ask you again - do you think your pairing is T-T?
In post 1300, Gentleman 6 wrote:I think G5 is probably town but has higher likelihood to be snowing town than other slots.
????????In post 1382, Gentleman 6 wrote:Also, I feel like throughout the game 7 has been super reluctant to give out townreads. She heavily qualified her Lady 9 townread in the earliest part of the game, her only real townread was me (universal to the point of being pointless to against), and she has since in recent pages gone against both her townreads on myself and Lady 9. Dunno.
Amusingly, I said that I wanted L4 and L7 with one as confident TR and the other as a slot that I wanted to sort via hood, but I lied about which was which. I didn't want to pair with L4 regardless for /reasons/.
Lady 4 is heavily leaning town.What’s your read on them individually?
Gentleman 5 is really pro-town but idk. There's moments that I don't like that really stand out. Kinda just a feeling thing, that I don't trust the townreads there. Not like immediately going after them.
Im talking about the G6 part.In post 1934, Gentleman 4 wrote:In post 1930, Gentleman 5 wrote:This never got answered, it was actually interesting cause G6 seemed to waiver on if his pair on L8 was town recentlyIn post 1441, Gentleman 5 wrote:That was fast. In fact thats the first thing L8 mentions: making sure shes going to the next round.In post 1270, Lady 8 wrote:I'm reading. I'm trying to commit to at least one catchup a day.
In post 1005, Gentleman 6 wrote:Whatever disregard correct play dance with the hottest girl.
Lady 8, will you dance with me?I accept.
G6: You mentioned it after you made the proposal but Id like to ask you again - do you think your pairing is T-T?Spoiler: Yes it did.
In my opinion:In post 1946, Lady 5 wrote:What if G3 takes L6?In post 1924, Gentleman 5 wrote:If G3 takes L5, G1 should take L6.
In post 1948, Gentleman 6 wrote:interesting that L5 and G5 both started townreading each other when I went after L5 and both for immensely shitty reasoning.In post 1939, Lady 5 wrote:I might be biased but I don’t think Mafia would put in that much effort.
IDK I’ll take Gent 5 down to Null for now.
Agreeing = townreading.In post 1949, Gentleman 6 wrote:went after G5.
Fixed.In post 1970, Gentleman 6 wrote:The same thing I planned on doing if you flipped scumIn post 1968, Lady 5 wrote:What will you do when I flip town?In post 1966, Gentleman 6 wrote:can we leave out L5 then lynch G5 please and have a really easy game
Just gonna keep this in mind for later.In post 1933, Gentleman 5 wrote:In post 1300, Gentleman 6 wrote:I think G5 is probably town but has higher likelihood to be snowing town than other slots.????????In post 1382, Gentleman 6 wrote:Also, I feel like throughout the game 7 has been super reluctant to give out townreads. She heavily qualified her Lady 9 townread in the earliest part of the game, her only real townread was me (universal to the point of being pointless to against), and she has since in recent pages gone against both her townreads on myself and Lady 9. Dunno.
Amusingly, I said that I wanted L4 and L7 with one as confident TR and the other as a slot that I wanted to sort via hood, but I lied about which was which. I didn't want to pair with L4 regardless for /reasons/.
Lady 4 is heavily leaning town.What’s your read on them individually?
Gentleman 5 is really pro-town but idk. There's moments that I don't like that really stand out. Kinda just a feeling thing, that I don't trust the townreads there. Not like immediately going after them.
G6 was drunkposting with L7 I see
Ill leave it for everyone else to look at. Those posts dont seem to be from someone who obviously knows im mafia.In post 1974, Gentleman 5 wrote:Just gonna keep this in mind for later.In post 1933, Gentleman 5 wrote:In post 1300, Gentleman 6 wrote:I think G5 is probably town but has higher likelihood to be snowing town than other slots.????????In post 1382, Gentleman 6 wrote:Also, I feel like throughout the game 7 has been super reluctant to give out townreads. She heavily qualified her Lady 9 townread in the earliest part of the game, her only real townread was me (universal to the point of being pointless to against), and she has since in recent pages gone against both her townreads on myself and Lady 9. Dunno.
Amusingly, I said that I wanted L4 and L7 with one as confident TR and the other as a slot that I wanted to sort via hood, but I lied about which was which. I didn't want to pair with L4 regardless for /reasons/.
Lady 4 is heavily leaning town.What’s your read on them individually?
Gentleman 5 is really pro-town but idk. There's moments that I don't like that really stand out. Kinda just a feeling thing, that I don't trust the townreads there. Not like immediately going after them.
G6 was drunkposting with L7 I see
Yeah, L8.In post 1987, Lady 5 wrote:I swear if you are both Town you guys need to fuckin quit with this shit now and focus on the real mafia.
Lol shes not townreading me and im not townreading her.In post 1990, Gentleman 6 wrote:like either this is SvS between L5 and G5 or L5 is a dumbass who instantly townread G5 the moment he extended her the slightest olive branch of a townread.
Wtf?In post 1996, Lady 5 wrote:I really don’t want to leave because I feel without me Town will miss Lynch and lose.
Its more that L6 and L2 deserve a seat to the table with G3 and G1In post 1999, Lady 1 wrote:I think G4, 5, and 6 are all probably town. I think L4 and L5 are probably town. I scumlean L6, but I can’t tell if they are insufferably bad or just mafia trying to control the narrative. Either way, her point about G8 not choosing me and therefore me being scum buddies makes no sense for her stated reasons and looks like she’s trying to setup lynches based off G8’s flip.
I agree that G8 is probably scum.
G5, why did you say my desire to pair with G3 was bad?
Given deadline, no.In post 2004, Lady 1 wrote:Did anyone else feel like the 7/7 pair came out of left field?
Because you threatened the replace out and get outside game influence?!In post 2003, Lady 5 wrote:I can try to keep it in check, but people just tell me to go away and that I’m confusing so you know.In post 1995, Gentleman 5 wrote:I miss OG G2.
He would have kept this game in check. G4 is trying to, but since hes not IC, its not as effective.
Youre no Chiaki. I dont think you can lead town, so cut the ate.In post 2011, Lady 5 wrote:Yeah but I don’t want to watch Town fail and get banned :/In post 2001, Gentleman 5 wrote:Wtf?In post 1996, Lady 5 wrote:I really don’t want to leave because I feel without me Town will miss Lynch and lose.
Who do you think you are? Youre no paragon of town this game. You nearly got modkilled this morning.
I want G8 to choose between you and L5. L6 and 2 deserve to get with 3 and 1 at this time. Personally I want an L5 flip at this point.In post 2012, Lady 1 wrote:What? That doesn’t make any sense. My answer to your question (to refresh your memory: which gentlemen would you (directed at me) want?) has no bearing on L6/L2 getting asked. Why do L6/L2 deserve a seat at that table with those specific gentlemen?In post 2005, Gentleman 5 wrote:Its more that L6 and L2 deserve a seat to the table with G3 and G1In post 1999, Lady 1 wrote:I think G4, 5, and 6 are all probably town. I think L4 and L5 are probably town. I scumlean L6, but I can’t tell if they are insufferably bad or just mafia trying to control the narrative. Either way, her point about G8 not choosing me and therefore me being scum buddies makes no sense for her stated reasons and looks like she’s trying to setup lynches based off G8’s flip.
I agree that G8 is probably scum.
G5, why did you say my desire to pair with G3 was bad?
Atleast we are in agreement there.In post 2027, Gentleman 6 wrote:L6 isn't scum.In post 2023, Lady 1 wrote:I think L5 is town. I would really rather we kill L6, but if L5 -> G8/L1 nabs 1 scum I will be ok with that.
L6 should be asked first.In post 2022, Gentleman 4 wrote:For the purpose of sanity, I hope Gentleman 1 becomes more active and asks Lady 2, and Gentleman 3 asks Lady 1, who in turn maintains her current activity trend.
Talk to me about L8
.... I wasnt talking about L3?In post 2033, Gentleman 4 wrote:Relax. Looking for wagons right now is rash - there are a lot of things that I think several players haven't said yet, and it would be remarkably hasty of you to try and get my sweetheart killed before I get a word in. I think trying to enter the dance phase at anything faster than a relaxed pace is foolish.In post 2017, Gentleman 5 wrote:G4 and G2: please be prepared for shit to hit the fan at the dance if L5 is alive or flips town. I hope yall can control the wagons cause we will probably be looking for a 1v1
I liked the entrance from yesterday, it was wayyyy to agressive and stubborn to come from scum.In post 2034, Lady 1 wrote:L5 is playing so bad it has to be town.
G6, G5, why the strong L6 town reads?
L8s accept was hasty, but not from nowhere.In post 2041, Lady 1 wrote:I’m thinking this game is 2G/1L. I think if L6 isn’t scum, L8’s auto acceptance from nowhere is scum indicative. Would make sense too if 2G/1L.
What?In post 2054, Lady 5 wrote:Yet I’m still considered the one that should be left out.In post 2042, Gentleman 5 wrote:I liked the entrance from yesterday, it was wayyyy to agressive and stubborn to come from scum.In post 2034, Lady 1 wrote:L5 is playing so bad it has to be town.
G6, G5, why the strong L6 town reads?
The fact she stopped after overreacting is good too.
But again it isn’t up to everyone, it’s up to G1 and G3 as who they truly believe is Town.
And that my friends is how a lady becomes left out, when no Gentleman is left to take their hand.
You and G4 are hiding reads for reasons. I wasnt aware that only you two could do that.In post 2056, Gentleman 6 wrote:I'm fine with 1 of L5/L1 sitting.
I am NOT fine with L6 sitting.
Do you remember the point that I saidLook I’m not going to fake townreads. And scumhunting isn’t leaving hints open to mislynch, it’s trying to find out people’s alignments.
I didn’t snipe. This right here feels like sniping at me though, and you have been for days. You’re not reading what I’ve written in response to your theory, you’re just sniping at me. I didn’t make her muslynchable. I had a theory I acknowledged could be silly. Didn’t even push it. You’re the one keeping it front and forefront by claiming I’m not allowed to scumhunt.
I explicitly think that you don't actually feel scummy despite my disliking your read progressions on an intellectual level and that's why I wanted a hood to sort you more directly
I think that G5 is explicitly scummy in his approach. I haven't responded to you because I didn't really have anything to say: I already understood that you could be town with the progressions you had.
I'm not calling you scum, in other words. I think your play has been pro-scum in terms of the sense of having not enough townreads in an absolute sense but that doesn't make you scum.
G5 is scum for more than his lack of townreads and his reluctance to dole out townreads, which is why I am spiritually voting him.
Which is why if G3 doesnt ask someone to dance in his first couple of posts hes claiming scum.In post 2072, Lady 5 wrote:Chances are G8 is probably just going to fast grab L6 since it’s auto.In post 2068, Lady 1 wrote:Town:In post 2057, Lady 3 wrote:L1 can you just rank the dance partners you want, then bold and Max size that list for us ty
G1
G3
G8
Ideal situation to read partner:
G3
G1
G8
I would take G8 and leave dance at very first opportunity though.
My list is always -) G3, G1, G8.
G8 at this time is a troll.In post 2081, Lady 1 wrote:G8 would only do that if he’s not scum with L6, which I’m not sure is that highly likely.In post 2072, Lady 5 wrote:Chances are G8 is probably just going to fast grab L6 since it’s auto.In post 2068, Lady 1 wrote:Town:In post 2057, Lady 3 wrote:L1 can you just rank the dance partners you want, then bold and Max size that list for us ty
G1
G3
G8
Ideal situation to read partner:
G3
G1
G8
I would take G8 and leave dance at very first opportunity though.
My list is always -) G3, G1, G8.
Those are bad reads, so I decline.In post 2087, Lady 6 wrote:If I don't survive, can you table your battle with G5 and L5 until G1 G8 and L1 die? I think scum are in a hell of a predicament here if my gut instinct is correct.In post 2056, Gentleman 6 wrote:G5 is scum for more than his lack of townreads and his reluctance to dole out townreads, which is why I am spiritually voting him.
If G3 partners with L5 that will leave G1 and G8 alive. One would partner with L1 and the other would let me die by partnering with L2.
If this setup happens, lynch L1 asap please. Then go to your silly squabbles.
This is true, L5 did accept right away.In post 2143, Gentleman 4 wrote:No lady has declined yet, I think Lady 5 did post before Lady 4 accepted, however.In post 2140, Gentleman 2 wrote:G5 you asked L5 to dance, did she decline or did you ask L4 before L5 answered you?
Assuming the salad says no, then what?In post 2147, Gentleman 6 wrote:Anyway, I've said what I wanted to say for right now.
Waiting for a response from Lady 4 I guess.
In post 1033, Lady 4 wrote:Caesar.In post 1026, Gentleman 5 wrote:Whats your favorite kind of salad?
In post 792, Gentleman 5 wrote:Actually im retracting my previous statement, because L1 and L6 havent posted much.
Lets starts some controversy.
Lady 5, care to dance with me?
Misty will be my biggest regret though
In post 1020, Gentleman 5 wrote:You hate to see it.In post 1005, Gentleman 6 wrote:Whatever disregard correct play dance with the hottest girl.
Lady 8, will you dance with me?
Lady 5 wrote:Gentleman 5 would help with pushing my scum Reads but I’d have trouble trusting him at least in the beginning as he’s not my Lock Town where I can say with 100% confidence that Gentleman 3 is Town.
Me and Him can share are Reads and make stronger solving.Hey FakeGod, am I allowed to retract my invite?
In post 1031, Gentleman 5 wrote:I can still work with L5, for reasons.
But I share the sentiment with L4 that her previous post was bad.
In post 1036, Gentleman 5 wrote:This reads to me as something I would say in a scum PT. Like something I would ask my scumbuddies before accepting the proposal. Given her hesitance, It makes me wonder.In post 1014, Lady 5 wrote:Gentleman 5 would help with pushing my scum Reads but I’d have trouble trusting him at least in the beginning as he’s not my Lock Town where I can say with 100% confidence that Gentleman 3 is Town.
Me and Him can share are Reads and make stronger solving.
I think L8 is mafia, I dont think L5 can be mafia with L8 given their interactions imo, so I may have to check into my reads of both.
In post 1046, Gentleman 5 wrote:Honestly, theres alot I could say about L5 not accepting the proposal.
I thought she would have accepted that asap since people scumread her and probably have her pinned as a first target.
Im not sure how that makes me feel ie her alignment
Hope this somewhat helpsIn post 1105, Gentleman 5 wrote:This wont work, but lets try it because Im bored.
Lady 4, care to dance?
P-edit: we dont know that, i doubt that the above works.
He does, he should, and he will.In post 2164, Lady 6 wrote:In post 2161, Lady 3 wrote:Okay everylady except lady 2 has turned on auto invite and lady 2 should def turn on auto invite
reading consensus: Gentleman picks should be
3 picks his lady first
1 picks his lady next
8 picks the lady at the end
It's posts like this that make me scumread you. I think G8 and L1 are partners and you're suggesting that G8 (a guy who never shows) have control on who dies between the last two people.
Btw, this is town.In post 2181, Lady 6 wrote:@Gentleman4, I don't know. I have told you to quit being bad and you double down saying I'm bad. Take your own medicine and please be quiet so the last three gentlemen propose.
No?
Ok, so is your read on G6 based on this game or because you have an idea of who he is? Because its starting to get obvious this alt game may not be as hidden as FG wanted it to be.Lady 8 wrote:Pretty sure I know who you and G6 are.In post 2300, Gentleman 5 wrote:I think its because their partners, and thus an extension of themself.
“Look my partner is sooooo town” just feels as bad as if someone said “Look at me Im sooooooo town”
G6 is paragon level and obv town.You're a broken record player that keeps spewing my name every other post that thinks they're hot stuff.
So fuck off maybe?Also I have no problem leaving if your pairing leaves as well.
In this game or in mafia in general?In post 2315, Lady 8 wrote:No, I just consider myself really obv-town.
L8 are you aware that you and your partner are literally death tunneling me?Not usually but since I recently lost a game as town where someone literally death tunneled me with town being bad that game, I'm taking no chances when there's someone who's literally being obv-town and also being good at scum hunting.
L8 are you aware that G6 wont explain his read on you, nor G4 his read on L3.In post 785, Gentleman 5 wrote:Personally, I feel outting townreads are a bad idea until dance time, but thats just me?