Mafiascum.net

So essentially what I gather is that Bell is predetermined to pair with fire to get rid of Ceph.

I'll try to read more into Bell/Fire/Ceph interactions but I think there could be a case of Bell and Fire agreeing to pair after night killing Yda and eliminating Ceph.

Yeah I really like this theory. I haven't been a fan of what I read so far (pages 1-13, post when i joined to present). Mainly a lot of jokes and brushing things off and not truly sorting. Like I feel like Bell could use the banter to hide in plain sight posting. In which, i mean they post while a bunch of townie people are talking, and by association, you think of those townie posts, and that they were there as well, so you think town. Deep dive tho there isn't really content.

One thing I'll be looking for is to see if Bell is even trying to convince Fire to trade partners. Because that's also another crucial part of the game. Fire has to agree that Ceph is scum. So that also means I need to check Fire's read on Ceph and see how Fire reacts to Bells advances.

heyo I don't hold anything against ya. I like the enthusiasm. Plus you think differently than I do, which is great because I'm seeing connections that I otherwise don't really consider. Like it's really helpful because now discussing these reads with you, i can get a grasp on the Ceph, Fire, Bell slots. Everyone else except Datisi i've interacted with so this is like the last step for me to get really comfortable with who and how the game is being played out.

P-edit: Honestly i think Imma try to compile a list of Bells reads and then a change in bells reads as of this point. I'm curious if the reads are static. Like I dont have evidence for it, but like if I find scumread on Fire, but then after the mafia NK, they flip that to get rid of Ceph, that's gonna be hella sus.

Btw my reads lists are real simple, Town vs not town

Town: Dunn, Andante, mala
Not Town: everyone else

Adding in recent interactions after my initial posting.

Well shit I dont really feel confident adding anyone else.

Not town: Bell, Myko, Enchant, fire, Ceph, datisi, Luke

That's 7 people. 4 townies.

Enchant, actually I may have figured out how to read Enchant. I recently hosted a game with Enchant as scum. They said this game that their playstyle is anti-town, however all their decisions they made were done for towns benefit. Like there was an XP system and revive mechanics and he chose to, as bloody scum, give XP to town and revive town. So in a weird way, Enchant plays as the opposite of their own alignment mechanically at least. Weird theory, I will have to try and study that more.

Bell, well i gotta be honest with ya, I'm not comfortable having Bell leave the not town category until further investigation. As stated.

Myko, and this is a weird one but I'd throw them in town but very hesitantly. My talks about old school shit was to see how they're treating the game. Like seeing if this is a veteran just chilling and having fun and what that means for their alignment. Also I like the fact that they called out Bell for silencing discussion.

Fire/Ceph aint leaving with Bell cuz I have all 3 of them under intense investigation if that makes sense.

Datisi i'd throw into town because my gut likes their post break downs. They haven't posted much and have read about 4-5 posts of theirs.

Luke feels off but thats a gut I can't explain yet. I just so far bloody hate their use of the word vague to describe most of their reads in the beginning of the game. Like it really feels like fence sitting so Luke can shift with the wind if that makes sense.

So

Town: Dunn, Andante, Mala, Myko, Datisi
Not Town: Bell, Ceph, Fire, Enchant, Luke.

I'm not confident enough to break this down further with what info I have.