Mafiascum.net

In post 1983, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:its v unlikely mena is scum and wanted to PL the most important scum role lol.

I'm assuming the scum know that FL is the recruiter because if they don't even have that piece of information I'm not sure this can be characterized as mafia game.

Fair point that Mena began D2 pushing for Ahsoka so i suppose it would only make sense that down the line he sides with clidd over Ahsoka

ABR has been consistently scummy in hood and prefered Mena of course.

Hopkirk read to me as forcing his vote on Mena a bit -- he characterized clidd v. FL as a 50/50 when in reality everyone on Ahsoka wanted Ahsoka, it wasn't just that we thought it was TvS, we thought it was Ahsoka. I also find it interesting he paranoias me, doesnt townread Kanna outside of Pooky's vouch, and also keeps Uncrowned in his scumpool. Additionally I'm unsure what he feels ties Mena to Ahsoka (Uncrowned is understandable enough i suppose).

Mena might be scum but I felt he was a tad townier than ABR in hood, dunno will have to see.

I do think it's 2 in these 3.

In post 1995, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:We don't really want to hit scum too early and let the last scum start nightkilling imo.

I believe i went thru this during night, basically if we hit scum today that means our Xylo has 3 players -- if we hit scum tomorrow instead, then it's a Mylo with 4. So either way it doesn't really matter, i dont believe we lose an elim.

In post 1996, Alisae wrote:I think the other 2 scum roles can kill.
If this was a nightless game that was not advertised as nightless I would be very surprised cause for scum to not have a kill and not advertise that honestly that doesn't sound fun to play.

It would be difficult to get players base on premise.

If that were true why wouldn't they kill last night? I do lean that they function the same way as FL since if they can kill that's BS imo considering we have two town lovers. We don't get very many miselims

the revealed scum PM shows that they gain a factional nightkill when they are reduced to 1 player - so its highly probable that's true on all of their role pms.

In post 2002, Morning Tweet wrote:If that were true why wouldn't they kill last night?

because they're unwell

In post 2003, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:the revealed scum PM shows that they gain a factional nightkill when they are reduced to 1 player - so its highly probable that's true on all of their role pms.

NO IUTS NOT POOKY


YOU DO NOT DESIGN A NIGHTLESS GAME AND NOT TELL YOUYR PLAYERS ITS NIGHTLESS POOKY WHAT THE FUCK

YOU DO NOT DESIGN A NIGHTLESS GAME AND NOT TELL YOUYR PLAYERS ITS NIGHTLESS POOKY WHAT THE FUCK

YOU DO NOT DESIGN A NIGHTLESS GAME AND NOT TELL YOUYR PLAYERS ITS NIGHTLESS POOKY WHAT THE FUCK

In post 1973, Ydrasse wrote:• You will gain a factional kill if you are the sole remaining mafia.

This line is probably in every mafia role pm.

NO STOP
YOU REALIZE HOW MUCH OF A DICK MOVE THAT IS

WHAT IF I MODDED SOME MYSTERY GAME WITH A MYSTERY THEME AND IT TURNS OUT SURPRISE IT WAS FLIPPLESS MOUNTAINOUS MULTIBALL AND NOT TOLD ANYONE

ITS TEH SAME FUCKING CONCEPT POOKY

I mean you can argue about whether it's right to do that but like it's pretty obvious from the revealed role and the lack of nightkills that this probably is the case here.

In post 2008, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 1973, Ydrasse wrote:• You will gain a factional kill if you are the sole remaining mafia.

This line is probably in every mafia role pm.

THAT DOES NOT MEAN THAT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE FOR THE 2 OTHER ROLES TO NIGHT KILL ITS JUST A SAFETY MEASURE LIKE THE FUCK

NO ITS NOT

See, no kill. Also, FL's partners assumedly didn't know them either.

Game is solved though. Flip mena, if town I use my one shot weak ability (not full claim) uncrowned or maybe ABR. If scum I potentially use it anyway depending on how sus I am. I wanted to flip menal first because I was leaning ahsoka over Clidd but felt like getrimg confirmation with my role. That's why I kept saying let's vote menal then I'll use assorted random actions on Clidd.

WHY WOULD HECTIC AND IRCHER REVIEW A GAME THATS NIGHTLESS AND NOT TELL YDRA TO ADVERTISE THAT ITS NIGHTLESS

LIKE WHAT THE FUCK

i never got the memo on that one

Not that I would ever design a nightless game, i wouldn't wish that on anyone

i dont really see what's stopping Ydrasse/Hectic from designing a secret nightless though especially when it goes so well with the finding lost lover sort of theme

I didn't say the other 2 roles can't nightkill

I said if any mafia members becomes the sole remaining mafia members, they will get to nightkill.

That just makes sense from a design perspective.

IF THATS ACTUALLY A THING THEN WHY WOULD YOU EVER JOIN A YDRA GAME LIKE EVER
WHY WOULD YOU WANT TO PLAY GAMES BY A MOD WHO WON'T TELL YOU "OH THIS GAME IS NIGHTLESS/MULTIBALL/FLIPLESS/WHATEVER"

LIKE WHY WOULD YOU NOT TELL YOUR PLAYERS THAT

Surprise mechanic

Also it's technically not nightless

In post 2015, Morning Tweet wrote:i dont really see what's stopping Ydrasse/Hectic from designing a secret nightless though especially when it goes so well with the finding lost lover sort of theme

REPUTATION?????????????????

I was less sure that ashokas role was fake than other people (hence less sure on Clidd/Ashoka) because the logic pooky used to justify ashoka's role being very unlikely also made my role very unlikely... which explains the whole no no thing.

I don't get why you're so annoyed Alisae.

In post 2019, Morning Tweet wrote:Also it's technically not nightless

IF UR SCUM AND U FIND OUT SURPRISE YOU DON'T HAVE A NIGHTKILL UNLESS SCUM DIES, THEN THAT IS NOT FUN TO PLAY. PERIOD. END OF CONVERSATION.

I kinda like this setup

the flavor is dope and romance is like my favorite theme and I will probably sign up for Ydra games in the future because this is like awesome.

Also I love being not nightkilled :>

I don't get why you are so upset upon finding out the bad guys don't have a gun

I'm kinda happy they don't have a gun lol