Mafiascum.net

In post 1732, Thor665 wrote:I note that your reasons for IaI dying included "unlynchable - that, in and of itself provides any scum a solid reason to kill IaI no matter who scum is, unless scum is IaI.

Not really... There's a lot of utility in having an unlynchable person who townreads you. Once town starts worrying about why that person is living for a long time,

then

you should be killing off unlynchable people. But for a first nightkill? An IaI kill comes from a team that wants me lynched, I think that's pretty simple.

I also would note, that if I go to your case and replace Blitz's name with Gerry, or Thor, or Karnos, et al - it doesn't actually change the validity of the case.
Do you disagree with the above?
If so - could you replace the name with Karnos and explain how the case doesn't work?

Of course I disagree... I don't get how you came to the conclusion that you and Gerry were actively trying to dismantle the bloc I've formed. Gerry has done nothing but sheep, and you townread me. Karnos I can see, but I felt at the time of writing that case that A: Titus was pushing the fact that both Maria and I were scum together more (i.e., that she believed that we both needed to die) while Karnos was more interested in just getting me lynched "to get information about Maria", and B: I think dismantling a townbloc is an objective scum!Titus would think of before scum!Karnos. It's not so much that it doesn't work with Karnos as it is it makes more sense with Titus. I'll admit it's not a strong case but I really did not have a reason to townread Titus, and the Titus wagon's composition was really good (besides myself, 3 obvtownies and Elyse is a pretty good wagon and I still want that group of people to be a townbloc.).

• Why is Shadow scummier than Karnos?
  
  Is Elyse town? (i admit i'm confbiasing a bit still from D1, but i'm not townreading Elyse as strongly as Nero and Kraska, so if I'm looking for bussers on the wagon, I'm interested in Thor and her)
  
  Why are people scumreading Nero?
  
  If you still scumread me today... Why did Titus and I attempt a double bus?

In post 2029, gigabyteTroubadour wrote: I'm also struggling to find a partner besides Karnos, I think the wagon distribution is more likely 2-off-1-on, if not everyone being off it.

In post 2041, karnos wrote:

In post 2029, gigabyteTroubadour wrote: I'm also struggling to find a partner besides Karnos, I think the wagon distribution is more likely 2-off-1-on, if not everyone being off it.

Are you saying there are 4 scum? Assuming 3 scum, as normal for this size game, there could have been 1-off 1-on. I don't know why you would suggest there are 4 scum, it would be very abnormal for a game of this size.

In post 2043, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:we'd lose today with four group scum, so lol