Mafiascum.net

I like Fennec's approach so far, they seem open and townie.

I’m open to voting Charloux or Claire rn

In post 200, MalcolmTucker wrote:I like Fennec's approach so far, they seem open and townie.

I don't see whats townie about constantly saying that I'm not answering these mysterious questions. He keeps sniping at me from a safe distance.

In post 191, Cape90 wrote:I know a person who plays like this as town

I think most people are ready and willing to call bunk on a shitty read.

I know that he mostly reneged on his stance on me but I still think 183 is a mischaracterization and the closest I actually came to that is 153.

If the "case" on me is then I easily explain that away in 149 so his thing about me not using words and fennec's claim that I'm not answering questions is both false.

In post 152, Nero Cain wrote:What do you believe that I haven't answered?

Dude can't even face me, all he can do is repeat the same thing over and over

In post 151, Fennec wrote:I'm not seeing much answers from nero.

In post 193, Fennec wrote:Nero never answered the questions

good thing no one is fact checking

In post 16, Frogsterking wrote:Players I can read well:

Gamma Emerald -- Not sure where his head is at right now. Town?
Nero Cain -- Scum. Outside Townrange.
Greeting -- Not sure/maybe scum/instincts hope Town
KittyTacky -- Town
Crescent -- AWOL
PookyTheMagicalBear -- Maybe scum/maybe has a good read on Greeting

Updated.

I think marci, cape, sirrhett, charloux and fennec are town with certainty. I'm glad to see Fennec is voting Nero. I'm pushing certainty this is a scum flip.

Town:

• Gamma
  Kitty
  Marci
  Cape
  Sirrhet
  Charloux
  Fennec

Scum:

• Nero

If Crescent is Town I suggest they demonstrate that by using my PoE as a starting point and showing where they can improve on the sorting.

In post 201, Gamma Emerald wrote:I’m open to voting Charloux or Claire rn

What?

In post 184, MariaR wrote:

In post 120, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 119, MariaR wrote:Not much, I suppose the conversation about Nero was the most interesting thing said in the thread so far besides the busywork questions.

Why, who and where?

Why: Because it was the closest thing to anything revealing said in my eyes but I understand people TR things easier than I do.
Who: Between Nero and Cape
Where: 49-54

In post 122, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 120, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 119, MariaR wrote:Not much, I suppose the conversation about Nero was the most interesting thing said in the thread so far besides the busywork questions.

Why, who and where?

Fourth question: what do you predict marci's rationale will be for their suspicion on MalcolmTucker?

I didn't read on so I still don't know but I also don't really care or see the point on such speculation unless this was a trap question

In post 185, MariaR wrote:Gamma/Nero can get votes no opinion on other people

Maria, can you post a reads list?

In post 166, Greeting wrote:

In post 156, Cape90 wrote:Oh Greeting was asking me how I was and then I never answered.

I am fine :p

Glad to hear that! I like your new avi.

Oh no.

In post 205, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 201, Gamma Emerald wrote:I’m open to voting Charloux or Claire rn

What?

If you’re referring to me saying Claire, that’s what I call MariaR since she has/had multiple public alts she would use in conjunction. I didn’t shift into calling her that exclusively until recently though.

In post 206, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 184, MariaR wrote:

In post 120, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 119, MariaR wrote:Not much, I suppose the conversation about Nero was the most interesting thing said in the thread so far besides the busywork questions.

Why, who and where?

Why: Because it was the closest thing to anything revealing said in my eyes but I understand people TR things easier than I do.
Who: Between Nero and Cape
Where: 49-54

In post 122, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 120, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 119, MariaR wrote:Not much, I suppose the conversation about Nero was the most interesting thing said in the thread so far besides the busywork questions.

Why, who and where?

Fourth question: what do you predict marci's rationale will be for their suspicion on MalcolmTucker?

I didn't read on so I still don't know but I also don't really care or see the point on such speculation unless this was a trap question

In post 185, MariaR wrote:Gamma/Nero can get votes no opinion on other people

Maria, can you post a reads list?

She just said she had no other reads, are you fr?

Of course y’all are just going to assume that I was pocketing , I can’t just say I like his avi anymore.

In post 208, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 205, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 201, Gamma Emerald wrote:I’m open to voting Charloux or Claire rn

What?

If you’re referring to me saying Claire, that’s what I call MariaR since she has/had multiple public alts she would use in conjunction. I didn’t shift into calling her that exclusively until recently though.

Okay. Thank you for explaining.

In post 209, Gamma Emerald wrote:She just said she had no other reads, are you fr?

I didn't realize how recent that was. My question stands anyway I guess but I realize it's kind of stupid now. Do you have any thoughts on her play so far?

In post 210, Greeting wrote:Of course y’all are just going to assume that I was pocketing

Cape90

, I can’t just say I like his avi anymore.

Greeting is exiting their Town range.

In post 212, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 210, Greeting wrote:Of course y’all are just going to assume that I was pocketing

Cape90

, I can’t just say I like his avi anymore.

Greeting is exiting their Town range.

Legitimately never seen Greeting as scum but thinking this might be it fr unfortunately.

Like I am not feeling that they are being as helpful as I know they can be

In post 204, Frogsterking wrote:Town:

Gamma
Kitty
Marci
Cape
Sirrhet
Charloux
Fennec

Scum:

Nero

How certain are you on you Kitty read?

In post 214, Cape90 wrote:

In post 204, Frogsterking wrote:Town:

Gamma
Kitty
Marci
Cape
Sirrhet
Charloux
Fennec

Scum:

Nero

How certain are you on you Kitty read?

Never mind, I see the quote above but why? What makes Kitty out of their scum range right now?

In post 149, Nero Cain wrote:chummy to who? Also, there were no extra votes or pressure between my 80 and 84 so your "testing the waters" theory doesn't hold WATER.

also I will just say I wasn't necessarily referring to that. But it does fall apart when instead of not going anywhere after this, you basically immediately target me

Eh, the Greeting voters are a little sketch even if I am still not opposed there. For instance

VOTE: Toogeloo

I think Maria is town

In post 215, Cape90 wrote:

In post 214, Cape90 wrote:

In post 204, Frogsterking wrote:Town:

Gamma
Kitty
Marci
Cape
Sirrhet
Charloux
Fennec

Scum:

Nero

How certain are you on you Kitty read?

Never mind, I see the quote above but why? What makes Kitty out of their scum range right now?

Good question, let me check.

In post 213, Cape90 wrote:

In post 212, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 210, Greeting wrote:Of course y’all are just going to assume that I was pocketing

Cape90

, I can’t just say I like his avi anymore.

Greeting is exiting their Town range.

Legitimately never seen Greeting as scum but thinking this might be it fr unfortunately.

Like I am not feeling that they are being as helpful as I know they can be

I have played against it before and they got rekt on D2 but their team went on to win the game. I read the scum chat after the game and it seemed like Greeting was very active in the PT and tried to carry by helping their team play better. If this is scum!Greeting expect them to be suspiciously absent for a while (coaching/planning in the PT) then make a bunch of dramatic, townie looking posts which fool the newer players.

PEdit

What about Maria do you like? Toogle isn't a player I've had great success reading in the past, though usually when I see someone do the double vote thing they're Town.

In post 211, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 208, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 205, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 201, Gamma Emerald wrote:I’m open to voting Charloux or Claire rn

What?

If you’re referring to me saying Claire, that’s what I call MariaR since she has/had multiple public alts she would use in conjunction. I didn’t shift into calling her that exclusively until recently though.

Okay. Thank you for explaining.

In post 209, Gamma Emerald wrote:She just said she had no other reads, are you fr?

I didn't realize how recent that was. My question stands anyway I guess but I realize it's kind of stupid now. Do you have any thoughts on her play so far?

Very lackluster

In post 212, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 210, Greeting wrote:Of course y’all are just going to assume that I was pocketing

Cape90

, I can’t just say I like his avi anymore.

Greeting is exiting their Town range.

Press X to doubt

In post 219, Gamma Emerald wrote:Press X to doubt

On my statement or on Greeting's alignment?

In post 215, Cape90 wrote:Never mind, I see the quote above but why? What makes Kitty out of their scum range right now?

IDK I guess it's purely an intuition read. Sorry. Do you have any experience with scum!kitty?

I really think Gamma is Town now. This is reminding me of town!Gamma from TFT where it felt like they were omnipresent to answer questions and help improve the PoE I was building with a constant supply of tone reads and meta reads.

In post 218, Frogsterking wrote:If this is scum!Greeting expect them to be suspiciously absent for a while (coaching/planning in the PT)

then make a bunch of dramatic, townie looking posts which fool the newer players.

Haven't really seen this second part at all so far.

In post 218, Frogsterking wrote:What about Maria do you like? Toogle isn't a player I've had great success reading in the past, though usually when I see someone do the double vote thing they're Town.

As for most people, would love to see more content this game from them. I kinda get this towny bluntness vibe from Maria. I believe if Maria were scum, in 119 they probably would have just gave reads. I think Maria has been oddly cryptic in general so far, even with the 4 posts they have.

Okay, I am unfamiliar with this whole double vote thing, never really seen it but I will see what Toogle does, never played with Toogle

In post 221, Frogsterking wrote:IDK I guess it's purely an intuition read. Sorry. Do you have any experience with scum!kitty?

I have not played with him.

I just don't see anything that is all that AI in his posts. Only thing is a Fennec town read really

In post 222, Cape90 wrote:I kinda get this towny bluntness vibe from Maria. I believe if Maria were scum, in 119 they probably would have just gave reads.

Interesting. I was wondering about that.

In post 223, Cape90 wrote:

In post 221, Frogsterking wrote:IDK I guess it's purely an intuition read. Sorry. Do you have any experience with scum!kitty?

I have not played with him.

I just don't see anything that is all that AI in his posts. Only thing is a Fennec town read really

He seems to rely purely on intuition for sorting and doesn't always have a lot of reads. I guess I'd expect him to be more afraid to post in the thread if he were scum. What he posted so far looks like he is posting stream of conscious style almost and his thoughts check out with what I expect from Town!kitty. If he is scum attempting to impersonate his town meta then I can't see any difference yet.

In post 222, Cape90 wrote:Haven't really seen this second part at all so far.

I'd expect it sometime past the D1 halfway point.