Mafiascum.net

In post 194, marcistar wrote:what we've gotta do is force everybody to get some readslists going before either of the 2 games left get filled i think

would that be helpful i feel like it would be

Are you asking for a….rainbow reads list?

yeah kinda if u wanna do dat ig, but not like super rn but i think before the rest of the ppl pick their games would be good right?

like we want the scum in the mafia discussion to have hella associations since that game will prob resolve first right?
otherwise they might just focus on being distracting i feel

we actually shouldnt give reads and help scum figure out swaps

lets get this show on the road

Rainbow Reads tomorrow. Got it.

I think that me, pooky, and penguin in particular should not be talking about reads anymore

Other people might need to a little bit to figure out games / who they would want to be with

I think I would like Faker in mafia discussion?

And I think they said that that is the one they want anyways

i want meuh to join sgb

if im right about m&m being s/s one of them has to get swapped out

as a bonus it will mean theres no way scum can rescue luke from me

In post 204, Lukewarm wrote:I think that me, pooky, and penguin in particular should not be talking about reads anymore

Other people might need to a little bit to figure out games / who they would want to be with

i will not be silenced

In post 202, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:we actually shouldnt give reads and help scum figure out swaps

lets get this show on the road

So its only bad when i type it out? lmao

In post 206, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:i want meuh to join sgb

if im right about m&m being s/s one of them has to get swapped out

You’re not
Which is why I wanna stack townies in MD.
Then scum has more limited options and day 2 becomes simpler

I feel very, very good about marcistar being town after the read on Lukewarm. I shared it, and it was part of why I heavily considered biting the bullet on Sillyposting. I also felt like I could win us that minigame if that was the 3, even if my initial read were wrong and I might not have fun doing it. Counterfactuals are easy since I never have to back it up. I also was going to make a marked attempt to have a more optimistic viewpoint on it.

Some people like to sit here all day and coordinate Day 1 but I really wanted a more mild discussion and some initial thoughts on which minigame, why, and if people had strong meta feelings about how we should sort. It doesn't look like anyone has any objections to me going MD, but I'll give it another chance. I think Dragons going into SGB works over RH9/Meuh, but I do worry about the difficulty of that game.

Pooky, do you realize that your reads are : Everyone who posted on page 1 is scum?

I haven't seen Meuh's scumgame in awhile but 210 on the surface looks quite good IMO.

It's mostly tone which is probably not worth putting stock in, but the confidence is nice to see.

In post 213, Faker wrote:I haven't seen Meuh's scumgame in awhile but 210 on the surface looks quite good IMO.

It's mostly tone which is probably not worth putting stock in, but the confidence is nice to see.

Have you even ever seen my scumgame? I don’t think you’ve played with scum!me before

Thinking about it, MD isn't really my strongsuit. I'm actually very, very bad at direct 1v1s without immense effort. I mostly view alignments and perspective as interchangeable, and with no real hunting or puzzle left to do in that game it is difficult for me to pretend to care that I am sincere or genuine.

For Meuh, I skimmed it as part of Signs; a tenuous meta argument was the crux of my townread on you that game.

215 is not to say I suddenly want to go SGB. I'm just spitballing.

In post 211, Faker wrote:I feel very, very good about marcistar being town after the read on Lukewarm. I shared it, and it was part of why I heavily considered biting the bullet on Sillyposting.

This was enough for you to feel "very, very good about marcistar being town?

In post 190, marcistar wrote:
112 i kinda lowkey like

In post 199, marcistar wrote:i like luke

Yes. It is a shame you cannot punish the read tomorrow in the minigame; maybe they will be kind enough to swap me back.

Ohhh that makes sense!
I think that scumgame I actually played pretty okay and then I slipped I was mason hunting and got flashwagoned
My more recent scumgame was more of a slow and tedious descent into a loss

In post 212, Lukewarm wrote:Pooky, do you realize that your reads are : Everyone who posted on page 1 is scum?

I noticed this too, but why does it matter at all

Pooky, you were noticeably silent in voicing any thoughts on what game I should go in. Did you have any thoughts on it, even before Sillyposting filled?

In post 218, Faker wrote:Yes. It is a shame you cannot punish the read tomorrow in the minigame; maybe they will be kind enough to swap me back.

I am looking at this post, but I cannot parse it out.

What would it mean for me to "punish the read" in this context?

And the read on me, or the read on marci?

Swap you back where?

I feel like I have missed a couple of steps of your logic here

It's me being cheeky about being in separate minigames, and thus relying on others to vote correctly in the event I am scum.

To answer directly, the read on marcistar (which you, Lukewarm, seemed to take issue with) and swap me to Sillyposting.

In post 83, marcistar wrote:what is there that i should be using to solve right now? its page 4 and not even everyone has checked in..

I solved