Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[NoPowerOverMe]

The thing that bothers me is the way you are pushing the one scum theory.

Also, the way cat trusts user and is constantly looking to him for advice.

Also, I remember user doing some math awhile back(don't remember where it was) where he showed that 3 non town was the most mathematically likely scenario and that doesn't seem to be the case.

[MURDERCAT]

I cleared username from my pov

[NoPowerOverMe]

Yeah but from my point of view you're just as likely scum as town, if not more so.

[iamausername]

NPOM, go back and look at Murdercat's reaction to Herta's claim in 1707 and tell me how it ever comes from scum

[NoPowerOverMe]

It's called bussing. Mudercat is a smart coookie. Herta and Cat formulate Herta's claim in the scum PT as well as cat's response to make him look more town.

[iamausername]

ok, so did they already know that roles can be doubled up? and they asked the mod to support their planned fakeclaim, and the mod went along with it?

[iamausername]

or they didn't know, and they decided to find out in the game thread, in the middle of their fakeclaim

[MURDERCAT]

It's called bussing. Mudercat is a smart coookie. Herta and Cat formulate Herta's claim in the scum PT as well as cat's response to make him look more town.

Then I can't be scum with username, correct?

[MURDERCAT]

Like we can talk about my play but mechanically I think there are some pairings we need to talk about first and we need to determine what scenarios you are actually worried about. You think there might be 2 scum, which pairings do you think are possible?

[iamausername]

"we know there's another scum faction out there that could kill either one of us, but let's both claim the same role to guarantee that one of us gets executed today, unless it's possible for roles to double up in this setup, i don't know, is it? let's not check before we go ahead with this plan"

[iamausername]

"it'll make me look super town, hopefully the one person who hasn't claimed already is a doctor who can protect me from the mafia kill!"

[iamausername]

the perfect crime

[MURDERCAT]

Lol I mean yeah and also I'm probably not scum with you for trying to elim you all of D1

But I want NPOM to list every scenario he is actually concerned about and we can logically walk through the evidence for/against all of them

[iamausername]

Lol I mean yeah and also I'm probably not scum with you for trying to elim you all of D1

it's called bussing, murdercat

[NoPowerOverMe]

Yeah, because mafia isn't a game where people lie.

[MURDERCAT]

But I want NPOM to list every scenario he is actually concerned about and we can logically walk through the evidence for/against all of them

Please do this NPOM, the final call will be yours but you need to tell me what you want be to provide evidence for/against

[MURDERCAT]

it’s not hypothetically possible, it’s actually very likely

ok, who are they

echo too, NPOM please reinforce that echo should do this

[NoPowerOverMe]

I don't really have the time right now, I'm working a long shift tonight.

[MURDERCAT]

(expired on 2020-11-25 20:12:00) remain until day end

Plenty of time

[Primate]

The thing that bothers me is the way you are pushing the one scum theory.

Also, the way cat trusts user and is constantly looking to him for advice.

Also, I remember user doing some math awhile back(don't remember where it was) where he showed that 3 non town was the most mathematically likely scenario and that doesn't seem to be the case.

It was murdercat and the math was about number of nontown factions, not number of nontown. 3 nontown "factions" in this game stands a fair chance of being right (mafia/ww/survivor). The permutations you posted are 3/4 nontown factions.

Also loving the sarcasm being thrown around, ha.

[MURDERCAT]

It was murdercat and the math was about number of nontown factions, not number of nontown. 3 nontown "factions" in this game stands a fair chance of being right (mafia/ww/survivor).

Correct

[SirCakez]

Votecount 4.1

EchoVision (1) - iamausername

Not voting (4) - EchoVision, MURDERCAT, Primate, NoPowerOverMe

(expired on 2020-11-25 20:12:00) remain until day end

With 5 players alive, it takes 3 to reach a majority.

[NoPowerOverMe]

4 town/1 survivor - Possible, but not likely.
4 town/1 SK - More likely than above
3 town/1 scum/1 survivor - A good chance.
3 town/2 scum/1 survivor - Also a good chance.
3 town/2 scum/1 SK - Not a good chance


These are the possibilities as I see it with 3 and 4 being the most likely. Wouldn't be surprised with 2.

[NoPowerOverMe]

Sorry 4) should be 2/2/1 and 5 should be 2/2/1

[MURDERCAT]

I don't think SK is possible because ico died but it could be alien