Mafiascum.net

My town play is not bullshit but I dont think you should have respect for my play considering the only game I played with you, I fucked up big time. Literally more than here. I was a town cop that found out you were ascetic and I still died day 2 because I claimed 3rd party scum.

In post 2103, shellyc wrote: @UNO I don't get what you arent satisfied by my responses towards you wanting me to explain the Adorable post
Can you point me to what you want me to answer

Ok I know this is getting really pedantic now, but I want to follow your logic here.

First: Did you interpret 101 as a town tell from Theta when you first read it?
I presume you're claiming the answer is yes.

Second: Did you interpret Isis townreading Theta as suggesting she had picked up on the towntell?
I presume again the answer is yes.

Third: Did you then interpret that as Isis also towntelling?
I presume again the answer is yes.

Fourth: Do you think that the entire game except me thought this or is it just specifically me who is supposed to be the mind reader?
I presume just specifically me.

Fifth: Did you therefore think that it was suspicious that I did not make these connections and so dismissed any concern about Isis when I voiced the one mildly suspicious thing that I thought about her in response to you asking me on my thoughts?
I presume the answer is yes.

Sixth: Do you think that is an at all reasonable accusation and are you thinking I am aware or not aware of the sample role pm at any point?

In post 2149, Noraa wrote:as far as I'm concerned you have only one finished town game with me and I was a RGB cop that claimed 3rd party scum.
If anything you should legitimately think my town play is bullshit.

i dont take marathon games very seriously and it was some multiball grand idea shenanigan game.

as for your competence:

you post 80+ times a day.
you are intelligent.
you get better at the game over time.
your WIM is very high

none of this suggests you are unable to do anything as scum.

In post 2141, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:ill make the case for you shelly.


Taylor says im 95% scum because I'm not soul reading anyone.

Gloria says I'm scum because I'm using meta on Taylor despite only have 2 completed games with Taylor.

Titus says I'm scum because I don't feel like answering her questions when she hasn't read the game.

Mush is busy writing fan-fiction about me.

Anyone else in the Pooky Fan-Club I'm missing?

Yeah I said you are scum for for egging LLD on if Noraa flips town even though I did the same thing

Actually though I am not sure you are scum even if a Noraa town flip happens, just somewhat suspicious

In post 2145, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:you are getting better at this pocketing thing


brw the reason I am unconvinced by your townspew is because I have a lot more respect for your play than anybody else here.

Is this RE Titus? Because I agree FWIW

Oh that's towards Noraa. I agree with that too

wow thats a hell of a defence to what was basically thought streaming my way through ISO posts shelly. Haven't even looked at you properly yet [3 pages behind at this post]

In post 2152, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:you are intelligent.

come again?
I just shot a mailman cop hybrid and a role watcher neighborizer in my last town game as novice 3 shot vig. I nearly pressed submit for killing the indecisive doc neighborizer day 3 also.

Your reasons are kinda terrible pooky.
back them up with my finished games please

are you trying to say you are not intelligent?

Im trying to say that you dont have any evidence that town!me is intelligent which is why saying and assuming that is just weird.

intelligence is not AI

In post 2161, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:intelligence is not AI

it is 100% impacted by alignment.
my town games I have made really poor decisions yet my scum games have just been getting better and better to the point that I'm fairly certain I would've won my last one had the weak fn not had me as a locktown and died the next day after targeting me and getting me guiltied and dead by day 2

no im talking about your intelligence as a person and being to get better at playing the game.

Intelligence comes of in the end, in decision making and results in this game. I dont think I'm stupid, no shit. But depending on alignment, I 100% come off as stupid when I am town. What matters is not am I stupid, but rather does alignment impact how the rest of the game sees me and the answer is yes.

In my first town game, I was sussed a bit after replacing in but didn't get any attention after hammering scum day 1(scum claimed my role and I didn't even cc, I just hammered) but I sussed four different people who were all vanilla town.
In my second town game, basically 80% of the slots replaced out like 5 times or something so it was too messy for anyone to really sus me tho I made one really bad decision that could've been disastrous towards the end
In my third town game, I got to E-2 the very first day of day 1 after BM tunneled me hard and I got angry but then counter wagons popped up and they ended up basically (imo) policy limming vt shelly. Obviously there was a case on her but really it was a policy lim imo. I survived day 2 cuz a guilty was claimed on Taylor. Survived day 3 and then had a claim to make me conftown.

In my first scum game, I was universally TRed. Lost because tracker Poe-ed.

In my second scum game, I repped in and town was super united. I tried but I failed. Mush caught me the moment I repped in. She was like eyo guys dis scum here and I panicked when my partner repped out and stuff.

In my third scum game, town wasn't united. No one was producing content. They gave me opportunity to high effort at the end and win the game.

In my fourth scum game, I was 100% universally TRed and died bc weak fn hinted hard that they were gonna target me and they died the next day.

*off

In post 2110, shellyc wrote:

In post 2109, Flea The Magician wrote:Adorable and Noraa scumbuddies? That's a corker of a bus if that's the case. Shelly is implicated in this quite heavily and is someone I need to read over anyway.

No Adorable is town

this is a really random misrep

are you accusing flea of misrep here

Theta I accused you of lurking when under pressure. what do you say to that?

In post 2167, Noraa wrote:Theta I accused you of lurking when under pressure. what do you say to that?

it is the weekend

also what pressure

uhhhhhhhhhh lel are you caught up or no? it dissipated cuz u disappeared entirely from the thread and other people started behaving weirdly :/

i am caught up

i did not notice anything about me though

well i noticed adorable completely missing the fact that i pushed noraa and adorable as scum buddies
is that what you were talking about

Huh I don't think I remembered wrong but maybe I'm the one that has to reread

I feel like the wall of Noraa competence between her scum game and town game has far been exceeded.
She basically took the breaks off.

The argument that Noraa is good scum and therefore seeming townie and AtEing is within her scope of play died the second she died in 3 of her games and started going on to a new level of town posting.
She has simply outpaced and outraced her scum game based on her level of experience.
The argument that she hasn't is no longer convincing to me.