I'm going to start here considering I just did a quick skim, and none of these were in the 5 that I got any town pings from with the exception of maybe Battle Mage, but haven't read enough to consider my full thoughts there.
I saw the Titus shot, I don't necessarily think that was the best usage of it if you town read Mastina and liked their reads, it put a bullet to them. It could have put a bullet to a more inactive null slot, but I guess Mastina dying means the conf town + reads was always going to be enough to kill here, so this mixed in with Mastina's reads are likely somewhat correct. It was the beginning, so I believe that Mastina wasn't fully correct, but I feel she was on the right path.
Good comment by Sugar Cain. Bell is also someone I'm leaning scum on here within the 12 ish pages I've read. I'll keep doing my catchup, and let you guys know what I think later.
Fair warning, I'm not 100% understanding the mechanics, when I try to read it, it goes right over my head, ha. I imagine eventually it'll all just click, and I'll be like, got it. hoo ha.
Okay, I take back what I said about the Titus shot, I guess. It's a mechanics thing, I was looking at it from face value.
First comment I read by Oil - I saw Dunnstral was being pushed by Mastina, that's interesting. I thought that I would probably agree, but going further back, I actually specifically think Dunnstral is town, and I think this could be indicative of OilScum who saw that Dunnstral was townie, and decided to take that side of the fight. First real scum read.
Oil
.BATTLE MAGE. Finral is a support mage who assists literal Battlemages in fights. Mixed in with this post by Battle Mage, I am soul reading BM as town here. This fits in exactly how I believe Battle Mage town would act here. While I don't like the pronoun comment, I think the slot itself is town.
For what it's worth, I do town read Flea as well. I liked the way they interacted with me on my replace in, and from reading backwards, I am slightly town reading them.
I kind of also want to say "obviously, Super Bowl is scum", but I'm actually not confident in that read. I think it
makes sense
for them to be scum based on their positioning in the game during the Mastina wagon alongside not necessarily agreeing with their pushes, however, I feel there's a chance they are town. I will look more into this. Note that I do want to say they are scum, but I know that could be wrong.I generally want to town read Firebringer, but there's something about the way they're talking with Bell that makes me get associative pings from them. I'll go into this later on, unless I see more, but I've felt it a couple times. I was thinking originally FB/Mastina fight was just personal, and I believe it is personal, but I don't think that means they're necessarily the same alignment. There are certain things FB has done that I feel has appeared townie rather than is townie, like the revoting of Flea, which I don't think is at all impossible as scum. I don't think I would push here first today, though, never before pushing Bell either.
Guillo vs FB is interesting. I can see it being TvS. This is a note to myself to look deeper into both these slots. I've been indifferent with Guillo thus far.
OOoooooh. Another Oil post I don't like here Flea makes a comment, then Oil makes a comment moving from the current topic. Either way, I think this is Oil who likes the town push of Flea to Noraa as Noraa's partner, or Oil who dislikes the town push from Flea to Noraa, and wants to change subjects, and offer alternatives.
I'm most likely doing whatever the voting equivalent is to Oil because I believe they are scum here.
Would someone walk me through the phases/mechanics of this game?
I need it in a way where I don't space out while reading it.Parts of me think Kookiemonster/Guillo is fake, but I'll put a tinfoil hat on this one.
this. Everything Oil does is like "do this for me, push here for me." they're staying out of the spotlight, but actively effecting the game with posts like these.
If I had to take a shot in the dark guess of where I'm feeling right now, it would be
Oil, Kookiemonster, Firebringer
as the scum team. Guillo, Bell, and Superbowl are the 3 I want to look into more, and could probably replace into that likely incorrect full solve.I don't think Oil is town here ever, though.
