Robbery! At The Casino (Game Over)

[ika]

tbh i was going to gambit it and vote who and see what would happen

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Firstly, I think it's a little harsh for GC to be taking the flak for this.

It's not like you only had 1 day to catch scum, this was D5.

i wish you fuckign waited for me......

i was waiting for DR to make his vote first....

I also thought you had made it pretty clear you were OK with lynching Fish.

at least i was right on bbt and that i onw know a special tell in his meta

Nah, you don't.

You only thought I was scum because I was trying to get you lynched. I quoted it for you and everything, you actually had no reasons for me being scum.

[ika]

yes i do bbt i was going to vote dr and you do have a major diffrence in your townvs scm play as well

[Green Crayons]

I was thinking of voting Doctor today, but that would have still put us at BBT v. FF come tomorrow. If I was last alive with those two (presumably BBT would have killed you because of y'all's history in this game, plus my indications that I found him to be more town than FF), I'd probably have voted FF anyways and we'd still have lost.

[Green Crayons]

yes i do bbt i was going to vote dr and

you do have a major diffrence in your townvs scm play as well

Credited:

Something about BBT's play didn't sit right with me from my read through. It's like he's trying too hard to be open about his reads. That's the best way I can put it.

For example, his shift on the beck/ika slot doesn't look genuine. BBT had a strong town read on beck the entire game. ika makes a few flippant posts D2, and BBT votes ika right out of the gate in D3. And from then on he's been just dumping all over ika to further support his ika vote.

UNVOTE: Nat

VOTE: BBT

I don't like his posting this game. I stand by what I said in Post 1426. He's trying too hard to look rational and spell out his positions, while using some pretty shaky logic to push his votes (e.g., looking at the wagon on a D1 town lynch without any flips, his basis for voting Ika in Post 1239 and Post 1242).

Also, I don't like his buddying with my slot when it was occupied by Desp. He found Desp to be incredibly town, and the votes on Desp to be incredibly scum, without justification.

If only I listened to myself. *fist shake*

[ika]

thts often why i give jack about a perdons logic

[geraintm]

Well, I claim no credit for being any help to town this game. I just can't play as mason.
I just got into this mindset that as town, and provable town, that I was able to coast through.
I also didn't really know what to do as mason, just seemed such a meh thing to be.

Bbt


Overall, I hope it is just a posting style thing that rubs me up the wrong way. He's done nothing wrong, not scummy, but this is exactly the kind of player who I don't spot as scum and get beat by

That seems....disappointing.
I think I actually only placed one vote on scum the whole game.
People in future games need to do the exact opposite of me. I am the Constanza of Mafia hunting.

[Majiffy]

Doo doo doo.

Been busy getting ready for Chicago.

Gonna do modstuffs now.

[Majiffy]

THIS IS A VOTECOUNT LOL

Formerfish (1): BlueBloodedToffee, Green Crayons, Doctor Who

BlueBloodedToffee (1): Formerfish

Not Voting: ika
With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Day 5 ends on Saturday, November 27 at 2:00 PM Eastern

Accuracy never guaranteed. But

probably

accurate.

[Majiffy]

Formerfish

has been lynched. He was a

Dealer,

VT.

The scumteam of Natirasha, BlueBloodedToffee and Doctor Who wins!

[Majiffy]

Dead QT
Mason QT
Scum QT

Scum (Daytalk)

Doctor Who - Pit Manager - Ninja-Enabler
BlueBloodedToffee - Floor Manager - Strongman
Natirasha - Dealer - Goon

Town

Egg - Gaming Operations Manager - JOAT (BP, Roleblock, Doctor, Rolecop)
Titus - Floor Manager - Even Night Tracker/Odd Night Watcher
geraintm - Dual-Rate Floor - Mason (Daytalk)
Aronis - Dual-Rate Floor - Mason (Daytalk)
6 VTs

[Majiffy]

Note: I ran a prototype version of this setup in an off-site game, wherein Spruce played. Hence his prompt re-replacement due to already knowing a good portion of the setup.

[Majiffy]

Thanks for playing. Peace out.

[Majiffy]

Oh yeah and there isn't a N2 action list in the spoilers in the QT because I never received an action from Titus, and the scum kill is obviously the dead person.

[Beck]

Way scum sided, near impossible for town to win IMO.

[Majiffy]

Eh the flub regarding passive/active BP kind of fucked town with the N1 kill.

It's actually more balanced than it looks. You just need to rely on scumhunting and not PRs. As most of my setups go.

[shos]

the tracker/watcher role was completely useless though, and this helped misguide town.

[shos]

either way, gg guys, BBT I was townreading almost all the way.

[Doctor Who]

Thanks for running Majiffy!

Good game everyone.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Thanks for modding Majiffy, really enjoyed the game.

Town we unlucky with the PR's pretty much all outing themselves.

A lot more of my thoughts on the game are at the end of the scum QT.

Good game guys.

[Green Crayons]

Yeah I thought it was a good setup. The tracker/watcher being completely nullified by the ninja was probably the most biased part of the setup, because it really laid the groundwork for an easy mislynch. Everything else looks golden.

Was almost a town win, too. Just couldn't figure out BBT v. FF correctly.

[Green Crayons]

The tracker/watcher being completely nullified by the ninja was probably the most biased part of the setup, because it really laid the groundwork for an easy mislynch.

Though thinking back on it, I don't think any of the scum pushed this line of reasoning? So really it just allowed us wildly imaginative VTs to get the better of ourselves.

[Doctor Who]

Had the Watcher / Tracker not spoken up on Day 1, then it could have been played as Vanilla. I thought I read somewhere that if you are a watcher / tracker these days you can safely assume that there are ninjas. Without the watcher / tracker, there was still a JOAT and masons.

Once everyone claimed, it basically set up all of the night kills except shos.

[shos]

How'd you like my crumb? ^.^;;;;

[Doctor Who]

I thought there was a chance that it could carry you until the end, which is also why I saw how it could be interpreted multiple ways.