Townread on pie is not strong; it's more that the pie wagon happened after a relatively town post.
I don't at all understand how reading someone town could be an insult to them regardless of their alignment (that means you think they're doing well regardless of their alignment), but lynching Waffles before tomorrow at the very earliest is dumb, anyway.
Cheery I thought was actually kinda town after he started responding to mollie? Only in exactly one of the posts, though.
Eagle is someone I have no town impressions from whatsoever.
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 4:21 am
by Fate
eagle.gives me the impression they don't want to be read as town
Cheery is trying too hard at it
aka Cheerys scum lets go Gamma dont be a Nuwen
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 4:22 am
by Fate
speaking of nuwen shes gonna be mislynched real hard after Im dead huh
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 4:33 am
by Gammagooey
In post 2002, Fate wrote:speaking of nuwen shes gonna be mislynched real hard after Im dead huh
i mean she could just get shot instead and I still think she's a pretty decent lynch but yeah she's not gonna be living too long into this game it looks like
cheery can get shrugmurdered i guess
Vote:Cheery Dog
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 6:10 am
by A Simple Math Problem
Happy green shirt Thursday ^^.
Deadline: April 3rd @ 3PM Commune Time
Gay Aliens are V/LA until Sunday
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 9:08 am
by Ythan
hm maybe
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 9:18 am
by Ythan
VOTE: Cheery Dog
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 9:27 am
by Fate
Well that's just about it for town cred on the wagon.
Waffles want to bus?
Not Voting (1) Sir Waffles Wafflington
Oo.....
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 9:27 am
by Fate
I guess I kinda just glossed over the fact that throughout this ENTIRE back and forth and shit Waffles hasn't even pretended to want to push a wagon
its almost like they are hyper self-conscious of their votes
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 9:36 am
by Gammagooey
^see you say that and it's like my brain just lights up with a big neon sign that has NUWEN on it instead
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 10:56 am
by Sir Waffles Wafflington
In post 2000, Iecerint wrote:
I don't at all understand how reading someone town could be an insult to them regardless of their alignment (that means you think they're doing well regardless of their alignment), but lynching Waffles before tomorrow at the very earliest is dumb, anyway.
I think what mina means is that if it were anyone else, she would think UT was scum because he has some really weird stances and some weird play that doesn't make a whole lot of sense for town. HOWEVER, even though he looks scummy, this doesn't look anything like how she's seen him as scum. I think that's what she means anyway.
~~~~~~~
I'm not convinced that Cheery Dog is scum. I think Cheery has a tendency to just look scummy. I don't really know who I think the scum are. What I do think is that scum are hiding in/behind the back and forths that have encompassed us/fate/ythan/mollie/ut/reck. I don't even know if I think everyone in that group is town or if there's scum there. My point and suspicion about Ythan comes partly on his claim and partly on his reaction to our claim. The way he keeps responding to things with "good point" demonstrate that he didn't actually read the interactions we've had or mina's claim. So, his post of "if they didn't want to be vigged did they even think about the scum kill?" was odd and looked like him just throwing up crap to throw up crap because if he'd read the claim, which Mina laid out really really clearly, he'd know that we did add that caveat. And if he'd read Mina's post in which she said, if you vig us tonight, ignore our crumb because we don't want to frame someone post mortem. I just don't understand how he's responding to the things he's responding to and asking the questions he is if he hasn't bothered to read the claim. Mina thinks he's definitely town though, so whatever. I think the remaining people in that group that we agree on is that mollie and ut are probably town. I keep going back and forth on mollie but her most recent posts look like she's thinking about and looking at the game as a whole which was what I thought was missing before. Anyway scum are probably in the shadows but I don't even know who they are. I don't like that eaglekit has dropped off the face of the earth, but I still think desperado's early push on mollie looked like he had something and mala's trying to get mollie and I to get along looked townish too, so IDK.
~~~~~~~~
Why didn't someone tell me about Cadbury Caramel Eggs? Because holy shit these things are amazing.
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 11:26 am
by Untrod Tripod
In post 2009, Gammagooey wrote:^see you say that and it's like my brain just lights up with a big neon sign that has NUWEN on it instead
nuwen had reads and votes
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 1:36 pm
by pirate mollie
In post 1874, Malakittens wrote:So ehm I managed to forget the eagle kit password and since I'm phone posting it doesn't save and I moved my email to desp somewhere with the password. When I'm home ill quote this on my hydra (sorry!). Also I'm convinced I have too many hydras because I'm forgetting passwords left and right.
@Mollie: what exactly put us back to scum read? Was it me agreeing with Desperado about his scum read on you?
Also you do have a good point about CD.
Something feels off about him over the last two games I played with him.
I need to pinpoint that more than gut at this point.
@Gamma: want to explain that because its like wtf. You don't like the wagons okay, but do you know your vote on us is just a singleton and you aren't really doing much to push us. It's looks like a scum placing a safe vote, tbh.
I was trying to find this in your iso and didn't see it and then realised you never followed up on quoting from your hydra. it happens
BUT
wrt the bold: can you plz link the last 2 games you played with him where he seemed odd? and what seemed odd about him? as oppsosed to before when you played with him? can you link those games too?
@ axxle
In post 1866, Axxle wrote:Your case reads so much more like town with blinders on than scum.
you said this to cheery. so can you plz clarify what moved you to do this, s'il vous plaît:
In post 2009, Gammagooey wrote:^see you say that and it's like my brain just lights up with a big neon sign that has NUWEN on it instead
nuwen had reads and votes
yep.
@ iceyrent
is it only cheery's pushback that makes him seem town? also pie is not a strong townread so how does he compare to cheerio.
I am just trying to get a grasp of how you are working this out and ty for discussing reads it is a relief
are you still reading ut as scum?
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 1:54 pm
by Axxle
I was referring to you. That his evidence for you being 'scum' sounded more like evidence for you being 'town with blinders on'.
Posted: Thu Mar 20, 2014 5:38 pm
by Ythan
The fact that you're still entertaining the idea that I'm a scum dayvig looks really illogical. Because that's an illogical thing to think. But this is not news!
In post 1854, pirate mollie wrote:
so then why didn't you bring it up on d1 when I was speculating about it instead of when it was brought up by other people? it isn't just the wc it is the general tone of the game too. and it isn't like you are questioning me about it it just seems like you tried to unobtrusively park a vote in there hoping to blend in in all of the cacophony.
would you like links to where I brought up multi-ball speculation on d1 and wow omg there was multi-ball? this feels a bit different and I was trying to work it out that mebbe it was indie heavy or something.
anyways in those games do you wanna know who went all "omg she said multi-ball!" they were scum cos scum focus on minor things like that instead of having to do the legwork in order to determine some1's alignment.
Day 1 had multiball as more of a possibility. At that stage you'd only mentioned it because of your role pm, as far as I remember reading it, today you went and mentioned your win condition as the cause. We had also had night flips now and vig claims (also a non-entity for scumkills besides the doctor part of the claim), and I wanted to know more. I think I was also partly ignoring you yesterday.
Also I haven't read any of those games I linked besides checking you were in there somewhere and the town's win conditions. (I was going to have a look at your posts, but considering most of them were micros, a category which has had a total of 4 multiball games run in it, (unless there have been some I'm unaware of), only one of these wasn't publicly multiball (also not run by me), I decided it was pointless searching when it's clearly that obvious)
In post 1855, pirate mollie wrote:I also would like to clarify something, so you think that nuwen and I are in lockstep as a scumteam and that somehow no1 would notice cos this would be optimal play as scum cos of...how?
I don't know why your scumteam operates in the way you're operating, it may not even be how you want to do it, but it's what is happening. In my opinion the optimal strategy for scum should be to just claim so they don't have to stress themselves out about trying to avoid the lynch. (see Triforce's claim, even though a survivor isn't scum, but can win with them).
In post 1859, Cheery Dog wrote:Here I'll quote where my scumread of mollie started today. Happy? (so much effort to go through the iso of someone that's posting under the radar or whatever people are calling it with me having less posts than other people)
In post 1269, Cheery Dog wrote:Having someone as town doesn't mean that they should just be ignored when scumming up the place.
