Mafiascum.net

In post 198, Not Known 15 wrote:

In post 175, DkKoba wrote:

In post 172, Not Known 15 wrote:

In post 35, DkKoba wrote:if nk15 is the non traitor scum then rofl

I have not seen any credible explanation.
As soon as I begun questioning them I landed in koba's scum pile.
This is scum. VOTE: Koba

btw NK you had literally not even posted in thread at the time of that quoted post, so can you elaborate now, having that pointed out to you?
because it seems you're looking for a reason to vote me <3

I was actually referring to a later post when you listed me at scumreads.
Now, koba, again:

From where do you have knowledge about this game being town vs traitor plus

one

full scum

?

You’re reading into that way too much lol

In post 200, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 198, Not Known 15 wrote:

In post 175, DkKoba wrote:

In post 172, Not Known 15 wrote:

In post 35, DkKoba wrote:if nk15 is the non traitor scum then rofl

I have not seen any credible explanation.
As soon as I begun questioning them I landed in koba's scum pile.
This is scum. VOTE: Koba

btw NK you had literally not even posted in thread at the time of that quoted post, so can you elaborate now, having that pointed out to you?
because it seems you're looking for a reason to vote me <3

I was actually referring to a later post when you listed me at scumreads.
Now, koba, again:

From where do you have knowledge about this game being town vs traitor plus

one

full scum

?

You’re reading into that way too much lol

I'm just going to ignore nk15 from here on out tbh

^not super constuctive
@nk it's not 1 scum+ 1 traitor. that would make the scumteam weaker than standard 4 9p, so wildly unbalanced.

In post 111, DkKoba wrote:let me give you a list of players who have played in a game with me before:


tictac
Testarossa
marcistar
ChaosOmega
Meuh
GuiltyLion
DkKoba
Dwlee99
Gamma Emerald
Not Known 15
Roden
humaneatingmonkey

When have we ever played together?

In post 202, tictac wrote:^not super constuctive
@nk it's not 1 scum+ 1 traitor. that would make the scumteam weaker than standard 4 9p, so wildly unbalanced.

I have been pushing people for what were simple grammar mistakes, so ok. However, if a traitor flips and no other mafia and you reach 3p exlo/4p mxlo with koba you know what to do

I don’t think traitor + solo scum would pass review due to violating the idea of “mafia being informed minority”

In post 207, Not Known 15 wrote:VOTE: Guilty Lion

are you going to respond to my questions to you in 83?

In post 114, tictac wrote:

In post 72, humaneatingmonkey wrote:marcistar is so kawaii

In post 73, humaneatingmonkey wrote:that's a valid read into the game

I'm a bit confused by these two posts - are you saying you think marci is town but you disagree with the reasons I gave? or do you not townread marci?

ah, I missed a quote, I meant to also quote tictac's 105 where he disagrees with me on a marci TR

In post 134, humaneatingmonkey wrote:i dont know if GuiltyLion is the type of scum who would back off a public scumread who is gaining steam after some behind-the-curtain assessment that it's just Dwlee's personality

I would absolutely do this as scum, just so you know

In post 176, humaneatingmonkey wrote:you're insistent that your reads aren't a bit disingenuous (which you would have admitted by now if you were town) when they ARE disingenuous

1) what is the idea that koba would have already admitted disingenuous reads by now (the parenthetical in the quote) based on? is that past experience with koba?

2) I don't really think Koba's reads are disingenuous. I know you've explained why you think they are, but I disagree, they make sense to me

I think like, tictac, marci, gamma are all town

koba probtown, town enough for the moment and prob D1

I do think it's very likely there's a scum in at least one of the hoods so I'm down with either Dwlee or NK15 wagons atm though I would like NK15 to actually engage with me so I can better suss out the degree to which he believes what he's pushing

In post 210, GuiltyLion wrote:

In post 114, tictac wrote:

In post 72, humaneatingmonkey wrote:marcistar is so kawaii

In post 73, humaneatingmonkey wrote:that's a valid read into the game

I'm a bit confused by these two posts - are you saying you think marci is town but you disagree with the reasons I gave? or do you not townread marci?

kawaii isn't the same as town.
i actually questioned whether marci was genuine in asking 4 help managing neighborhoods, since she's not totally new and having a neighbor of unknown align isn't really different from having other folks here also of unknown align. these "too newbish" reads have kinda horrible accuracy tho, and tonewise she seems towny.. soo lots of words to say "i don't have a read there yet" and "u pointed the most scumish post she has as a reason 4 a townread"

In post 214, GuiltyLion wrote:I think like, tictac, marci, gamma are all town

koba probtown, town enough for the moment and prob D1

I do think it's very likely there's a scum in at least one of the hoods so I'm down with either Dwlee or NK15 wagons atm though I would like NK15 to actually engage with me so I can better suss out the degree to which he believes what he's pushing

why am i below tictac and gamma?

eh actually on second thought I shouldn't have tictac as particularly strong town given I don't really know what their scum range is, I mostly just liked their approach to HEM. Gamma I think is vibing more like his towngame so far given my experience with him.

main thing with you is you're in a hood + I don't think you're out of scum range at all despite me liking what you've had to say so far

what does the hood have to do with anything?

hoods are the most NAI thing and if you think you can setup game an RC setup you're trolling.

I believe there is at least one scum in a hood, I said that already

based on what?

call it a hunch

no no

why do you think there *has* to be scum in a hood?

I think there's scum in a hood because I scumread people who are in hood.

why do you think there has to be?

I'm not going to answer that beyond what I've already stated

if I start advocating to chain eliminate every player in a hood I'll offer more reasoning then

you have never played with me in a closed game, so you should know that I am a vehemently against lumping mechplay with dayplay and strictly forcing people to make reads off dayplay.

the only exception being if there is a flipped cop with reports on alive players.