Mafiascum.net

In post 1987, Ankamius wrote:How is urist obvtown

He's not, I was being rethorical 'cause Nancy said she would only pair with him if he gets obvtown and I think that's not even possible. But I do think Urist is town by tone and by meta. You're all right saying he hasn't played well, but that doesn't make him scum.

In post 1985, Pink Ball wrote:Urist is obvtown tho. But RC is your best match, I read your cards and he's in your not so distant future

Why is RC my best match?

So do you believe only one of me and Pink is scum?

In post 1999, PvtUrist wrote:Dann's posts continues to ping scum to me.

I wish you could put your reasoning into words so I could engage with you on this

In post 1994, Taly wrote:i dont like to have my audience wait.

be still my beating heart

In post 1998, PvtUrist wrote:

In post 1995, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 1991, PvtUrist wrote:#1265 #1814 posts of DT that felt genuine.

It's nothing solid, and again consists of 1) seems genuine, and 2) no scum pings yet.

Besides, DT doesn't add up into my {PB, Dann, Moment} scum team theory.

Ah, I see you've taken the tinfoil hat road by thinking my interactions with Dann are svs. Welcome to the club. I'm pairing with Dann as soon as he has the guts to invite me to dance, do you think that would be wise coming from an svs?

PB!Dann SvS interaction? Suppose I missed that.

No, you and Dann and scumreads for different, non SvS interaction reasons.

Dude we are like... The hottest couple in the thread, we have been throwing hints to eachother for a long time.

Why are you scumreading me? That's lame sauce

In post 1988, PvtUrist wrote:I'm not expecting to make it into the last 6, take that as you will.

{Krazy, Taly, Anka, ND39, Allo, Gamma, Vedith, DT, Brie}
{Alisae, FB, Dr.W, RC}
{PB, Dann, Moment}

are where I'm at.

Why are PB and especially Dann so low?

In post 1664, Moment wrote:Page 9.

I gut townread Allomancer.

I'm right around where you're calling Dannflor scum for "wooden posting" and weak setup-spec and other such reasons. I myself find this fairly towny:

In post 211, Dannflor wrote:A lot of people are posting a lot, very few people have said anything of value.

Vedith’s self preservation is town, also

In my experience, scum in this situation goes for fabricating some uncontroversial read to talk about rather than both declaring that nothing much of value has been said yet and making a completely out of left field townread on someone being scumread.

Moment's post on whitewashing Dann.

In post 1846, Dannflor wrote:If she ends up going through to the dance, she'll probably face pressure in general and for what changed her mind. That's not a risk mafia generally wants to take.

I think this is the only thing Dann said so far that particularly pinged me, and there I was more thinking it was possibly just shoddy reasoning. idk, Ank what did you think of this post? Was Dann possibly trying to pocket you?

In post 2006, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:

In post 1988, PvtUrist wrote:I'm not expecting to make it into the last 6, take that as you will.

{Krazy, Taly, Anka, ND39, Allo, Gamma, Vedith, DT, Brie}
{Alisae, FB, Dr.W, RC}
{PB, Dann, Moment}

are where I'm at.

Why are PB and especially Dann so low?

They're scum reads.
PB for gut/tone-read,
Dann as explained, and
Moment as above.

The list of players currently already townread is also a factor.

In post 2007, PvtUrist wrote:Moment's post on whitewashing Dann.

tbh I'd kinda like to wait for Moment to do more before overly nuking his like three posts with content, even though I know I did already kinda have a surprised reaction to his point about Nancy's mech talk

I'm coming around to Dr Worm town btw

I think the only thing you could potentially scum read him for is (maybe?) trying to antagonize Nancy, but I think he's moved on from purposefully doing that. I agree with Krazy that his line of thinking regarding the IC and making it to the 2nd dance is towny. Additionally, the scum reads against him feel automatic and lazy which makes me think he's mislynch material

In post 2001, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:

In post 1985, Pink Ball wrote:Urist is obvtown tho. But RC is your best match, I read your cards and he's in your not so distant future

Why is RC my best match?

From my point of view, because you're one of my biggest townreads and I want RC paired with town. Because of his reputation, people will WIFOM him whenever they get the chance, so it's better having him with someone difficult to lynch. If RC is scum, I trust in your ability to catch him in your exclusive PT since you're good at reading players' intentions and you're not easily pocketed.

In post 1991, PvtUrist wrote:#1265 #1814 posts of DT that felt genuine.

It's nothing solid, and again consists of 1) seems genuine, and 2) no scum pings yet.

Besides, DT doesn't add up into my {PB, Dann, Moment} scum team theory.

I’m not sure I agree with your PB/Dann/Moment scumteam but yeah I can see why you’re townreading DT, based on those posts. Like Dann is one of my strongest top town gents here.

In post 2008, Krazy wrote:

In post 1846, Dannflor wrote:If she ends up going through to the dance, she'll probably face pressure in general and for what changed her mind. That's not a risk mafia generally wants to take.

I think this is the only thing Dann said so far that particularly pinged me, and there I was more thinking it was possibly just shoddy reasoning. idk, Ank what did you think of this post? Was Dann possibly trying to pocket you?

I'm not sure why exactly anyone would want to pocket me at that point

In post 2009, PvtUrist wrote:

In post 2006, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:

In post 1988, PvtUrist wrote:I'm not expecting to make it into the last 6, take that as you will.

{Krazy, Taly, Anka, ND39, Allo, Gamma, Vedith, DT, Brie}
{Alisae, FB, Dr.W, RC}
{PB, Dann, Moment}

are where I'm at.

Why are PB and especially Dann so low?

They're scum reads.
PB for gut/tone-read,
Dann as explained, and
Moment as above.

The list of players currently already townread is also a factor.

Don't be lazy. Have you read any game with me in it in order to scum toneread me? And gut why? You're just not giving a chance to reply to your read on me

In post 2014, Ankamius wrote:I'm not sure why exactly anyone would want to pocket me at that point

fair, I guess. can we eliminate white knighting or you think he was being genuine?

In post 1992, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 1986, Taly wrote:

PB

, humor me, who is my best match?

Krazy

In post 1995, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 1991, PvtUrist wrote:#1265 #1814 posts of DT that felt genuine.

It's nothing solid, and again consists of 1) seems genuine, and 2) no scum pings yet.

Besides, DT doesn't add up into my {PB, Dann, Moment} scum team theory.

Ah, I see you've taken the tinfoil hat road by thinking my interactions with Dann are svs. Welcome to the club. I'm pairing with Dann as soon as he has the guts to invite me to dance, do you think that would be wise coming from an svs?

RC doesn’t even intend to ask me and i think I should be paired with either Dan or Krazy. I would not be opposed to any of those 3, however.

In post 2008, Krazy wrote:

In post 1846, Dannflor wrote:If she ends up going through to the dance, she'll probably face pressure in general and for what changed her mind. That's not a risk mafia generally wants to take.

I think this is the only thing Dann said so far that particularly pinged me, and there I was more thinking it was possibly just shoddy reasoning.

I know this isn't directed at me, but why do you think it's shoddy? It's not a super strong point for town!Ank but I think it makes it more likely than not

In post 2009, PvtUrist wrote: Dann as explained

You haven't

In post 1994, Taly wrote:lol it is mathematically guaranteed that scum is townreading me at this point

*carries on with readslist*

but yeah

PB

, could you answer my prompt to you in my last post soon? ty

p-edit

oh, ty

PB

*carries on with readslist again*

im gonna stfu until its posted, or unless someone directly squares up to me

i plan to have it sent tonight, tomorrow morning at very most. i dont like to have my audience wait.

Taly is such a diva and I mean that in absolutely the best way possible.

<3

In post 1997, Dannflor wrote:

In post 1951, Allomancer wrote:well me, pvt, and dt are all town so there's that

yo maybe this is the scum team

That isn’t possible. They can’t all be all gents or all ladies. I’m assuming that since we have 9 gents to 8 ladies, probably 2 gents and 1 lady?

In post 2017, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:

In post 1992, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 1986, Taly wrote:

PB

, humor me, who is my best match?

Krazy

In post 1995, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 1991, PvtUrist wrote:#1265 #1814 posts of DT that felt genuine.

It's nothing solid, and again consists of 1) seems genuine, and 2) no scum pings yet.

Besides, DT doesn't add up into my {PB, Dann, Moment} scum team theory.

Ah, I see you've taken the tinfoil hat road by thinking my interactions with Dann are svs. Welcome to the club. I'm pairing with Dann as soon as he has the guts to invite me to dance, do you think that would be wise coming from an svs?

RC doesn’t even intend to ask me and i think I should be paired with either Dan or Krazy. I would not be opposed to any of those 3, however.

RC said that the mechanically correct pairing for him was you, so I think there's intention. And you keep implying Dann or Krazy who I don't think either has intended to pair with you since Krazy already invited Taly and he's waiting that reply, and Dann is, in all seriousness, my best pairing, since we're not an obvtown pair and scum will likely push us and we could get some cool interactions out lf it. Also, as far as I know, he trusts me as mucho as I trust him

In post 2020, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:

In post 1997, Dannflor wrote:

In post 1951, Allomancer wrote:well me, pvt, and dt are all town so there's that

yo maybe this is the scum team

That isn’t possible. They can’t all be all gents or all ladies. I’m assuming that since we have 9 gents to 8 ladies, probably 2 gents and 1 lady?

That makes most sense. I have (and I think most people do) more gents lower than most of the ladies

In post 2018, Dannflor wrote:I know this isn't directed at me, but why do you think it's shoddy? It's not a super strong point for town!Ank but I think it makes it more likely than not

Feel like this is the same line of bogus reasoning that makes town incorrectly townread scum when they do things like self-voting, when scum I think self-votes way more frequently than town does (or at least under different circumstances)...

I agree on Ank Town, I just was worried you were trying to fabricate reasons for townreading Ank when you already know she's town. That being said it's not a strong ping and I still think you're town rn, just the first one I felt

In post 2010, Krazy wrote:

In post 2007, PvtUrist wrote:Moment's post on whitewashing Dann.

tbh I'd kinda like to wait for Moment to do more before overly nuking his like three posts with content, even though I know I did already kinda have a surprised reaction to his point about Nancy's mech talk

Especially since what you pointed out about BoR, where I also did plenty of that. This whole mech talk=scum, probably leads to more mislynches than anything. In Excalibur, VeridanCleric’s ISO was lkke 95% mech talk.