Mafiascum.net

Can you explain why Irrel, the strongest scum player in the game, is locktown to you?

I never called him this?

I will tell you what though. I have to reread some of the game atsomepoint. Ill see if I dont see some scum mot somewhere? cuz thats what we should be looking for.

hmmm 19 hours.

In post 2148, Fuscosco wrote:Are you saying he may?

Yes, I think he's the likeliest from priors.
What's your case on Shoshin? Explain the "interactions" and "associations"?

In post 2150, Shoshin wrote:Can you explain why Irrel, the strongest scum player in the game, is locktown to you?

Is this to me?
I don't really lock Town players.

Vedith, recap on the Volxen scum case?

If he is scum, its Irre/ScumRead/[3rd party who isnt obivous rn]

Fuscosco, I'm asking why you think Shoshin is scum.
Your argument is that she's the best "information lynch", if I read right.
I want to know the "associations and interactions" you're speaking of.

Scum wouldnt put two of themselves against any one of these, I feel. its super wifomy and we'd have all game to suspect them.

I dont trust vedi to produce a cohesive and detailed list of why 'volx is scum'

In post 2158, Auro wrote:Fuscosco, I'm asking why you think Shoshin is scum.
Your argument is that she's the best "information lynch", if I read right.
I want to know the "associations and interactions" you're speaking of.

relax. youre fighting for them harder than they are themselves.

We have 19 hours and need to consolidate on to a lynch.

I dont see volx as scum. I continue to see misguided newish town here.

Oh it's plurality vote, I think.
That gives scum more control over the lynch.
Right now Shoshin would be lynched considering plurality, right?

In post 2162, Fuscosco wrote:I dont see volx as scum. I continue to see misguided newish town here.

Volxen isn't new, but I know the player very well and he's very likely town.
But you're voting Shoshin, and I want to talk about that.

And I dont see shoshin as scum. Theyve dialed way back today, but in a good way.

From what Ive read this is where to go, and rereading more on SRs would give me scum number 3

Sure, youve convinced me. I mean if one has to die, Im comfortable with this as well.

Cool. I'd still love a case and rebuttal to Shoshin's self-case from anyone who wants her lynched.

In post 2164, Auro wrote:

In post 2162, Fuscosco wrote:I dont see volx as scum. I continue to see misguided newish town here.

Volxen isn't new, but I know the player very well and he's very likely town.

His style speaks for itself. He may not be new, but his style is one often used by new people. Its not denigrating.

In post 2146, Shoshin wrote:

In post 2141, volxen wrote:@Irrelephant, Do you think that scum!Shoshin would be able to reasonably predict that you would be willing to sacrifice yourself in order to stop her from getting nightkilled, as long as she could convince you that she is town? I'm just curious if you think that's a reasonable thought process to come from scum!Shoshin based on your history together, because if it is then it substantially reduces her risk in self-nominating as scum.

My prediction of Irrel's behavior around me is that he never sacrifices himself for me ever again because of what happened in Starcraft. I'm amazed he's doing it here and grateful but it's not at all what I ever would have predicted.

I agree that Shoshin could never have seen this coming as either alignment, it’s basically the most surprising thing I could do fhpov. I stand by it, though. I won’t be inviting or fighting my lynch

Don’t lynch Shoshin before lylo - and if I were still alive, I’d sheep Shoshin as long as she hit scum once every two phases.
Don’t lynch Alonzo before the day before lylo
Don’t lynch volxen or Auro unless they push each other’s lynch
Shoshin, save DT’s lynch for after you’ve hit a scum. Of your scumreads, he’s my townlean.

Any other questions about my reads or thoughts?

*unvoting or fighting