Mafiascum.net

In post 2047, VP Baltar wrote:Better question: how are you judging DV's list if you haven't read? What looks bad on it?

Read on my slot and cakes

And also you didn't feel aligned with them and they have you low

Based on mechanics, I don't think that they necessarily look bad. I think a mass claim would be a solid idea today. My tentative reads are more based off of things I don't think they would pursue as scum. First of all, ABR blowing up at IV in the middle of the day looked genuine and unlikely to be s/s. I also think ABR hard pushing Cakez is a really interesting play as scum. The thing in the middle where he backed down for a bit seemed genuine, and I feel like he would maintain an aggro mentality as scum? IV is definitely more confident then ABR. I don't think IV would have a fun time playing so self aware, and I think he genuinely is out of his scum range. Also, I don't think he publicly calls Cakez as gut town. I would expect scum to go with gut scum, and I do think town indecision is a thing.

In post 2050, Dunnstral wrote:

In post 2047, VP Baltar wrote:Better question: how are you judging DV's list if you haven't read? What looks bad on it?

Read on my slot and cakes

And also you didn't feel aligned with them and they have you low

Alright, I'll give you some time to catch up.

Cliff notes are:

D1 = ABR doing ABR things and running up Shoshin quickly. She fake claimed cop as town, then doctor and was appropriately yeeted.

D2 = is A LOT of fluff. ABR claims tracker/motion detector and correctly claims Cakez visited midwaybear N1. They fight for ages on whether this means Cakez is scum, and we get a number of claims or insinuations of claims. Cakez flips town.

You can probably skim some of the stupider fighting, but it'd be good to hear your thoughts on the role madness as soon as possible.

In post 2051, midwaybear wrote:The thing in the middle where he backed down for a bit seemed genuine, and I feel like he would maintain an aggro mentality as scum?

Wasn't that after he thought IV had hammered?

Mostly this string of posts which I think came before IV's fake hammer. I don't really think it's necessary for him to say this as scum when he can just call out Cakez for ATEing and continue to aggressively push. There was also a similar moment with Noraa, but I don't find that as AI.

I've never played with Albert as scum before, so I'm wondering if you've seen anything similar.

Eh, I find that pretty NAI play for ABR. He plays a very psychological game. Aggro doesn't work with every player to get them to do what you want. Sometimes honey is more effective.

I don't want to speak too strongly about meta because idk what ABR's current meta is. I just know I don't take any "emotion" in his posts too seriously. Perhaps that is wrong of me, but fool me once goldilocks.

That's fair. I guess I would have just found him continuously pushing Cakez to be more scummy than what he did here. Now, I'm seeing his posts after the hammer and they seem pretty genuine.

In post 1919, Albert B. Rampage wrote:VOTE: Cakez

Ok... this is so high stakes i dont want to be wrong

Although voting Cakez was not great, I understand the feeling of dedicating so much to a push that it almost clouds your judgement. I might be overshooting how AI these posts are, but for some reason I really want to townread ABR here.

I find it weird you believe he is town. The fact he didn't die last night while claiming our strongest investigative role is not a good sign.

I dunno maybe there is a scum roleblocker with a backup town roleblocker. Well, if ABR, IV, and Cakez are all town, scum definitely have some ability that allows them to mitigate any investigative effects.
Or they are just trying to frame him.

In post 1315, Datisi wrote:while it's certainly on par with "mafia odd-night complex traffic analyst", i kinda doubt scum would have a lazy modifier...

This is an ok point I'm considering

I hate that Ico and I are on completely opposite timezones. This is going to be difficult.

Also rereading Datisi's iso is giving me neurosis by osmosis.

In post 2051, midwaybear wrote:I think a mass claim would be a solid idea today.

Thoughts on order?

well I visited dv as planned

ABR?

In post 2064, VP Baltar wrote:Thoughts on order?

Personally, maybe something like DV-Gamma-Ico-VPB-dunn-peta-me.

Fuck this game

VOTE: IV

? ABR, results? I assume you didn’t see me going anywhere?

MY ACTION FAILED

Im ready to vote out Gamma and VPB and IV

Peta ico town. Midway dunno

Dunstral town

Fucking cakez man I was seriously reconsidering his flip and could have saved him, he just meakly dipped his bannered and surrendered to scum. And I wouldn't have claimed yesterday if he just left me the fuck alone on d2 instead of attacking me.

CAKEZ NEVER ATTACK ME AS TOWN YOU ARE ALWAYS WRONG AND YOU ALWAYS WIND UP KILLED OVER IT. JUST DONT. I CANT MAKE SENSE OF THE WAY YOU PLAY.

In post 2073, Albert B. Rampage wrote:Fucking cakez man I was seriously reconsidering his flip and could have saved him

Lol may as well claim scum bud