In post 53, OutWorldER wrote:don't like tris's posts, 39, 41, 47 all feel like classic IIOA
VOTE: Tris
tris is very town so could you develop?
Every post of hers so far is fluff or IIOA. While the fluff could be written off as early-day posting, the posts I mention feel like an attempt to say something useful to establish a presence in the early-game without having to do anything controversial.
Not enthused by her reaction either, no defense on her part at all, the "good catch" feels defeatist, which I often see coming from scum.
i'd say that scum generally would try to not bother with pushes on em' early, her acknowledging feel very town to the contrary "yeah that's scummy, keep digging if you want, cuz i'm a pure heart of towniness" ya know?
and i'll check out those posts
I guess this is just a matter of different experience, but I also think that scum being aloof to pushes is a common enough tell that scum know to avoid it.
I don't like your exaggerated defense of her in this post, though I guess I didn't phrase things correctly. I guess appeasement would be the better word to use instead of defeatist.
never really thought about how scum avoids triggering tells, so idk on that one
this didn't really feel like appeasment, like, unless i'm misundersteanding?
Gypyx wrote:so worldER
imo, only 41 is really IIOA, and even then, i don't see how it's scummy, like, town also acknoledges obvious stuff ya know
especially given it's early and the game is wild
so ye, to me it's fine, other 2 posts feel like trying to thinking what the consequences of the voting format are
I would argue that if it is an obvious conclusion it is Information and not Analysis.
But even with your thesis, tris didn't develop off those conclusions in any way. It doesn't seem like she used that conclusion to develop any reads on how scum or town would be using the format to control the game, and if she did she didn't communicate them.
In fact the only posts of hers that really communicate to me any effort to draw alignment or communicate her own was her recent posts (83, 84, 85), y'know, after I started pushing her.
are really gonna get anything else than obvious conclusions page 1-5?
and well, idk, she has like 10 posts, and yeah, pushing often leads to peoples getting serious with the game?
not really seeing where's the problem with everything that bein' pointed out
I guess it's a matter of tone more than anything but it feels like she was trying to diffuse my vote by conceding the point like that.
think i've only seen town do that kinda stuff now that i think of it, but it's probably arguing around pointless stuff at that point
interesting vote / way to present it tbh, feelin' like it's lowkey scummy?
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 9:29 pm
by Gypyx
In post 131, flow trap wrote:I thought that the Blocs switched around every round?
indeed
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 9:33 pm
by Gypyx
In post 139, bugspray wrote:yeah tbh, i feel like scum would want to take ocntrol of their blocs if possible and someone who stokes tvt bloc infighting should absolutely get a paddlin'
- scum has an optimal way to play the game
- peoples who don't play that way are suspicious
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 9:38 pm
by Gypyx
i mean optimal isn't the best term but whatever you see my point Bug person
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 9:40 pm
by Gypyx
In post 154, Auro wrote:No. I'm going to have VANILLA ice cream by myself rather than go to TOWN to party.
Anya and Xtoxm are town, sweet! Gypyx probably too, let me review that.
could you give a percentage on that Xtomxm read? cuz like, dude only got 1 post lol
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 9:43 pm
by Gypyx
In post 190, mozamis wrote:It's rare outside of a Noob game to find someone outrageously scummy in the first few pages.
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 9:45 pm
by Gypyx
VOTE: Momrangal
don't see mozamis being scum tbh
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 10:12 pm
by Momrangal
Ya shur ya wanna do that m8
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 10:14 pm
by Momrangal
Actually
Gonna hard claim pgo protective.
Have fun with it
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 10:17 pm
by Gypyx
oh noes a pgo
better unvote before the role actually gets into the list of roles accepted in normal games
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 10:28 pm
by Momrangal
Reflexive
Vigilante
Jailkeeper
All normal.
Sticking to it, sounds like you don't want around. You scared
