Mafiascum.net

execution

PookyTheMagicalBear [2]:

Klick, Deimos27

Klick [1]:

Dumb and Dumber

not voting [4]:

Alduskkel, DonCorleone, PookyTheMagicalBear, Wug

flavour

mod notes

• Datisi is V/LA until Sunday.

I can neither confirm nor deny.

Anyone else want to convince us that Pooky is the best firing today?

In post 1991, Klick wrote:Also

In post 1987, Dumb and Dumber wrote:I mildly townread Pooky's posting. I have seen Pooky deathtunnel before, I do not think that makes him scum.

This is a very reductive version of why Pooky is scum

OK, can you explain the non-reductive version, with a tldr?

As best as I can understand, your case basically boils down to pooky deathtunneling Clover, and we're trying to get a sense of what else is impacting your Pooky read.

- Dumber

In post 1989, Klick wrote:

In post 1988, Klick wrote:You're wrong; it's {1v3|1v4} going into the night, which nullifies the rest of your logic.

I read this wrong, sorry, 1v3/1v3 is correct

Also, why are we viable?

Do you think this is likely or just that there's nothing particularly ruling it out

-Dumber

Klick can you give a high-level summary of your progression on pooky throughout the game?
I think that would be really helpful.

- Dumber

just checking in

still alive somehow.

I think it's kind of suspicious how DnD is playing as if he already knows I'm going to flip as town and setting up for the 1v1 tommorrow - makes me lean towards Klick town and DnD scum ~ but the choice is going to be up to you guys.

DonC's vote here is pretty susp - if he really thinks I'm scum I don't think he puts me at L-1 this early in the day

Like we have 5 days to talk things over - pretty obvious at this point everyone except for DnD prefers a pooky lynch by a mile - there's no reason to rush things except to stop discussion prematurely.

In post 2006, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:I think it's kind of suspicious how DnD is playing as if he already knows I'm going to flip as town and setting up for the 1v1 tommorrow - makes me lean towards Klick town and DnD scum

We do not seem to be in a position where we would necessarily need to set up for a 1v1 tomorrow. The potential value of whatever additional preparation we may be doing would still be a lot lesser than the lost value in derailing the wagon on you.

Do you think the case on you is sound? Why do you townread Klick?

-Dumbass

Klick/Aldusskel is our very preliminary solve.
It's interesting to see that Aldusskel barely mentions Klick or engages with him in his first 50 posts (which I assume are before coalition) except for a light townread.

-Dumbass

It doesn't make sense for Klick-scum to defend Clover that hard and attack me for a lynch on D1 - I flip town and he is in a way shittier position D2. He's much better off getting a Clover lynch followed by me getting lynched.

In post 2009, Dumb and Dumber wrote:lost value in derailing the wagon on you.

Pretty sure it's impossible to derail the wagon on me

I have 3 votes on and 2 people who have signaled intent to hammer.

A Clover firing would have to be consistent with his previous stances. Also, i feel like you overestimate how shitty of a position it should leave someone in, and I also feel that people are generally overestimating how scummy it is to tunnel on town.

Well, perhaps the idea that I am scum posturing around your townflip shall derail it! DonCorleone, please unvote and engage with us.

-Dumbass

In post 2010, Dumb and Dumber wrote:Klick/Aldusskel is our very preliminary solve.
It's interesting to see that Aldusskel barely mentions Klick or engages with him in his first 50 posts (which I assume are before coalition) except for a light townread.

if Klick is scum - Aldus doesn't make sense as a partner - me flipping town would hurt Klick-scum - they'd rather have clover flip town yesterday.

UNVOTE:
There's more analysis I want to do but I'm busy till Sunday so will unvote for now

I mean, I could unvote, but I’d rather just lynch pooky

First we lynch pooky

If town, re-evaluate

If scum, lynch wug

it's easy to tell D&D hasn't read the game from how they're actually voting someone other than pooky

D&D if klick were confirmed town then what would your pick for the scumteam be?

Then surely it must be easier to describe the case on Pooky? What did we miss from not having read the game?

DC, why not re-evaluate today? We go into 3:2 FiLo if we choose wrong.

-Dumbass

FTR I think Pooky/D&D just became somewhat less likely because if that team NK's in-coalition it's to sacrifice Pooky and get the other coalition member hyper townread — and D&D is now trying to save Pooky.

Just saying I'd expect a bus here to lock in the D&D WIFOM protection with Wug/Aldus/DC on the chopping block.

Assuming scum!D&D this play makes a lot more sense as setting up Klick -> Pooky or Pooky -> Klick miseliminations.