Mafiascum.net

both lists are alphabetized

]
Shoshin

Town unless lylo then conf!scum
Shoshin

Town to worry about if they make it to lylo but not quite conf
The worst

Reads list ordered town to scum
Chickadee
WhemeStar
Taly
Random
Sajj
AA9

In post 2124, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:

In post 2118, Reality Check wrote:

Commander Shepherd
Nancy Drew 39
Reality Check
Shoshin

ArcAngel9
Chickadee
randomidget
Scioness Sajj
Taly
The Worst
WhemeStar

that's a good operational townblock to start from at least

idk maybe I'll follow up on this with another read through at some point

Why is the worst, second to last in your readslist? How is their Creature progression remotely scummy?

In post 2125, Reality Check wrote:both lists are alphabetized

So your town core (which I can only see by quoting you) and your scum core. Okay but why is the worst,not green? How can being mvp pushing Creature lynch be remotely scummy?

In post 2123, Commander Shepard wrote:

In post 2118, Reality Check wrote:

Commander Shepherd
Nancy Drew 39
Reality Check
Shoshin

ArcAngel9
Chickadee
randomidget
Scioness Sajj
Taly
The Worst
WhemeStar

that's a good operational townblock to start from at least

idk maybe I'll follow up on this with another read through at some point

I would put Shoshin a darker green than us. Mainly Shoshin is town because her flip will happen before mine. If she ever makes it to lylo she is policy.

that's not something I'm worried about; I think I'm starting to understand the gamestate now, and if I'm accurate, then that will be sorted out before lylo.

Shepard, you realize that you're incentivizing scum to leave me alive until LYLO?

nancy, I'm not factoring my reads into this

that's a "strongly-town-indicative-mechanically" list and an "everyone-else" list

In post 2129, Shoshin wrote:Shepard, you realize that you're incentivizing scum to leave me alive until LYLO?

this is a non-issue unless something majorly fucked is going on

In post 2126, Commander Shepard wrote:]

Commander Shepherd
Nancy Drew 39
Reality Check

Shoshin

Town unless lylo then conf!scum
Shoshin

Town to worry about if they make it to lylo but not quite conf
The worst

Reads list ordered town to scum
Chickadee
WhemeStar
Taly
Random
Sajj
AA9

Why are people reading Taly scummy?

In post 2128, Reality Check wrote:

In post 2123, Commander Shepard wrote:

In post 2118, Reality Check wrote:

Commander Shepherd
Nancy Drew 39
Reality Check
Shoshin

ArcAngel9
Chickadee
randomidget
Scioness Sajj
Taly
The Worst
WhemeStar

that's a good operational townblock to start from at least

idk maybe I'll follow up on this with another read through at some point

I would put Shoshin a darker green than us. Mainly Shoshin is town because her flip will happen before mine. If she ever makes it to lylo she is policy.

that's not something I'm worried about; I think I'm starting to understand the gamestate now, and if I'm accurate, then that will be sorted out before lylo.

Yeah if I ever die can I count on you and Nancy to push my reads?

I am really putting myself out here.

Taly hasn't posted.

In post 2129, Shoshin wrote:Shepard, you realize that you're incentivizing scum to leave me alive until LYLO?

In post 2131, Reality Check wrote:

In post 2129, Shoshin wrote:Shepard, you realize that you're incentivizing scum to leave me alive until LYLO?

this is a non-issue unless something majorly fucked is going on

+1

Pretty much you are on me every fucking night.

Not being on me is a mistake.

Shepard, why are you townreading Reality?

In post 2136, Shoshin wrote:Shepard, why are you townreading Reality?

Because they are a townread.

In post 2130, Reality Check wrote:nancy, I'm not factoring my reads into this

that's a "strongly-town-indicative-mechanically" list and an "everyone-else" list

Oh okay, I guess that makes more sense. I’ve had a strong townread on the worst and his entirely believable Creature progression has just solidified it but otherwise, most people are null.

In post 2137, Commander Shepard wrote:

In post 2136, Shoshin wrote:Shepard, why are you townreading Reality?

Because they are a townread.

No shit. Why?

time to sleep

have a good morning everyone

In post 2139, Shoshin wrote:

In post 2137, Commander Shepard wrote:

In post 2136, Shoshin wrote:Shepard, why are you townreading Reality?

Because they are a townread.

No shit. Why?

Because my laser pointer didn’t scare them.

Ha no. Seriously it’s because of a gutread in how she has responded to things.

I am tired going to bed now.

In post 2133, Commander Shepard wrote:

In post 2128, Reality Check wrote:

In post 2123, Commander Shepard wrote:

In post 2118, Reality Check wrote:

Commander Shepherd
Nancy Drew 39
Reality Check
Shoshin

ArcAngel9
Chickadee
randomidget
Scioness Sajj
Taly
The Worst
WhemeStar

that's a good operational townblock to start from at least

idk maybe I'll follow up on this with another read through at some point

I wonder if I die tonight because Nico pretty much spewed me IC.

I would put Shoshin a darker green than us. Mainly Shoshin is town because her flip will happen before mine. If she ever makes it to lylo she is policy.

that's not something I'm worried about; I think I'm starting to understand the gamestate now, and if I'm accurate, then that will be sorted out before lylo.

Yeah if I ever die can I count on you and Nancy to push my reads?

I am really putting myself out here.

I wonder if I die tonight since Nico pretty much spewed me IC.

Nancy, you aren't dying until you reevaluate that read on Random.

In post 2143, Shoshin wrote:Nancy, you aren't dying until you reevaluate that read on Random.

Listen, have you considered how horrible it would be for town to have Angel in lylo, even if your theory is correct? She would be forced to mislynch town. So. even if you’re right about her - and that’s one ginormous IF - she is still a liability to town.

Why am i not apart of the townbloc

why arent we lynching chick

Because Chick is more likely town than AA9
And even if AA9 is town and we are wrong she needs to die.

I don't really object to any of the read lists flying around but can someone gimme an indication on who is mechanically town vs just prob/obvtown atm?