1. I have one person who I feel as good as scum slipped, that no one will listen to me about. (Spring)
2. I have one person whose reads list is squishier than rotten bannanas and I was scumreading before the other guys slip made me think he was town. (zzx)
3. I have one person who in their previous incarnation quietly lurked and was disgustingly scummy when they posted, and hasn't really done much to redeem themselves. (Titus)
4. And finally I have one person who was scummy all of yesterday, hasn't really done much today, I pushed all of yesterday, and when I finally got off him the guy who pushed him slightly more than i did died. (Xay)
Honestly I need like four fucking votes. The only good news is that there is no way spring and zzx are scum together which makes me lean towards voting one of them.
Can people who haven't responded to me yet, and who are on non-spring wagons tell me why they disagree that spring is scum?
I have no thought one way or another. MS not engaging though is eyebrow raising.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 8:27 am
by Thor665
I support the ZZZX wagon.
I'm also pretty content with the idea of the Titus wagon, though I think the case is weaker.
I'd support a lulzy last minute rush for either Spring or Saki.
I'm a very equal opportunity lyncher.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 9:22 am
by TiphaineDeath
I seem to have support, though not votes, for my lets kill spring plan, so I think I'm gonna stay here for now and keep advocating.
Ra-Ra lynch the scum!
Also @ thor, deadline isn't till like the 9th, lulzy rush yes, last minute no, come join in the water's fine.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 10:00 am
by RachMarie
Thor is there anyone you would NOT support lynching?
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 10:26 am
by EddieFenix
Thor for president for his equal opportunist stance on lynching lol xD. Also, where the hell is Jon? I'd rather someone not go completely silent....
Even if you did a cursory ctrl+F of my posts and tracked down the start of Day 2 where I listed a couple town reads you would get a couple of them. I have also mentioned others. I would also note, that even if you wanted to read between the lines of my last comment and compared the wagons available and the number of votes on them you could even spot at least one more.
I have solid reasoning for each of the lynches I support - if you have an issue with individual reasoning then let us speak on that, but if your issue is "supports at least 4 different lynches in a game with 20 living players" then I really would like to see you justify why I need to be remotely chagrined by that. I am not. I think anyone with less than that is being dishonest to themselves or to the rest of the players, or is scum.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 10:50 am
by Thor665
In post 2104, TiphaineDeath wrote:Also @ thor, deadline isn't till like the 9th, lulzy rush yes, last minute no, come join in the water's fine.
Psssh.
"I support wagons A, B, C"
"Thor, I know A has, like, thrice the support B does, but come support B!"
Bribe me or give reasoning, but a 'hey, c'mon!' isn't worth spit for that one.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 10:58 am
by ZZZX
I dont get why you support my wagon :M
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 11:07 am
by Thor665
Active lurking in the form of lying about your work on forming reads.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 11:08 am
by Thor665
How'd you lose those, by the way? Computer crash? Forgot to save them? Forgot where you saved them? What?
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 11:10 am
by ZZZX
In post 2111, Thor665 wrote:How'd you lose those, by the way? Computer crash? Forgot to save them? Forgot where you saved them? What?
I just have no idea where they went. Including 25 pages of a novel I was writing (latest save disappeared?) that I have rewritten today :>
Yea I know. Noone does. But how does that makes me scum? Cant scum also make reads? Would scum make up execuses that appear so fake? The only reason I am using the excuse I am using is because it is real. No freaking reason for scum to do something like what I did. Look freaking closely ...
I love your enthusiasm. Kill em all, let Mod sort em out! No seriously, I have a gut Town read, we'll see if you've fooled me, in time.
a quick pedit I second the nomination!
@ ZZZK You've Town read both Thor and I, promising a post later to explain more. Is it later yet?
VOTE: ZZZK
At this time, I can't even fake a reads list. I have a few scumspects, and a group I think are Town. Even among them, I'm not firm on them yet.
As far as Necro, unless I see an @ directed to me, I'm skimming his posts. Burden of Proficiency aside, they were wrong on the lynch, very wrong on Talah, and wrong on me.
In post 1997, Malakittens wrote:Dude man, if Titus is scum then it basically confirms Jon as scum in my eyes.
If/when I flip Town, how would that effect your read on Titus?
In post 2009, Malakittens wrote:Fine, ignore the fucking slip, but I'm sure that Titus is scum based on behavior alone.
Actually, the last game I played with Titus, the lady who had the slot before Titus had said "help me bus
my partner
in thread. Titus won as scum, even though there was plenty said about the "slip". I'm not scum with Titus this game, though.
Reading through your ISO, I get the feeling you're Town. Your posts read naturally, progressing with the thread. I can easily see the points you're arguing.
In post 1867, Titus wrote:None of my prods are empty, hence why I am following up on my statements and wanting discussion. It absolutely is an acceptable argument.
Titus has been asking good questions, expecting answers that'll help sort slots. Call it WKing, or whatever, I think she's Town.
In post 1877, Titus wrote:Necro, how the hell do you get off chiding me for not working with anyone and then blatantly ignore my posts.
That's Necro's strategy this game, have scum reads from the beginning and push them at any cost. They would be a good flip for association tells.
@ Jordan What did you figure out about your PR?
I still think Rach received a scum Role PM.
Tentative Town read on SKOT, truth is, I haven't been paying a lot of attention to this slot.
Next several days, I'll be busy, but I'll check in as time allows.
@ ZZZK What did you use to do your reads list with?
@ ZZZK Looking back over your reads list, maybe you're not Town reading us, your list is hard to follow. What are your reads for all the TBCs?
If Titus is scum this time, I'll probably start Policy Lynching you! JK
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 2:16 pm
by Sharpest-knife-on-tree
In post 2118, jon_h61 wrote:@ ZZZK Looking back over your reads list, maybe you're not Town reading us, your list is hard to follow. What are your reads for all the TBCs?
If Titus is scum this time, I'll probably start Policy Lynching you! JK
oh good lord this sounds like distancing- maybe mastin is right about the slot after all...
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 2:18 pm
by Malakittens
Lynch Titus first, then Jon, but yeah I think they are both probably scum.
The bad thing w/ Rach is she lurks either alignment, but she normally does townier things as town and I haven't thought about ISO'ing her, but I feel like if ZZZX is indeed mafia then Rach could
maybe
be bussing.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 2:23 pm
by Spring Starflower
my wish came true. please flip scum.
VOTE: zzzx
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 3:34 pm
by Jordan_Downey
VOTE: zzzx
I'm not even concerned that all of his list is scum or I'm not talking about it, suspicion tends to come from town. I don't like the fact that he says, I have these reads. I have these reads. I got a read list typed up blah blah. Then when he gets his reads, they are all crap. It's like he looked at the activity log and that's where most his reads came from. Like he is not reading the game at all or paying attention to much. It all feels quite like he's trying to look lack a lazy I don't know whats going on town and not being very successful at it.
Posted: Sat Jun 28, 2014 4:08 pm
by TiphaineDeath
How bout this thor, titus stalled hard, and as soon as I started actually advocating for another counter wagon at all there were three more votes on ZZX. If one of titus or Spring isn't scum I will eat my hat.
I'll probably start Policy Lynching you! 
JK