I was rereading day 2 yesterday. I had Majiffy and Svenskt both leaning town. When Svenskt replaced out I moved him from leaning to strong town read, but didn't adjust my Majiffy read at all until after nightfall. Then I thought that if Majiffy didn't start some serious analysis day 3 he had to be scum. Day 3, no analysis, just more tunneling. Will be a lot more cautious about him in the future.
- f
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 1:40 am
by ArcAngel9
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 1:41 am
by Selkies
I think the key to identifying majiffy/jen for us was aa9's claim, surprisingly enough. With that, we POEd it down to Majiffy/Jen/Rach, and when we eliminated Majiffy/Rach and Jen/Rach, it had to be Majiffy/Jen.
Curious to see scum QT. Majiffy played a good game, fery MVP. Couldn't have won it without her.
yeah..scum QT and dead QT please..
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 1:42 am
by RachMarie
totally makes sense too
strongman to overcome doc protection, but only one shot so it does not completely nullify the doc, and of course it would have overcome the one shot bp if had targeted on the same night while using the one shot strong man.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 1:46 am
by ArcAngel9
In post 2152, Selkies wrote:I think the key to identifying majiffy/jen for us was aa9's claim, surprisingly enough. With that, we POEd it down to Majiffy/Jen/Rach, and when we eliminated Majiffy/Rach and Jen/Rach, it had to be Majiffy/Jen.
-orci
that one 1 shot body guard man...crazy
and jakes 1 shot bulletproof make sense to me why there wasn't night kill on night 2
i somehow also considered that it you that mafia targeted, but i couldn't open that point becuz my claim doesn't go with it... but when jeniffer counter claimed and how majiffy started busssing, it confirmed me that it is majiffy and jen.
She keeps using RL excuses, various postponements, lists of questions without follow up, then IIoA about town blocks... she's scum.
VOTE: Jennifer
Yep.
Your read was part of what we factored in.
Rereading day 2 I don't understand why we lynched Varsoon.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 1:50 am
by ArcAngel9
i feel the balance is good.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 1:54 am
by RachMarie
I had been pushing Jen for days
@ Selikes with Jiffy best way to deal with him is kinda like with Thor, figure he is town at first, use his abilities for scum hunting, and if he is still around by day 3 or 4 and definitely by LYLO then lynch him he is scum
So the 1-shot BP would cancel out with the 1-shot strongman (roughly). But toss in a confirmable IC?
I dunno, I feel like town had 1 PR too many.
That's why I had so much trouble believing it when AA9 outed as doctor. If our not being dead hadn't made the day 4-1, which was incomprehensible for a scum team to want, I probably would have wanted to lynch her.
Sometimes "too many" specials works in scum's favor. Could have happened in this game if the nights had worked out differently.
- f
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 1:54 am
by Selkies
In post 2159, Selkies wrote:Rereading day 2 I don't understand why we lynched Varsoon.
Because I screamed at you to lynch varsoon iirc. My bad.
@ Selikes with Jiffy best way to deal with him is kinda like with Thor, figure he is town at first, use his abilities for scum hunting, and if he is still around by day 3 or 4 and definitely by LYLO then lynch him he is scum
yabbut there has to be scumhunting. what we got in this game was a lot of tunneling, not scumhunting.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:07 am
by orcinus_theoriginal
Also Rach, that's not a great strategy. Because eventually you'll be in a game with you and Majiffy as town, and scum will leave you and Majiffy alive for you to mislynch him at lylo.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:22 am
by Jake from State Farm
In post 2147, ArcAngel9 wrote:now rest of you die with shame for suspecting me after everything i did to win this game
HUH!!!
Jake, I'll forgive you for this!!!
and rest of you, thanks for playing great game. Good efforts
And BORK, thanks for moderating it. you're a great mod!!!
You will forgive me? Da fuck?
You act like a whiny bray cause you don't get your way and so you insult me and I didn't do jack shit to you and you will forgive me?
Good game bork, glad I could help you out.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:23 am
by Jake from State Farm
*brat
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:28 am
by Selkies
indirect vs direct insults.
Neither really bother me. I just wanted us all to play the game.
- f
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:30 am
by Jennifer
Good game, guys! And I think I can safely say now that I much prefer being town to scum... I feel bad lying and much prefer helping town figure out who is out to get us.
I don't mind sharing mafia qt, once Majiffy weighs in, I'm happy to post it if he doesn't.
This game was a challenge for me given the pace (I definitely did not expect a 87-page micro game), but definitely a learning experience! In retrospect, I should have killed Rach last night (not that it looks like it would have changed the outcome).
I hammered Varsoon because I didn't expect to live to the next day (I believed Selkies PGO claim). What a surprise that Arc protected them that night!
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:42 am
by Selkies
you targeted us even though you believed our claim.
whoa.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:46 am
by borkjerfkin
so yeah, the balance here really depended on a number of things:
1) town only had one confirmable PR
2) doc + bp could easily draw doubt into what actually blocked a kill
3) strongman needed to be used a little more strategically than I saw it used here.
Night actions coming.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:47 am
by Selkies
that means AA prevented 2 nks. good work.
Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 2:47 am
by borkjerfkin
ArcAngel9 protects Majiffy (succeeds)
Jennifer strongmans Icebox (succeeds)
result
Icebox Dies
ArcAngel9 protects Selkies (succeeds)
Jennifer kills Selkies (fails: blocked by ArcAngel9)
result
nuttin
ArcAngel9 protects Selkies (succeeds)
Jennifer kills Selkies (fails: blocked by ArcAngel9)
