Posted: Wed Feb 19, 2020 10:51 pm
Mod notes:
- Iconeum standing V/LA weekends.
Page 9 of 56
Posted: Wed Feb 19, 2020 11:11 pm
VOTE: Slaxx
Posted: Wed Feb 19, 2020 11:12 pm
ripIn post 78, Slaxx wrote:I’ll die on this hill
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 6:06 am
VOTE: slaxx
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 6:06 am
ripIn post 78, Slaxx wrote:I’ll die on this hill
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 6:07 am
@ico
bad logic doesn't mean scum
bad logic doesn't mean scum
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 6:08 am
this is a european lobby it looks like
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 6:41 am
Reads and stuff later today
@compath from 0 to 10 how upset?
@compath from 0 to 10 how upset?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 7:24 am
trainee "trainee" trainee stepping in again! Cop "Cop" Cop's been delayed on his way here. apparently there's talk of a Serial Driver on the loose! someone who has no concern for others' well-being and drives buses wherever he pleases! anyway.
she works hard you know
why is the way that Officer "Officer" Officer carries out her investigations lawbreaker-indicative?In post 199, Luca Blight wrote:I’ll get to the other reasoning soon, although the Hectic SL was based on the ‘officer’ gimmick which is making him hard to read. Based on content he’s entirely null.
she works hard you knowplease share with the class, Doctor! what did you see?
had you arrived at this conclusion when you made post 6? is there any particular reason that you wanted to hold onto this read and ignore Icon/Officer "Officer" Officer's questions about it until now?In post 184, Ame wrote:In particular, I read Compath's joke as forced because the hectic pun is obvious and seems like something that has probably been made many times. From this, I thought Compath was either,
A. Awkward scum
B. Someone who has played with hectic and was hinting at who he was
The latter was my interpretation after thinking about it, and if it were the case it was town indicative to me because it would be unnecessarily putting himself out there / providing information to hectic. I scum read DDL for his serious vote because I felt he also picked up on the awkwardness, but instead of thinking it through to the alternative option (B), he stopped at (A), which was scum indicative to me (pushing over sorting).
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 7:41 am
trainee "trainee" trainee again!
Knight Luca's suspicious on Conniver Kanna actually have good grounds with what he can see, and is a good look for him! but Luca, the coffee questions and "Wow" are almost definitely NAI in this context
Wyvern Icon! what do you think of Demon Slayer Ame's 196? i'm surprised you had nothing to say it about it considering your earlier push and suspicion on Ame regarding her Compath read (◕ﬦ ◕✿)
Knight Luca's suspicious on Conniver Kanna actually have good grounds with what he can see, and is a good look for him! but Luca, the coffee questions and "Wow" are almost definitely NAI in this context
Wyvern Icon! what do you think of Demon Slayer Ame's 196? i'm surprised you had nothing to say it about it considering your earlier push and suspicion on Ame regarding her Compath read (◕ﬦ ◕✿)
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 7:43 am
you know who
what did i miss?? can you show me where please? i can't find any mention of why you're excludedIn post 119, Ame wrote:Not reading I seeIn post 116, Hectic wrote: Deputy Compath, is the exclusion of Ame deliberate from your reads list?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 10:55 am
Actually VOTE: Luca Blight I had a look at that game you linked and you were reallllyyy against RQS there, why were you accepting of Ame in this game?
Also you said this but this is *after* you already trusted them (if that makes sense)
Also you said this but this is *after* you already trusted them (if that makes sense)
In post 166, Luca Blight wrote:The difference though is that in that newbie game the player (Spangled) didn't hold onto the RQS, whereas Ame is.
What is the scum motivation behind insisting everyone answers the questions?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 11:02 am
As for clidd, not sure. I know he does do walls as town but idk if he's incapable of doing them as scumIn post 199, Luca Blight wrote:What’s your read on Clidd, Kanna?In post 177, Kanna wrote:It's interesting because he's going against the current. E.g he put clidd who was p scumread earlier as a TR while you/hectic/me as an SR. He hasn't put out all the reasoning yet, so I'm not sure.In post 174, Iconeum wrote:what do you mean by 'interesting'? what do you make of it?In post 142, Kanna wrote:Luca's latest takes were pretty interesting because they seem to be the opposite of most reads I've seen. I just want to say I wouldn't look into the coffee thing or the wow thing because ~reasons~. From my POV, it looks a bit opportunistic to push me on those things but I could be biased.
@luca; would be interested in the rest of the reasoning btw
Do you think going against the current is more Town or scum indicative?
I’ll get to the other reasoning soon, although the Hectic SL was based on the ‘officer’ gimmick which is making him hard to read. Based on content he’s entirely null.
@clidd, do you have any other scumgames I can look at? That one you linked was v short
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 11:04 am
@clidd, you're not hiding a gun, are you?
coffee
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 11:12 am
@luca; (carrying on from that post)
I think going against the current could go either way, it depends on whether the reasoning is good? I do kind of get gut feelings that scum might purposely go against the current though so people don't accuse them of sheeping. Would still like to hear the rest of your reasoning
I think going against the current could go either way, it depends on whether the reasoning is good? I do kind of get gut feelings that scum might purposely go against the current though so people don't accuse them of sheeping. Would still like to hear the rest of your reasoning
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 11:23 am
In post 178, Ame wrote:@Kanna, why a strong 7?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 11:23 am
Also current reads?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 12:55 pm
Kanna, as I said I’ve seen a few RQS coming from town since that game, so I no longer automatically associate RQS with scum.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 12:58 pm
I’m getting some Town vibes from Kanna recently.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 1:00 pm
@Luca can you go into your Compath read?
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 1:03 pm
I’m about to go out but will do when I get back.
It’s a read mainly based on tone, but I’ll see if I can elaborate on it.
It’s a read mainly based on tone, but I’ll see if I can elaborate on it.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 1:05 pm
Ok. Also what were you hoping to gain here:
In post 14, Luca Blight wrote:Your turn, Ame.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 1:14 pm
This reads as town to me. I was considering voting Ame because of the focus on RQS combined with only a spattering of discussion driving this particular game forward. I generally find people will happily engage in theory and generalization until they can park their vote somewhere, and it is usually a fairly good tell on Day 1. I feel good about Ame.In post 184, Ame wrote:In particular, I read Compath's joke as forced because the hectic pun is obvious and seems like something that has probably been made many times. From this, I thought Compath was either,
A. Awkward scum
B. Someone who has played with hectic and was hinting at who he was
The latter was my interpretation after thinking about it, and if it were the case it was town indicative to me because it would be unnecessarily putting himself out there / providing information to hectic. I scum read DDL for his serious vote because I felt he also picked up on the awkwardness, but instead of thinking it through to the alternative option (B), he stopped at (A), which was scum indicative to me (pushing over sorting).
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 1:20 pm
To specify a bit, the logic doesn't feel revisionist.
I'm not for sure if I agree with it, but I believe they believe it.
I don't know if scum-DDl pushes on me out of the gate though. The most memorable game I had with him was on my lolwagons alt where I stomped scum out early, and I know was scum I wouldn't immediately push on someone the way he did. Not saying he wouldn't push on me at all, just not for sure he goes this ham with it out the gate as scum. So I think I feel alright about DDL now as well.
I'm not for sure if I agree with it, but I believe they believe it.
I don't know if scum-DDl pushes on me out of the gate though. The most memorable game I had with him was on my lolwagons alt where I stomped scum out early, and I know was scum I wouldn't immediately push on someone the way he did. Not saying he wouldn't push on me at all, just not for sure he goes this ham with it out the gate as scum. So I think I feel alright about DDL now as well.
Posted: Thu Feb 20, 2020 1:22 pm
That game was a year ago, but still. Doesn't fit with how I assume he would play it. So (Ame, DDL) are town-ish. Going to keep going here.