Posted: Sun Jan 13, 2019 11:12 am
Ugh
Gamma doesn’t play emotionally as scum.
UNVOTE: Gamma
Gamma doesn’t play emotionally as scum.
UNVOTE: Gamma
PB, FL, feel free to weigh in.In post 1919, Jingle wrote:Xtoxm: Why you posting reads in the Neighborhood and not the real thread? Apparently your neighborhood content is what makes PB townread you, so why isn't it relevant for mass consumption? Also, what is your neighborhood content?
You’re either scum or brain dead. WHAT MAKES MORE SENSE, JK PLUS RB OR A DUPLICATE ROLE?In post 2081, sheepsaysmeep wrote:gamma's right that he's counterclaiming theta
he's wrong that theta can possibly be wolf here
I don’t feel like he’s doing it actively or anything.In post 2078, Jingle wrote:PB, FL, feel free to weigh in.In post 1919, Jingle wrote:Xtoxm: Why you posting reads in the Neighborhood and not the real thread? Apparently your neighborhood content is what makes PB townread you, so why isn't it relevant for mass consumption? Also, what is your neighborhood content?
Wasn’t that Echo Bay Grits SEO? Aka ehabanohar mk2? Why are you comparing that to this at all?In post 2083, Party Boat wrote:I feel that I should point out that xyzzy's last large game was literally all dayvigs, 1-shot bulletproof dayvigs, scum dayvigs, scum traitor 1-shot bulletproof dayvigs, and TWO 2-shot bulletproof Serial killer dayvigs
so
maybe banking on the setup making sense over reads isn't the best plan
also yeah it prob would have been better to bring this up before Leo got lynched d1 but I was already scumreading Leo so get shrugged at I guess
You’re still not thinking straight imo but you’re not thinking bass ackwards at leastIn post 2084, Flavor Leaf wrote:Gamma, I think there’s just 2 jailkeepers. Theta doesn’t CC there.
Maybe it’s a high roleblocky game
@FL: What do you make of this then?In post 1793, Party Boat wrote:I do think Xtomx looks moderately better from my point of view than the rest of the game's
Like the complete lockstep with varsoon (and a little w/ flavor before xtomx asked for replacement) is feels a little unwarranted but he does have a few more reads & comments in the neighborhood that make me think he's more likely town than not
plus i think I think part of the reason why he latched onto varsoon is just because xtomx likes varsoon as a player so i could def. see that coming from town
Sort of. But then she reassures me. Currently I feel good on Nancy.In post 2069, Flavor Leaf wrote:Does anyone else have any mad paranoia with Nancy slot?
That's a really stupid post to make. Are you trying to get blocked? If I was a role blocker, I'd be tempted to do it. Probably wouldn't in the end, but I can't know. And activating night 2 doesn't make sense. Sounds like the weirdest IC ever. I'm suspicious. (But there's the fact that fake claiming IC is a strange and deadly gambit balancing out my skepicism.)In post 2044, Kokichi Oma wrote:My ic activates at night and reveals day 3. Dont block me n2 just in case
I like you're analysis of Nancy.In post 2050, Party Boat wrote:aight nancy next
so if you made me guess now I'd say I think Nancy's town but I think that her playstyle (overly emotional, tons and tons of kind of Frozen-angel esque posts) is really hard for me to read, especially early game.
Like her posts are a little light on content/depth but are generally fine-good imo, it just feels like she's playing in a very different way than I do in that it feels like she's kind of making in-game friends/enemies and then sticking to them for a bit rather than separating out people's content/appeals to her from whether or not she thinks they're likely scum and though I think the tone and general reactions to things feel more town than not, I'm not going to be confident in her being town until there are a few more flips and I can separate out some of her interactions into *her talking to town* and *her talking to scum* and see if they look different.
TheBrie:
I don't really like her #560 post about not wanting to vote a 'doomed' player even though she thinks leo is scum. I feel like her push on varsoon feels like scum pushing someone they know is scum for towncred? Like most of my read on her is just that a lot of her posts feel posturey and it's really hard to tell if she believes in anything she's saying given that she hasn't voted anyone in like a week. She def. took her time in Echo Bay Grits to shoot if I'm remembering that correctly so it's not really out of character for her to waffle about stuff like this I think. I do think her reads are alright from what I remember? But she also was very willing to shrug off previous scumreads (varsoon and jaylow/saul in particular, of which maybe I'm wrong on one but I REALLY think at least one of those two is scum) basically just for them replacing out (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p10642554 for varsoon, also said she'd just give saul a pass and forget that jaylow was in slot later on).
She just has tons of things that feel more like commenting on the game rather than trying to solve it and I think that's a little more likely to come from scum. I WOULD really like to see her boldly put out a lengthy readslist with reasons considering that it feels like she's waffling on everyone in the game right now though.
light_ganski:
is a SNEAKY MOFO as I know from echo bay grits but her scumreads are good and her towniest reads are good and her reactions to in-game things are good
she just needs to post like literally twice as much for me to be comfortable calling her town or she's maybe just scum posting legit thoughts but lurking most of the time because it's the best scum strat in the game
I'd say more likely town than not but POST plz my friend I beg of u
two town jailkeepers makes an ounce less sense than but both make senseIn post 2082, Gamma Emerald wrote:You’re either scum or brain dead. WHAT MAKES MORE SENSE, JK PLUS RB OR A DUPLICATE ROLE?In post 2081, sheepsaysmeep wrote:gamma's right that he's counterclaiming theta
he's wrong that theta can possibly be wolf here
VOTE: sheepsaysmeep
You’re so blatantly and irrevocably off-base you get to die first.
Why is Party Boat scum?In post 2093, Xtoxm wrote:what you have to remember, jingle, is that party boat is scum, and everything he says is bullshit.
i had a bromance with varsoon in the hood.
who btw was townreading me and hes a better authority on my alignment than anyone in this game, and probably anyone on site that hasnt quit.
everything else is pretty much in both places i think.