Is it weird to anyone else that CT went looking for TMI tells in everyone's ISO and found only the least incriminating one in mine? It's kinda been bugging me.
Like, just look at this, let's even accept that Nancy honestly thought TPFKAP knew exactly who their teammates were.
Is she *agreeing* that this is distancing?
Is she *disagreeing*?
Is she discussing her personal thoughts on anything?
Or is she making noise and hoping someone else will attack a slot for something?
Pedit: I am fine with you not wanting to mine. But at that stage YOU'VE ALREADY TAKEN THE DEBATE AS FAR AS IT CAN GO BECAUSE BUJABER ISN'T GOING TO CLAIM SCUM IF HE'S FAKING HIS THEORY.
I agree you can decided this for yourself and get back to us - I fail to see the point of the debate in helping you, he stated his theory, you noted your hole - thus endeth the excitement.
Sheep me on Nancy Drew?
I suppose it's possible I had it backwards with RC v Tora.
But I still feel that the manner in which Tora declared his 3p read on Elsa, and then bragging about it was over-the-top and unlikely to come from scum.
Thanks for reminding me of this. You all get to be asked the question that I would normally keep to my chats with Drixx in private:
Tora+Elsa scum team, setting up a play as a mafia doctor? Thoughts?
Please send in you night action before the deadline expires
Night Deadline (expired on 2018-10-15 22:00:00)
Aha! Proof that I was right and that Thor is pushing a lynch on me for scummy reasons. It says right in the fucking role flip that LD/TPFKAP knows exactly who her teammates “Hands of Blue” are but not the other way around. So since HoB don’t know about LD (TPFKAP), LD certainly knows about them. So therefore
any vote that TPFKAP made is possibly an associative read that can possibility help town discern who HoB are.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 7:51 am
by Jingle
Publically claiming Doc in multiball as scum would be incredibly dangerous. Especially publically claiming Doc that town has to lynch before endgame.
The standard version knows their teams identity, isn't known, and loses if they are the last member of their faction.
This one, as per the flip, did not now their teams identity, presumably wasn't known, and inherited the kill of their faction if they were the last member.
I just read it. Read the role flip. It confirms what I’m saying.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 7:52 am
by BuJaber
But the role PM doesn't mention names of players like [redacted] & [redacted] which is what is the usual mod standard around here.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 7:55 am
by Jingle
It confirms the FLAVOR of the scumteam. It is arguably possible that the mod removed the section on whom the HoB are, but unlikely.
Anyway, there's a solution:
@A50: Was the HoB traitor informed of their scummates identities?
Like, just look at this, let's even accept that Nancy honestly thought TPFKAP knew exactly who their teammates were.
Is she *agreeing* that this is distancing?
Is she *disagreeing*?
Is she discussing her personal thoughts on anything?
Or is she making noise and hoping someone else will attack a slot for something?
Pedit: I am fine with you not wanting to mine. But at that stage YOU'VE ALREADY TAKEN THE DEBATE AS FAR AS IT CAN GO BECAUSE BUJABER ISN'T GOING TO CLAIM SCUM IF HE'S FAKING HIS THEORY.
I agree you can decided this for yourself and get back to us - I fail to see the point of the debate in helping you, he stated his theory, you noted your hole - thus endeth the excitement.
Sheep me on Nancy Drew?
I suppose it's possible I had it backwards with RC v Tora.
But I still feel that the manner in which Tora declared his 3p read on Elsa, and then bragging about it was over-the-top and unlikely to come from scum.
Thanks for reminding me of this. You all get to be asked the question that I would normally keep to my chats with Drixx in private:
Tora+Elsa scum team, setting up a play as a mafia doctor? Thoughts?
-Cerb
Thor sr me for making logical assumptions based on what was explicitly stated in TPFKAP isn’t?
I don’t even understand what you’re talking about here. EJ claimed to have been on Cheeky, correct? Well, if Toog is LR, then how could he still be alive unless there’s another protective in the game?
???
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 7:59 am
by BuJaber
RR .. that'd be an even worse way to attract attention as scum. What would be their end goal?
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 7:59 am
by Nancy Drew Shogunate
In post 2131, BuJaber wrote:But the role PM doesn't mention names of players like [redacted] & [redacted] which is what is the usual mod standard around here.
No, and why would it? When does the mod ever reveal the entire scumteam in a flip? Can you point to a single game, where this has happened. Necromancer obviously excluded - since that was a mod error.
Like, just look at this, let's even accept that Nancy honestly thought TPFKAP knew exactly who their teammates were.
Is she *agreeing* that this is distancing?
Is she *disagreeing*?
Is she discussing her personal thoughts on anything?
Or is she making noise and hoping someone else will attack a slot for something?
Pedit: I am fine with you not wanting to mine. But at that stage YOU'VE ALREADY TAKEN THE DEBATE AS FAR AS IT CAN GO BECAUSE BUJABER ISN'T GOING TO CLAIM SCUM IF HE'S FAKING HIS THEORY.
I agree you can decided this for yourself and get back to us - I fail to see the point of the debate in helping you, he stated his theory, you noted your hole - thus endeth the excitement.
Sheep me on Nancy Drew?
I suppose it's possible I had it backwards with RC v Tora.
But I still feel that the manner in which Tora declared his 3p read on Elsa, and then bragging about it was over-the-top and unlikely to come from scum.
Thanks for reminding me of this. You all get to be asked the question that I would normally keep to my chats with Drixx in private:
Tora+Elsa scum team, setting up a play as a mafia doctor? Thoughts?
-Cerb
Thor sr me for making logical assumptions based on what was explicitly stated in TPFKAP isn’t?
I don’t even understand what you’re talking about here. EJ claimed to have been on Cheeky, correct? Well, if Toog is LR, then how could he still be alive unless there’s another protective in the game?
???
The fuck are you talking about? I'm not talking about Toog here, so why are you talking to me about them?
I'm talking about *your* slot, and Toog isn't relevant to this at all.
-Cerb
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:00 am
by Jingle
Option A. Additional protective.
Option B. All scum holstered their shots.
Option C. Toog is kill immune.
Option D. Toog came up with a rather impressive fakeclaim in a rather impressive amount of time after seeing no flips.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:00 am
by Reasonably Rational
In post 2134, BuJaber wrote:RR .. that'd be an even worse way to attract attention as scum. What would be their end goal?
I mean, I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt and assuming you're being bad town. Why can't I assume they're being bad scum while I investigate the hypothetical?
-Cerb
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:01 am
by BuJaber
I'm asking for real here not just to dissuade you. It'd be a fascinating scum gambit if they are actually scum.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:02 am
by Nancy Drew Shogunate
In post 2132, Jingle wrote:It confirms the FLAVOR of the scumteam. It is arguably possible that the mod removed the section on whom the HoB are, but unlikely.
Anyway, there's a solution:
@A50: Was the HoB traitor informed of their scummates identities?
You know that mysterious pair going by “Hands of Blue” are also in pursuit of the Tam siblings on behalf of the Union, but they are not notified of your identity.
In post 2131, BuJaber wrote:But the role PM doesn't mention names of players like [redacted] & [redacted] which is what is the usual mod standard around here.
No, and why would it? When does the mod ever reveal the entire scumteam in a flip? Can you point to a single game, where this has happened. Necromancer obviously excluded - since that was a mod error.
You misunderstood..
The typical mod way of flipping scum or traitor who knows his buddies in this site is to literally use "[redacted]" instead of the player name. The role PM here did not have that. It's reasonable to assume TPF did not know the actual players only their flavor.
In post 2134, BuJaber wrote:RR .. that'd be an even worse way to attract attention as scum. What would be their end goal?
I mean, I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt and assuming you're being bad town. Why can't I assume they're being bad scum while I investigate the hypothetical?
-Cerb
It is possible. We shouldn't play towards it, because honestly if they're bad scum we should catch them on other reasons, but it is theoretically possible.
And the scum equity is negative. It actually makes them less likely to win than not claiming at all, because EJ's flip paints really bad associatives with Toranaganate in that case, and EJ is likely to flip before LYLO.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:06 am
by Almost50
In post 2132, Jingle wrote:It confirms the FLAVOR of the scumteam. It is arguably possible that the mod removed the section on whom the HoB are, but unlikely.
Anyway, there's a solution:
@A50: Was the HoB traitor informed of their scummates identities?
Only their flavor, but not the players/slots
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:06 am
by Reasonably Rational
In post 2139, BuJaber wrote:I'm asking for real here not just to dissuade you. It'd be a fascinating scum gambit if they are actually scum.
I mean, Elsa *wanted* to be publicly leashed, ensuring that their heals couldn't be viewed as a threat by any killing entities, while also claiming neutral and thus a potential ally to every faction. Seems like a reasonable path to take if one wanted to minimize the odds of being cross killed for at least one half of your team. They also claimed ascetic, dissuading anyone from spending on action on checking any of their claims.
All in all, reasonable scum line to take, especially if the player in question is known for playing in a "survivor" type way.
-Cerb
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:07 am
by Jingle
Always assume scum is good, town is bad, and any surprises will be pleasant ones. Unless you're scum, then you know scum is good and town is bad
Scared of Jareth (Mafia): You are too scared of Jareth to side with the town.
Traitor! (Traitor):
You are a traitor and are not part of the main mafia faction and are endgamed if they are all removed. They do not know your identity.
Sweet (Investigation-Immune): Anyone trying to determine your alignment would believe that you are aligned with the town.
You win when the Goblins have sent all of the Town to the oubliette or nothing can prevent this from happening.
Your fakeclaim is, well, Hoggle. You don't get a different one.
Your scumteam consists of [redacted].
Night has begun and will end about 6:00 PM EDT on the 21st.
I’m officially stupid.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2018 8:09 am
by Reasonably Rational
In post 2145, Jingle wrote:Always assume scum is good, town is bad, and any surprises will be pleasant ones. Unless you're scum, then you know scum is good and town is bad
Shh Jingle, let me keep playing with the person who doesn't know that I know these things. (Like literally, you can find a lot of my games where I say this exact thing.)
