show me a game where JS has done the read thing I was complaining about
JS sure can't, even though he says it's something he likes to do
so if you're going to white knight him, show me something
Is this good enough? I'm not entirely sure which read thing you're talking about in particular so I had to guess.
I'm not sure if this will satisfy you but I wasn't reading him as town because of meta. If you actually look at the intent behind his posts maybe you will just see incompetent townie.
Posted: Fri Dec 28, 2012 5:21 pm
by Om of the Nom
Using meta in this case is dumb anyway since you have no full fledged scum games to compare it to (only a third party game). If you're going to use meta against him then look at his 3rd party game and notice how his play here is
The Mini-Librarian - 0
DeltaWave - 0
Iecerint - 0
zoraster - 5 (Pretentiousdra, Wyrd, One Direction, Om of the Nom, JacobSavage)
Slumberpartybois - 0
TheButtonmen - 1 (DrippingGoofball)
Wyrd - 0
dramonic - 0
One Direction - 0
Nachomamma8 - 0
Ythan - 0
Zoidberg - 1 (TheButtonmen)
Quilford - 0
vollkan - 0
Om of the Nom - 0
Kawaii - 0
JacobSavage - 6 (DeltaWave, Iecerint, Quilford, Slumberpartybois, Zoidberg, zoraster)
Pretentiousdra - 0
BT - 0
TheTrollie - 0
DrippingGoofball - 3 (Kawaii, The Mini-Librarian, Bella)
Drench - 0
Not Voting - 6 (dramonic, Nachomamma8, Ythan, vollkan, BT, TheTrollie)
Posted: Fri Dec 28, 2012 6:30 pm
by Zoidberg
↑TheButtonmen wrote:Hell yeah I'm objecting to his lynch? As I clearly stated he's done nothing that looks terribly scummy, the comment about third party was due to my knowledge that the last time I played with him and he sat about coasting like this he ended up being SK but I'm not really feeling that strongly at the moment either.
Zoidberg I was asking about for a reason and after further reading I'm pretty comfortable saying he needs to be wagoned hard and long.
↑Ythan wrote:Zor wagon isn't better than Jacob wagon.
Are you sure?
Jacob's been stumbling over his answers like an incompetent player.
Zor is taking evasive action against anything presented against him.
One of these players is trying but failing, the other one is hiding behind the other main wagon. Take your pick.
Posted: Sat Dec 29, 2012 4:26 am
by DrippingGoofball
↑Om of the Nom wrote:
Jacob's been stumbling over his answers like an incompetent player.
Zor is taking evasive action against anything presented against him.
And Thebuttonmen is scum too.
So basically today we have our choice of three scumbags to lynch.
My priority is TBM>JS>zor
Zor is last only because his evasive maneuvers are working on me.