Mafiascum.net

In post 2024, DkKoba wrote:

In post 2012, Titus wrote:

In post 2009, DkKoba wrote:

In post 1965, Titus wrote:We would have one scum in Ari Gamma Koba, likely not Gamma.
One in Luke Math Alch, likely not Math
Umlaut off.

how u gonna say "likely not" at the 2 likley remaining scum

Are you looking to expand the elimination pool?

How can you read all of what i said and conclude that

By protecting scum and putting town in the PoE, you get miseliminations.

yes; thats what you're doing. Im fixing the issue.
if i bother to read this game its probably even more solved, but cba. Im vibing

Me: these 5 people who are being consensus scumread by others are town imo
Titus: youre literally expanding the limpool

everyone:??????

Gamma is highly likely not scum. No one is pushing him. Math is miselim bait. Ari being obvtown is absurd.

is this the same reading method that let gamma beat you as scum in townstump game

tbh titus i'm still not satisfied with the explanation that math is town. missed kill is whatever because it looked like he bought my act of having the guilty, and if both scum and protective bought it, and he's scum, i feel like it's likely he just shoots me?

saying town!him goes against consensus sometimes is fine and dandy but that doesn't prove he's not scum that's going against consensus here, which is what i actually need here. besides, with a missed kill and omega slowly slipping away, i feel like scum would have to fight against consensus?

In post 1997, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1994, Datisi wrote:titus asked you what's your solve if me/her/omega are town. you said you don't see a world where meg doesn't get hammered there then. that seems to me like you're calling one of us scum.

No it’s not. That’s you making an assumption and putting words in my mouth AGAIN.

It’s what I am struggling with. That’s all. I don’t have an answer for that yet as I haven’t done a proper VCA.

Just because I point out a flaw doesn’t mean I necessarily have the solution.

Number one rule of answering questions in mafia/Survivor (since it applies there wrt jury questions): always answer the initial question, even if there is a caveat.

In post 2030, Datisi wrote:tbh titus i'm still not satisfied with the explanation that math is town. missed kill is whatever because it looked like he bought my act of having the guilty, and if both scum and protective bought it, and he's scum, i feel like it's likely he just shoots me?

saying town!him goes against consensus sometimes is fine and dandy but that doesn't prove he's not scum that's going against consensus here, which is what i actually need here. besides, with a missed kill and omega slowly slipping away, i feel like scum would have to fight against consensus?

vote with me lol

In post 2009, DkKoba wrote:

In post 1965, Titus wrote:We would have one scum in Ari Gamma Koba, likely not Gamma.
One in Luke Math Alch, likely not Math
Umlaut off.

how u gonna say "likely not" at the 2 likley remaining scum

Dk straight up malding at not being able to crack the townblock

koba, why is alch not scum?

In post 2030, Datisi wrote:tbh titus i'm still not satisfied with the explanation that math is town. missed kill is whatever because it looked like he bought my act of having the guilty, and if both scum and protective bought it, and he's scum, i feel like it's likely he just shoots me?

saying town!him goes against consensus sometimes is fine and dandy but that doesn't prove he's not scum that's going against consensus here, which is what i actually need here. besides, with a missed kill and omega slowly slipping away, i feel like scum would have to fight against consensus?

Scum!Me is always in control of the consensus lol.

You’re literally arguing why I am town lmfao.

In post 2031, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1997, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1994, Datisi wrote:titus asked you what's your solve if me/her/omega are town. you said you don't see a world where meg doesn't get hammered there then. that seems to me like you're calling one of us scum.

No it’s not. That’s you making an assumption and putting words in my mouth AGAIN.

It’s what I am struggling with. That’s all. I don’t have an answer for that yet as I haven’t done a proper VCA.

Just because I point out a flaw doesn’t mean I necessarily have the solution.

Number one rule of answering questions in mafia/Survivor (since it applies there wrt jury questions): always answer the initial question, even if there is a caveat.

And I did. Datisi made it say something I didn’t. My answer was and is I don’t know.

In post 2034, Datisi wrote:koba, why is alch not scum?

You are asking the wrong person, he's in my poe.

In post 2037, DkKoba wrote:

In post 2034, Datisi wrote:koba, why is alch not scum?

You are asking the wrong person, he's in my poe.

oh, i misread an earlier post then

do you feel efforting enough to talk about it

In post 2035, MathBlade wrote:Scum!Me is always in control of the consensus lol.

math's shitpush on omega isn't going through, math is no locktown, how could've i been so blind.

math is now* locktown fucking hell the joke is ruined i'm gonna go now

In post 2028, Titus wrote:Ari being obvtown is absurd.

I am sooooo obviously town tho.

I'm practically glowing.

In post 2030, Datisi wrote:tbh titus i'm still not satisfied with the explanation that math is town. missed kill is whatever because it looked like he bought my act of having the guilty, and if both scum and protective bought it, and he's scum, i feel like it's likely he just shoots me?

saying town!him goes against consensus sometimes is fine and dandy but that doesn't prove he's not scum that's going against consensus here, which is what i actually need here. besides, with a missed kill and omega slowly slipping away, i feel like scum would have to fight against consensus?

The first paragraph is valid but not sound. He recognizes the situation. Particularly him.

Again, they would chip away and not be head on. Math being head on as town. As opposed to Koba who is trying to slip names into the townblock and take some out.

In post 1957, Datisi wrote:aristeia, what are your thoughts currently? how come you're not voting anyone?

My top suspects are Alchemist and Lukewarm.

Alchemist because he sounded almost disappointed when a bunch of people told him that I was very town and that his thoughts about me were actually how I play as town, I'd think town!him would be more relieved that people told him to stop trying to kill me when I'm like obv!town as it avoids a mis-elim.

If he disagreed with everyone else and still believed I am scum, I would expect him to push back, instead his sigh of annoyance felt like scum being disappointed at a mis-elim being taken off the table.


Lukewarm has overall just not felt very engaged or solvey compared to what I've seen of him in the past and that's a big shrug for me.


I haven't voted because I liked sheeping yesterday since it produced good results and I'm making my mind up about who to sheep today. If you have some solid opinions about who to kill you will tell me yes?

In post 2043, Aristeia wrote:Lukewarm has overall just not felt very engaged or solvey compared to what I've seen of him in the past and that's a big shrug for me.

Can you describe this? A few people have been SRing Luke and my objection has been that he seems to be legitimately solving so if that’s not correct then my TR on Luke kinda turns to dust

In post 2043, Aristeia wrote:

In post 1957, Datisi wrote:aristeia, what are your thoughts currently? how come you're not voting anyone?

My top suspects are Alchemist and Lukewarm.

Alchemist because he sounded almost disappointed when a bunch of people told him that I was very town and that his thoughts about me were actually how I play as town, I'd think town!him would be more relieved that people told him to stop trying to kill me when I'm like obv!town as it avoids a mis-elim.

If he disagreed with everyone else and still believed I am scum, I would expect him to push back, instead his sigh of annoyance felt like scum being disappointed at a mis-elim being taken off the table.


Lukewarm has overall just not felt very engaged or solvey compared to what I've seen of him in the past and that's a big shrug for me.


I haven't voted because I liked sheeping yesterday since it produced good results and I'm making my mind up about who to sheep today. If you have some solid opinions about who to kill you will tell me yes?

I wasn’t annoyed I just worded it weirdly.

What do you see from Luke that looks like he's solving?

I skimmed the ISO last night and again just now and it just looks like he's been tunneled on ChaosO for most of the game?

In post 2045, Alchemist21 wrote:I wasn’t annoyed I just worded it weirdly.

the feeling I got was that you were annoyed.

I mean obviously scum!you wouldn't outright just say "I am annoyed my mis!elim is gone"....

In post 2047, Aristeia wrote:

In post 2045, Alchemist21 wrote:I wasn’t annoyed I just worded it weirdly.

the feeling I got was that you were annoyed.

Nah, that’s me acknowledging that people who know you would know better how to read you and deferring to their Townread on you.