Mafiascum.net

In post 2172, Infinity 324 wrote:By the way, I doubt there was a mafia tracker

and

a mafia voyeur. So I doubt Maria is scum.

Can someone try and setup spec for me? I'm not good at stuff like that.

Maria, why don't you suspect vedith if you doubt there is a watcher and 2 doctors in the setup? Would you suspect him if I flipped town?

Yes

It's really scum sided for there 2 be 2 doctors imo

So with Rask... I don't like the whole DGB and HipLop scum day 2, but voting HipLop over DGB and putting HipLop before DGB in the scummier lynch part. It's a psychology thing imo.
It would make sense to distance from DGB while pushing for a HipLop vote here.

@Slandaar - Can you explain your thought process on why you were obvious town? This is not a dig, I just want to know.

In post 2176, MariaR wrote:It's really scum sided for there 2 be 2 doctors imo

Why?
Infinity claiming doc HipLop did makes no sense.

In post 806, Slandaar wrote:Leaving

LQ

,

KTS

,

DGB

, Maria,

Aristo

Possible that Slandaar got all the scum in this post?

@Maria - Why are you town again?

wtf...

In post 2181, Raskolnikov wrote:wtf...

Yes?

well at least there's 2 lynches available I guess

So I don't think I like Slandaar as the vote either.
To me it's Rask or Maria...

So as it stands, the claims we have are

Vedith - Watcher, watched Fire
Maria Tracker - Tracked Infinity to me (I guess tracker confirmed, just not alignment)
Slandaar - VT
Rask - VT
Infinity - Doc and visited me

Infinity is more or less confirmed, right? If Maria is town, then she saw him go to me, and I can't think of a scum role that would benefit them to visit me without me dying.

Tracker could be town or scum in this situation, but I feel tracker would be redundant as scum as powers are only night 2.
Game balance wise would suggest that a VT is a goon.

Slandaar I'm liking more from his early posts.

In post 2187, Vedith wrote:Tracker could be town or scum in this situation, but I feel tracker would be redundant as scum as powers are only night 2.

To clarify - I mean that Tracker is to see who has a role with scum... It doesn't matter who has roles for scum overall as they can only be used 1 night, and not after the information is gained.

alive
Raskolnikov - VT
Infinity 324 - Doc claim, visited vedith
Slandaar - VT (lateclaim)
MariaR - tracker (infinity visited vedith)
Vedith - watcher (checked fire)

dead
Firebringer- VT
Manuel87 - VT (claimed PR)
hiplop - Doc (late claim)
JarJarDrinks - Gunsmith
DrippingGoofball - Mafia PR/Watcher claim
LicketyQuickety - Mafia Goon/VT claim

So 4 VT, 5 PR of which 1 is scum
infinity town would mean double doc
maria + vedith town would mean town tracker + watcher

I think 4 VTs is reasonable though. Slan scum would mean 3 VTs to 5 PRs which is like eh.

Vedith did you get no result or no one visited

In post 2191, Raskolnikov wrote:Vedith did you get no result or no one visited

He was not visited.

In post 2187, Vedith wrote:Game balance wise would suggest that a VT is a goon.

Are you actually sure on this?

you bastard I see what you're doing. saying we should lynch in VTs and that you think slandaar is town

I kind of agree on tracker being useless except for the sole purpose of getting the player confirmed as a PR if they out results first and target PR

In post 2186, Vedith wrote:Infinity is more or less confirmed, right? If Maria is town, then she saw him go to me, and I can't think of a scum role that would benefit them to visit me without me dying.

I could be another track/watch role, but eh

In post 2187, Vedith wrote:Tracker could be town or scum in this situation, but I feel tracker would be redundant as scum as powers are only night 2.

I agree.

2 docs, gunsmith, watcher, tracker if all PRs are true
VS mafia voyeur, goon, ???

is this a reasonable level of power? also technically tracker as town has usage of checking 1 VT claim to make sure they haven't gone anywhere
I'm not sure if this was designed with early massclaim in mind

I think reviewers would take mass claim into account.

Right now I'm at:

-Slandaar doesn't fit in the scum team really
-Pretty sure rask is town
-Doubt scum have a tracker, so I think maria is town

Which would leave vedith scum by PoE, which makes sense. Vedith didn't want to lynch DGB until he counter claimed (which is, tbf, points in his favor). Kraska had DGB as lean town, then switching to voting her, then jumped on kts. DGB and LQ has vedith slot as town but didn't mention it much. The only problem is this interaction which I find really weird if kraska and LQ are both scum (incoming in next post...)

How does everyone feel about the VT count?