it's a little outdated but heres the starter pack:
In post 1629, Morning Tweet wrote:NDMath I guess i gave some credit since his role seems to interact with the setup. To be honest though with Titus' soft CC and not even really being sure Ari is town i'm not sure how good that is
Tarou is unreadable
Enchant is basically unreadable. i think after skimming PyP, his play doesn't really resemble it quite exactly. and im also sort of surprised he forgot this game existed if scum since i've seen him care about scum more than that
Titus, although it's not her fault i don't have any reference for
Yuki and Ari have a bit more content than the others but I don't know them and obviously they're not around since ive repped in as far as i can remember. Yuki seems adamant they're playing to their town meta and Tarou is backing that up which makes me lean towards Tarou
-
realistically i think the majority of bad guys has to be in these players and if that isn't the case I don't think we're getting anywhere ever
I thik that Skybird, Pooky, Gamma, and potentialllyyyy A50 could technically be scum but those are problems i would wait on until I like have any grasp over the first half of the playerlist i mentioned
Gamma actually could be a tier lower but im getting the impression he is playing i just haven't been paying attention to his posts. i was also under the impression earlier that he played out of his scumrange according to some players (Same sort of thing for A50)
Pooky can just be scum but i wouldn't dare kill him. Sky i came around to the other day although im less certain of that now
No one I mention above the dash is playing the game to even the slightest degree
NDMath has a really bad D1 comparatively especially if you figure the main wagons are mostly or all town. Tarou has a similarly bad D1 and it also had a really bad comment about "Told yall we shoulda elimed Ari" despite doing nothing to show that on the previous day
Enchant contributes a little deeper than PyP Enchant by my own analysis and thats the best ive got.
Titus hasn't been able to play
Yuki chooses not to play. Is adamant they only play like this as town
Ari isn't here and i have been told flaking out is NAI for him. Glad you're here lets not have a repeat of 8-ball and you'll either obvscum or obvtown (to me) immediately
also Skybird's posting recently has been sort of bad from a Tarou!town perspective. I thought the same of A50 but im kind of not putting as much stock into that
Pooky can be scum but at least he's playing to at least some degree