Mafiascum.net

In post 1, Jingle wrote:This game is 10:3.

OSTENTATIOUS wrote:

mastina

OSTENTATIOUS

Dannflor

Egix96

Binary Star

Chemist1422

Flavor Leaf

Arkham Asylum

Pine

Chickadee

CheekyTeeky

jjh927

Dr Easy Bake

Here are your flips, everyone

In post 986, Pine wrote:I have information softconfirming that DEB was scum.

I will not be elaborating.

So let’s move off of the “if DEB was scum” angle.

I'm confused rereading this, didn't Pine claim VT?

In post 1013, Pine wrote:Scum has practically no reason to bus.

DEB’s EOD wagon was likely 100% Town, though it’s possible someone was bussing out of habit.

scum are mathematically guaranteed to have bussed and this post also didn't make sense at the time

I feel like I'm scumcasing Pine but I'm literally just rereading isos

I've been reading through d1 again and I'm really confused as to how Pine isn't just scum here????????

~ Poison Ivy

FL swung by briefly (I outed, he commented) but hasn't had time to hit Krazy's question yet

In post 1405, Pine wrote:

In post 1383, NerfedBuJ wrote:For what it's worth I didn't ask pine to claim more details just for the lols. I wanted to gauge the strength of the soft guilty.

I'm no where near as confident as FL about it but I still lean towards DEB being town.

I'm like 90% confident. It's plausible I'm misreading the slip/tell I caught, but the lack of a night kill really seals the deal. Either the scumteam no-killed (entirely possible) or DEB was not a Doc Enabler. You don't have a save N1 if the Doctor is switched off.

So this is interesting when compared to:

In post 736, Pine wrote:ANNOUNCEMENT: I have done a meta deep dive (for certain values of "deep") on DEB and it significantly weakened some of my concerns about him. I can't go into too many details for ~reasons~.

neither meta tell on DEB is ever explained

In post 1424, Pine wrote:

In post 1423, jjh927 wrote:AA is 100% locktown

note to self: reread context here

In post 1467, Pine wrote:

In post 1465, Egix96 wrote:Between all current wagons, my lynch preference is
mastina > Pine > BStar ~= Leaf > Asylum

Yeaaaah, not sure I like this.

"I'll vote any of these wagons if you give me a pretext to!"

It's hard for me to believe Pine makes a post this bad as town

In post 1510, Pine wrote:I don’t hate a JJH lynch, but a deadline crusade isn’t going to work

wolfy if jjh was scum

In post 1665, Pine wrote:I’m a VT. Massclaim is bad

See the thing is he hard back-pedaled the "info that softconfirmed"... if it was just setup spec based on DEB claiming doctor enabler, then why not just say that in thee first place?

-Kat

FL says he doesn't know but you can bring up the Last Knight Tomorrow

Yeah, Dann claimed his doc save in 1046; 1424 strongly implies that Pine understood the consequences of the claimed doc save which means that

In post 2067, Pine wrote:Okay, I missed this entirely. It's really irritating that no one brought it up (at all afaik) around the fake guilty, as it appears to completely exonerate AA.

is nagl

-kat

I've looked through Pine's ISO and I really don't think his thought processes in general line up

~ Poison Ivy

In post 2157, OSTENTATIOUS wrote:FL says he doesn't know but you can bring up the Last Knight Tomorrow

BuJaber had very town posts in D1
Chickadee had very town interactions with DEB on D1
we're noshit town

lynch Pine kill Cheeky if game isn't over

~ Poison Ivy

the scum is 100% within those two slots

~ Poison Ivy

VOTE: Pine

We need to hear from both Cheeky, and Pine. They'll both need to approve of whatever strategy we use going forward.

sure but I'm not seeing a universe where I support a lynch on anyone other than pine today

~ Poison Ivy

I actually want to work with Pine to solve this a little.
he did seem legitimately vexed by the lack of flips and I think now we actually have the game mechflipped down to 4 slots might inspire him a bit.

@Ank, mastina will be reading the dead pt & reareading the game tomorrow.

Well, I kinda don't think it's you Ost, although given the dead thread vig I guess you're not essential to town power so you're not really town off setup spec anymore.

Ank is arguing Chicka is town... now the problem here is that we know that Deb was bussing day 1, since he bussed himself!

but 708 is kinda not s/s, ank is right there -- I personally still dislike 238, though

also personally didn't love the hammer

cheeky is tricky -- according to your story, scum gambited on a mastina kill to save cheeky. but 2 scum would be dead, which means that if cheeky was last scum, then dead thread would vig cheeky tonight. This seems to imply that cheeky probably is not the last scum? although speculating based on the dead thread is rough when we do not have access to it

I personally would have gone pine-->chicka but ank seems pretty strong on chicka town. So if you want to talk about that, sure, but I think Pine should usually be the lynch here because he is the last scum

-kat

In post 2167, OSTENTATIOUS wrote:@Ank, mastina will be reading the dead pt & reareading the game tomorrow.

wow, this is the most mastina answer ever

uhh so I was kinda like "hey I'm gonna let Pine think he has a shot" in the dead thread because for a moment i forgot the last scum can probably still talk to DEB and jjh

so that was kinda dumb

@Pine, you do look the worst here. would you mind letting me know when you're around? I need your 2p PoE now we have the flips.

FL was right Day 2, with his Jjh/pine solve

It’s 2 am and I haven’t had internet since Monday.


But I’ll get to this at work tomorrow.

In post 2169, Arkham Asylum wrote:

In post 2167, OSTENTATIOUS wrote:@Ank, mastina will be reading the dead pt & reareading the game tomorrow.

wow, this is the most mastina answer ever

Mastina is never going to read this game. Mastina is never going to give input.

No worries. Welcome back!
Do you have 15 minutes before you go?