Mafiascum.net

In post 2021, Tracer.Bullet wrote:

In post 1831, Holiday wrote:April/Dwlee/A50. Kill in there.

short

simple

direct

nothing performative

nothing lamisty

feels like she has an urgency to get the message out there b4 thread lock

Just got out of a game where a scum made the exact same thing, saying "kill player1/player2" before thread lock on an actual hammer

In post 2019, Dwlee99 wrote:What...?

Like, April is playing really agenda-y and informed and forced. If you don't care that that's his meta I don't see how you wouldn't have him as scum.

But mostly I'm just giving you a hard time for saying something that seems obviously wrong to me, so sorry.

In post 2018, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Also how scum is T3. Holy shit.

I have a cold so I was sleeping

In post 2024, Tracer.Bullet wrote:

In post 2022, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 2018, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Also how scum is T3. Holy shit.

Nah t3 town

ok who were you talking about when you said I was at best 1/3 then

April

Something_Smart wrote:

In post 2019, Dwlee99 wrote:What...?

Like, April is playing really agenda-y and informed and forced. If you don't care that that's his meta I don't see how you wouldn't have him as scum.

But mostly I'm just giving you a hard time for saying something that seems obviously wrong to me, so sorry.

I think April is mildly townie right now for their play. They could be scum, but I don't think it's more likely than them being town. The meta case on April was to scumread them, not townread them

In post 616, T3 wrote:niger won 7-2
april is town

Are you referring to this?

This is April’s first game in like 10 months though.

In post 2025, Dwlee99 wrote:Just got out of a game where a scum made the exact same thing, saying "kill player1/player2" before thread lock on an actual hammer

you can have anecdotes for everything.

if I said something like Dwlee is scum because I just got out of a game where Dwlee was scum, do you think that's a good argument?

In post 2029, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 616, T3 wrote:niger won 7-2
april is town

Are you referring to this?

No. I’m referring to the part where I said that April did some towny stuff with trying to manipulate the game to get more discussion. But now I also remember I said that April could also do that as scum. But now I remember that this is April’s first game in 10 months. So leaning town.

In post 1892, Dwlee99 wrote:I would like the day to end on someone I scumread. This is a completely novel sentiment that I myself invented

Dwlee is probably just town for the way he’s talking to tracer. I feel like scum would be more filtered and careful, in a sense.

In post 2033, T3 wrote:

In post 1892, Dwlee99 wrote:I would like the day to end on someone I scumread. This is a completely novel sentiment that I myself invented

Dwlee is probably just town for the way he’s talking to tracer. I feel like scum would be more filtered and careful, in a sense.

Sounds like you have no respect for big D's scum game

In post 2031, Tracer.Bullet wrote:

In post 2025, Dwlee99 wrote:Just got out of a game where a scum made the exact same thing, saying "kill player1/player2" before thread lock on an actual hammer

you can have anecdotes for everything.

if I said something like Dwlee is scum because I just got out of a game where Dwlee was scum, do you think that's a good argument?

That's not the argument. I'm saying that at best, what you're pointing to is NAI behavior, so you townreading them for it is bad. If I can show that scum perform the behavior you're talking about as being townie with frequency, then it's not actually townie behavior!

In post 2034, Tracer.Bullet wrote:

In post 2033, T3 wrote:

In post 1892, Dwlee99 wrote:I would like the day to end on someone I scumread. This is a completely novel sentiment that I myself invented

Dwlee is probably just town for the way he’s talking to tracer. I feel like scum would be more filtered and careful, in a sense.

Sounds like you have no respect for big D's scum game

How far back do we go? Did you play with me back in 2016?

In post 1943, Enchant wrote:I am strongly against Alice elim as well

In post 1944, Tracer.Bullet wrote:Have you actually played with Alice?

Like, seriously you two had me rushing to the frontpage to check which game I was reading

In post 2035, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 2031, Tracer.Bullet wrote:

In post 2025, Dwlee99 wrote:Just got out of a game where a scum made the exact same thing, saying "kill player1/player2" before thread lock on an actual hammer

you can have anecdotes for everything.

if I said something like Dwlee is scum because I just got out of a game where Dwlee was scum, do you think that's a good argument?

That's not the argument. I'm saying that at best, what you're pointing to is NAI behavior, so you townreading them for it is bad. If I can show that scum perform the behavior you're talking about as being townie with frequency, then it's not actually townie behavior!

Pointing out one example doesn't make something NAI.


If I say something like "most swans are white"

you can't counter that with "oh look here's a picture of a black swan"

and pretend that there's as many black swans as white swans in the entire world.

Sure, one example doesn't, but I'm talking to my experience and providing examples as stand ins for my broader experience

In post 1971, NorwegianboyEE wrote:It’s not Alice, nobody named Alice is in this game.

THANK YOU. Norwee is confirmed a Townie to me.

In post 1975, geraintm wrote:i only have had two guy feelings about holiday.

So, not only do you think holiday isn't a she, but you also believe it's a 2 guy hydra??

I mean, that would be rich.. but I don't think the mod allows a hydra without announcing it to be a hydra

In post 1975, geraintm wrote:you are either for April or for Holiday

We are in NOVEMBER, so nobody can vote for APRIL yet. However, we are indeed approaching the holidays season, so it goes without saying one should vote Holiday here. (Who the freak doesn't want a HOILDAY anyway?)

Btw, would anybody care to explain what the hell "ring a rang a dong" means??

In post 1981, Tracer.Bullet wrote:Someone pushing townies to die is always pro-mafia

Someone pushing for a claimed VT elimination to prevent outing TPRs is always pro-TOWN.

In post 1982, Tracer.Bullet wrote:

In post 1977, Enchant wrote:If Holiday is town i voting Gera next.

If holiday flips town

then you push gera and gera flips town

what you do on day 3?

We push you. Correct play >>> Winning one game. I am going to park-vote ger regardless of the Holiday flip here. (Unless April is somehow Scum, in which case I'd be content to be the lim myself)

In post 1985, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Enchant shaddup.