Not at all impressed with this post. I asked for a case on why you're town, not a defense against my points specifically on why you're scum. It's filled to the brim with manipulation and hypocrisy. It's basically deflecting rather than answering my concerns.In post 2092, ProHawk wrote:I have pondered long and hard on what I could say to you to get you to change your mind. Read through your posts, trying to get a handle on your perspective. At one point you had said that Squirrel and I absolutely had to be scum-scum, not town-town, nor even scum-town. I am hoping Squirrel flipping town has spurred your re-evaluation.
As for analysis, you are completely sold on this idea of me being scum because of my scum-play in Tales of Vesperia. I am telling you, my play there and here is EXTREMELY different. Consider the following:
Did I slip/scum-slip in Tales? Compare my posts there and here. You should notice my posts as scum are more calculated, they are read over multiple times, I have a plan and try hard to make error-free-posts. Look at my posts here. I am working on trying to figure things out, but am not worried about hitting the submit button before figuring things out. What you feel like are fake and manufactured are actually genuine. I forgot we had started in the night phase later in the game commenting on poisoning details despite having started out the game stating that exact fact. I completely screwed up in calculating mylo/lylo situations. My confusion/indecision/flippidy floppity stems from an absence of knowledge, not an abundance of it.
I screwed up confusing SG with SP. I thought MC claimed that I visited SP. You somehow think it meant I slipped up. What you are completely forgetting is the fact that scum will have planned this gambit in advance. They would have discussed "Oh hey tomorrow we are probably going to mass-claim. Here is what I am mass-claiming be ready to do X, Y, and/or Z". I would have known who MC was going to claim I would be visiting.
Me making mistakes is genuine. Me correcting my posts before they go out is manufactured. I am not going to take pot-shots at the scum-team until you answer one question for me:
Did you or did you not realize the last game-day was MYLO?
Oh, I have PLENTY of reason to have suspicion on you. I don't need an excuse. If ProHawk's posting today has been bad, yours has been abysmal. ProHawk's posting looks scummy; yours flat-out just looks like scum. Basically every post I reference as being "free ammo" for ProHawk's (now-revealed-to-be-nonexistent) argument? Are basically posts that trip my scumdar and trip it HARD.In post 2095, scienceshrimp wrote:also prohawk i think mastin wants you to make a case on why we're scum, so that she has an excuse to lay down suspicion in our direction
Bluntly, know one of the reasons I'm not voting ProHawk right now?
Is because of how scummy YOU are being, in just about every post you make.
I realize the implausibility of it, but I'm really, REALLY considering a you-ProHawk team specifically because of your attitude. Interactions fit, and you two are certainly the two individually-most-scummy players right now. Your thoughts make no sense, and seem highly opportunistic. Your stances convenient. As they have been through the majority of the game.
Same reason I haven't been questioning you: because you? Aren't my focus. (Or haven't been. Thinking I need to direct more attention onto you.) ProHawk has been. Bluntly, he's the player I most need a read on. More than any other player, I feel he holds the key to the game. Him-town, him-scum. That I need sorted. And if him-scum, who his scumbuddy would be.In post 2098, scienceshrimp wrote:why isn't she questioning MC?
And yet you assume I haven't been. All my posting today has been oriented around this, loosely put. I can build a case for MC being scum or MC town. I can build a case for you being scum easily but also a case for you being town. I have built a case for ProHawk being scum, but am not blind to the point where I'm ignoring the case for him potentially being town. I'm workingmastin, why are you not working that out?
everything
out.But bluntly...you're not. You've already concluded that it's MC and me. You're not asking questions of MC, either. You're not asking questions of ProHawk, either. You're not being cautious. You're not analyzing. You're not considering all the possibilities like I am. And that? That is why I'm increasingly concerned about you being scum. ESPECIALLY considering how you've held that townread on me. Both slots, for different reasons from different heads. Yet when push comes to shove, in lylo, you've discarded that. In favor of a scumread. Not because of any tangible reason. But because it's convenient for you to have it.
