Mafiascum.net

OKAY. THIS THREAD IS GETTING SUPER STALE.

I WANT EVERYONE'S TOP 3 LYNCH CANDIDATES NOW

xvart wrote:Did ooba ever tell us what he wants to do with his life?

xvart.

I don't think anybody asked .. I want to be a cop ..

gandalf5166 wrote:Good catch. I don't believe he did.

Why is it a good catch

My top lynch candidates are: xvart and gandalf
You (RC) are recruited but cannot be recruiter due to night actions so waste of a lynch ..
Similarly on singersinger ..

Also singersinger should shoot herself .. Scum would then have to decide between roleblocking her and Andrius or Robo ..

RC: Friend

ReaperCharlie wrote:OKAY. THIS THREAD IS GETTING SUPER STALE.

I WANT EVERYONE'S TOP 3 LYNCH CANDIDATES NOW

Friend, Erg0, and in a distant 3rd Inhim.

I'm reading up on these last few pages today. Expect a post in typical BBM fashion, slow and steady.

Updated reads, mainly for keeping my own thoughts straight, partially for everyone else to be on the same page (Possibly questions too, I haven't gotten there yet):

Charlie - 1850 wasn't my favorite post in the world. States possible intent on joining a robo wagon (pre-claim), but really doesn't commit anything. Call it just how I view things, but a L-2 vote (by my count) isn't really something to be all that cautious about, especially given that a claim was essentially going to happen either way. A little bit of an "all over the place" vibe at certain times. While, I kind of read singer and ooba on a scummy side, I'm not really sold on the speculation in 1962. Sure, I'll take it as a possibility, but I can't make a judgment on how likely it is...1984 makes more sense in my mind though. Read: Basically still neutral, leaning ever so slightly scum.

Friend - (Hypocrite alert!) Not really here much during day three. Still pushing the whole yos2 thing from yesterday, feels slightly forced, and definitely tunnel-y. Basically, my read hasn't changed from my catchup post. My lead candidate for recruiter.

Yos - A bit defensive this day, more so than my read of day two. Fairly certain he isn't the recruiter. Despite the events of the day, he still feels townie-ish to me.

Andy - Robo's claim only strengthens a town read here. Wasn't a superfan of the jump on ooba. Seemed forced and kind of content-less. All in all, still feeling town.

Xvart - Not quite as strong as yesterday, but still on my town read side.

Meweird - Dead, recruited. Pretty sure he's only a death miller though...obviously (Joke)

Singer - Feeling recruited today. It's extremely sketch to keep the double vote, in my mind. Her posts today really seem as if she's trying very hard to prove herself as still town, buddying to the "town" if you will. The comments about having the town lead the kill and wanting it to be useless to the cult in post 1950 just plain feel off. They don't feel genuine, and it feels as if she is newly recruited and trying to keep in good graces with the town. Read: Leaning much stronger to the scum side.

Robo/Vezok - Okay, you've claimed. Now you need to start ACTUALLY DOING SOMETHING. Seriously. Do you even find anyone scummy at this point, because besides jumping onto the faraday wagon, I can't find anything to tell me otherwise. Read: Without the claim, I'd still have my vote on robo, hands down. That being said, I believe the claim (mainly because its a fairly common role I use myself in cult games I've run). I'm leaning town with a side of "DO SOMETHING, SIR". If you read and acknowledge this, Robo, post the word 'apple', preferably in your next post.

Faraday - Dead, unrecruited. Can't think of a witty comment again, sorry.

Prozac - Too quiet today sir, and no amusing drunk posts . I haven't really had anything to change my read, but I would love to hear from you more today. And yes, I know. This is a list, sorry. I like giving lists like this when making larger than ideal catch-ups...

Inhim - Very non-existent today. Probably the most non-existent today. I would still love to hear more from you, but the quietness isn't making my read go towards town...

Gurgi - I'm glad to see you arrive in day three, Flimsy. I don't have anything bad to say about your posts today. Still leaning town with Flimsy.

Chrono - Still a pretty neutral read, honestly. I believe the roleblock-roleblock scenario as of right now. Kind of agree with ISO-60. Who else do you suspect besides Ooba? (Extra: I'm only reading d3, so if there is another pre d3 post you have that would answer that, direct me to it, and I'll shut up )

Ooba - Like I stated in others recaps: I'm not sold on RC's theories. I do think that the no result from Andy is suspicious with the flavor given by Chrono. Given that, I'm not completely sold on recruiter due to the claim. I like my chances for calling a recruit here though.

Erg0 - Kinda quiet, makes me get a "meh" neutral read like yesterday. Your posts do give a bit of a sense of "im here, but I'm not really saying anything important", so the meh neutral read leans to scum as of right now.

Gandalf - Another one for the quiet pile. I know your here, but I don't really know where you're at in terms of this game. ISO-80 says Friend is probably the other recruiter, does this still hold true? Are you willing to vote Friend today?

Again, that SHOULD be everyone.

singersigner wrote:

xvart wrote:

singersigner, 1998 wrote:I'm honestly not sure. I would assume I could say something like "double-aim." Or just PM him myself...?

All skepticism aside about Flay being so conspicuously unclear in the role pm, how about you find out and get back to us?

xvart.

It's by a PM. It "won't be connected to me," but since the claim, you guys will know it is.

I suspected as much, in which case it doesn't actually serve as proof of your claim. I seem to recall TheLonging thinking that he had a daykill via PM on day 1, I'm undecided on whether this makes me believe you more or less. Any idea why he would think that?

I'm really getting the feeling that xvart didn't get a PM about being blocked by Chrono. There are two (maybe three) possible reasons for this, but I have a feeling this will be significant later.

I'll post my top 3 later today, need some thinking time.

I am willing to vote Friend. Let me look back at a VC so I can get a look at the leading wagons though, I don't think he's one of them, and there was something I was waiting for from someone, but I can't remember what it is.
Never mind, he is. LESSA GO!

Top three lynch candidates ARE: Friend, SS, and Porochaz, in that order.

Unanticipated V/LA :/

Be back in a few days. (posting this across all games)

Apple.

Actually, I'll make that Apples. Plural.

Here ill even post a picture.


And then after I make them into a pie.


In other words, I read an acknowledge your post.

Ooba wrote:Also singersinger should shoot herself .. Scum would then have to decide between roleblocking her and Andrius or Robo ..

This doesn't make any sense?!? Why would I do the work of scum for them??

Of the people hopping aboard my suddenly-popular wagon, Gandalf's was the worst.

Friend wrote:Of the people hopping aboard my suddenly-popular wagon, Gandalf's was the worst.

aim: Gandalf

Lame duck omgus. With a hint of AtE.

RC: ooba, Friend, and maybe chrono. Until someone can explain to me the no alignment result on ooba is not a good reason to think he is the recruiter I don't anticipate changing my vote.

ooba, 2051 wrote:Also singersinger should shoot herself .. Scum would then have to decide between roleblocking her and Andrius or Robo ..

I don't understand this line of thinking.

Friend, 2060 wrote:Of the people hopping aboard my suddenly-popular wagon, Gandalf's was the worst.

aim: Gandalf

So your only qualifiers for scum is who is voting you? Self preservation is scum motivation?

xvart.

singersigner wrote:

Ooba wrote:Also singersinger should shoot herself .. Scum would then have to decide between roleblocking her and Andrius or Robo ..

This doesn't make any sense?!? Why would I do the work of scum for them??

What doesn't make sense is you saving up the kill for two nights while there were recruiters around ..
A scummy person claims a vig - correct play is for them to shoot themselves - saves a lynch ..

ooba, 2063 wrote:What doesn't make sense is you saving up the kill for two nights while there were recruiters around ..
A scummy person claims a vig - correct play is for them to shoot themselves - saves a lynch ..

The point is, her shooting herself is irrelevant if she gets recruited tonight (unless she submits her NK immediately and recruiting has no effect on actions already submitted). But I do agree that singer is not being truthful. singer needs to use her double vote today. Barring that failing, she should be on my list of three instead of chrono, so updated:

ooba, Friend, singersinger

xvart.

ooba wrote:

singersigner wrote:

Ooba wrote:Also singersinger should shoot herself .. Scum would then have to decide between roleblocking her and Andrius or Robo ..

This doesn't make any sense?!? Why would I do the work of scum for them??

What doesn't make sense is you saving up the kill for two nights while there were recruiters around ..
A scummy person claims a vig - correct play is for them to shoot themselves - saves a lynch ..

You must be smoking the bad pipegrass, bro. Seriously. I've never seen this level of dementia from you before.

I am torn between sticking with my gut on ooba despite phony-looking evidence, and taking a gamble on lynching Friend, on whom there is NO evidence.

Somebody make up my mind for me. Andrius. I choose you.

I never would have pegged ooba as a follower of Pie.

The logic in this case is more sound than usual. If the scum have no night kill, we have no reason to give them one when we can just have it kill itself.

Lord Gurgi, 2066 wrote:I never would have pegged ooba as a follower of Pie.

The logic in this case is more sound than usual. If the scum have no night kill, we have no reason to give them one when we can just have it kill itself.

Did you miss everything I just said?

xvart.

Robocopter87 wrote:Apple.

Actually, I'll make that Apples. Plural.

Here ill even post a picture.


And then after I make them into a pie.


In other words, I read an acknowledge your post.

I don't understand this. Is it an inside joke of some sort?

Recruiting has to apply last, xvart.

Gurgi. She is ALREADY RECRUITED. That is PAINFULLY F#%&ING OBVIOUS.

Remind me again why we suffer you to live, when Mr. Obvrecruit Andrius over there was the one who cleared you as town?



Not to mention you make NO sense.



Also. I swear. xvart, we need to hydra soon, I think my brain might explode otherwise.

Soooo why aren't we lynching the obv_recruit? Its better than a town lynch.

And RC, I've *supposedly* been protected from recruiters for the past few nights.

ooba is known for asking Vigs to kill themselves. He told AGM to self-kill in Greek Mythos. (He didn't.)
BUT I normally recommend going with your gut.

More later. Falling aslssp at the moment.

Andrius wrote:Soooo why aren't we lynching the obv_recruit? Its better than a town lynch.

Yet worse than a recruiter lynch, or haven't you been paying attention for the last EIGHTY-THREE PAGES.

Andrius wrote:And RC, I've *supposedly* been protected from recruiters for the past few nights.

Adding *supposedly* doesn't exactly help me to believe this. Which I obviously don't.

Andrius wrote:ooba is known for asking Vigs to kill themselves. He told AGM to self-kill in Greek Mythos. (He didn't.)

Unsolicited defense of ooba noted.

Andrius wrote:More later. Falling aslssp at the moment.

Nonsense!

Your posts are much easier to pick apart when you're falling aslssp.

Please, by all means, continue to post (at least, until you wake up).

My posting standard in this game is becoming as bad as some others. Will catch up and post later on in the day (RL day)