Mafiascum.net

K. I'm ok to lynch ABR/Starbuck.

I don't see how the midway case from starbuck just sprang into existence (esp since I suggested that a while back, and since she thinks I'm scum...)

I've seen midway play as scum before, fairly mild and non offensive. Could be both way but I think Starbuck or Raya both have better chances of being scum than him. Not really against a lynch but not really for either.

Btw Raya, now the first day is done, don't you think asking for reads is redundant atm?

In post 2021, springlullaby wrote:She's not that petty.

I mean, look, she even said I'm not that petty.

In post 2024, Starbuck wrote:I haven't been trash-talking, though. I've brought up legit reasons why spring's tunneling on insignificant details makes no sense and she defends herself saying that I'm using ad hom against her instead of having a conversation. Have I gotten catty, sure? But not at the level that she keeps screaming about toxicity.

What insignificant details?

In post 2025, springlullaby wrote:I don't see how the midway case from starbuck just sprang into existence (esp since I suggested that a while back, and since she thinks I'm scum...)

I was going back to re-read him and ND today because I finally had a few hours to really dig into it. In all actuality, you, farside, and Raya bringing up points that I didn't understand regarding him is what made me want to go read.

In post 2026, Starbuck wrote:

In post 2021, springlullaby wrote:She's not that petty.

I mean, look, she even said I'm not that petty.

As town, you wouldn't be.

In post 2025, springlullaby wrote:K. I'm ok to lynch ABR/Starbuck.

I don't see how the midway case from starbuck just sprang into existence (esp since I suggested that a while back, and since she thinks I'm scum...)

I've seen midway play as scum before, fairly mild and non offensive. Could be both way but I think Starbuck or Raya both have better chances of being scum than him. Not really against a lynch but not really for either.

Btw Raya, now the first day is done, don't you think asking for reads is redundant atm?

I'm just having trouble keeping track of who you're reading as what. It seems like you think everyone is scum. I'm just asking for a list. No reasoning needed

In post 2030, Raya36 wrote:

In post 2025, springlullaby wrote:K. I'm ok to lynch ABR/Starbuck.

I don't see how the midway case from starbuck just sprang into existence (esp since I suggested that a while back, and since she thinks I'm scum...)

I've seen midway play as scum before, fairly mild and non offensive. Could be both way but I think Starbuck or Raya both have better chances of being scum than him. Not really against a lynch but not really for either.

Btw Raya, now the first day is done, don't you think asking for reads is redundant atm?

I'm just having trouble keeping track of who you're reading as what. It seems like you think everyone is scum. I'm just asking for a list. No reasoning needed

Well, what about I like to keep myself spicy?
I'm not against lynching you if that's what you are asking.

In post 2031, springlullaby wrote:

In post 2030, Raya36 wrote:

In post 2025, springlullaby wrote:K. I'm ok to lynch ABR/Starbuck.

I don't see how the midway case from starbuck just sprang into existence (esp since I suggested that a while back, and since she thinks I'm scum...)

I've seen midway play as scum before, fairly mild and non offensive. Could be both way but I think Starbuck or Raya both have better chances of being scum than him. Not really against a lynch but not really for either.

Btw Raya, now the first day is done, don't you think asking for reads is redundant atm?

I'm just having trouble keeping track of who you're reading as what. It seems like you think everyone is scum. I'm just asking for a list. No reasoning needed

Well, what about I like to keep myself spicy?
I'm not against lynching you if that's what you are asking.

I'm not asking about me. I'm asking about your read on everyone

At this point, I'd like ABR's slot and midway at the end of the chain.

I'm starting to think ABR/Titus is just a mislynch to be honest. I definitely want to see Midway in the bottom two. I'm undecided on who I want the other to be. Probably Spring

Ngl I don't really see the whole one of spring/starbuck has to be scum thing that's been going on.
Can't I just town read them both in peace?

I think they're both town so yeah

Thanks PB very cool take.

You're absolutely welcome

In post 2013, Titus wrote:

In post 2010, farside22 wrote:

In post 2009, Titus wrote:

In post 2006, farside22 wrote:

In post 2004, Titus wrote:ABR, imo, is actually the type to sub out when not getting his way or losing. It's all about ego with him. That's why we don't play together anymore. I loved this list but refused to play with him.

Anyway, let's get started. Shall we?

Are you going to do a read through or wing it?

Wing it. As always.

*shrug*
Your funeral.

If I have a funeral, it's because I subbed into an anti-town slot and lack an obvtown gene.

Pretty much.
Went from calling springs quiz list scummy and ranting. Giving mid a chain without a reason. Following reads from anyone and everyone without a reason.
Doesn't get pissy with mid for talking about giving the chain to one of his scum read. Conviently scum reads bottom 2 plays with no reasons.

In post 2040, farside22 wrote:

In post 2013, Titus wrote:

In post 2010, farside22 wrote:

In post 2009, Titus wrote:

In post 2006, farside22 wrote:

In post 2004, Titus wrote:ABR, imo, is actually the type to sub out when not getting his way or losing. It's all about ego with him. That's why we don't play together anymore. I loved this list but refused to play with him.

Anyway, let's get started. Shall we?

Are you going to do a read through or wing it?

Wing it. As always.

*shrug*
Your funeral.

If I have a funeral, it's because I subbed into an anti-town slot and lack an obvtown gene.

Pretty much.
Went from calling springs quiz list scummy and ranting. Giving mid a chain without a reason. Following reads from anyone and everyone without a reason.
Doesn't get pissy with mid for talking about giving the chain to one of his scum read. Conviently scum reads bottom 2 plays with no reasons.

Let me guess, mid was doing what he wanted. Springs list defended vocal people ABR wanted dead.

ABR is about what's easy, not what is right.

I have started my list backwards of his (assuming your list is accurate).

Who did mid chain?

In post 2041, Titus wrote:

In post 2040, farside22 wrote:

In post 2013, Titus wrote:

In post 2010, farside22 wrote:

In post 2009, Titus wrote:

In post 2006, farside22 wrote:

In post 2004, Titus wrote:ABR, imo, is actually the type to sub out when not getting his way or losing. It's all about ego with him. That's why we don't play together anymore. I loved this list but refused to play with him.

Anyway, let's get started. Shall we?

Are you going to do a read through or wing it?

Wing it. As always.

*shrug*
Your funeral.

If I have a funeral, it's because I subbed into an anti-town slot and lack an obvtown gene.

Pretty much.
Went from calling springs quiz list scummy and ranting. Giving mid a chain without a reason. Following reads from anyone and everyone without a reason.
Doesn't get pissy with mid for talking about giving the chain to one of his scum read. Conviently scum reads bottom 2 plays with no reasons.

Let me guess, mid was doing what he wanted. Springs list defended vocal people ABR wanted dead.

ABR is about what's easy, not what is right.

I have started my list backwards of his (assuming your list is accurate).

Mid picked dunn i think. Mid was accused going with the concesses by picking sb, so he switched it to someone else.
Spring listed me, sb, spring, dunn and raya. Abr denied it saying he didn't want that list because if anyone was scum reading players on the list they should deny it. The biggest scum read he had on the list was Sb followed by unwnd.

In post 2043, farside22 wrote:Mid picked dunn i think. Mid was accused going with the concesses by picking sb, so he switched it to someone else.
Spring listed me, sb, spring, dunn and raya. Abr denied it saying he didn't want that list because if anyone was scum reading players on the list they should deny it. The biggest scum read he had on the list was Sb followed by unwnd.

I can get behind mid. I would also suspect sb or dunn as a partner.

ABR is wrong. Every quest should be approved until one fails. Then we either have scum or forgetfulness. Either we get info or quest bonuses.

In post 2024, Starbuck wrote:I haven't been trash-talking, though. I've brought up legit reasons why spring's tunneling on insignificant details makes no sense and she defends herself saying that I'm using ad hom against her instead of having a conversation. Have I gotten catty, sure? But not at the level that she keeps screaming about toxicity.

Your setting up mislynches left and right.
First Cake.
Then ABR
Then Spring
Then maybe me?

Not much more left for scum to get a win eh?

Midwaybear is tone town and is Town 100% of the time.

Starbuck dying is the most optimal today as it gives us the most information.

In post 2001, MariaR wrote:

Titus replaces ABR give her a warm welcome!

Hello Titus!

I almost forgot:



I was thinking about the group and I think 3/4 are town and 1 is null. So I'm ok with it