↑kanyeknowsbest wrote:good thing u didnt need a fakeclaim : ]
*cough* *cough* *cough* *cough*
i think that spring wanted you to be forced to claim mummy so that youd have a reason to use your pr body part stuff since the clues point to the mummy. so mean springchan~~
Well, the thing is. I had no plausible reason to pick up post restrictions. In addition to that, what I don't think you get is that the post restriction
is in and of itself a clue
, just not one the mod directly and explicitly provides.
Also that's not even the
second
version of The Broken Jug that I found in my research. What is this, I don't even, etc.
I think the mod was causing the visions. damn you vi, superwell played. I got you there! but you quickhammered me nicely I'm guessing you didn't really 'by mistake' hammer, right? just pretended?
wonderful game. my pm:
springlullaby wrote:
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 2:25 pm
by Vi
↑shos wrote:damn you vi, superwell played. I got you there! but you quickhammered me nicely I'm guessing you didn't really 'by mistake' hammer, right? just pretended?
Let's go with that.~
I actually didn't want to lynch you, but 1) it happened, and 2) had I actually brought you to LyLo you probably would
not
have tried to autowin with me, even though I had fought so hard to get that far
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 2:38 pm
by shos
this game could end with a both-independent win if you didn't lynch me..
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 3:20 pm
by Zar
you would have died shos, she was a serial killer >_>
TRAITOR
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 3:26 pm
by Zar
Nuwen what was that batshit claim you came up with?
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 3:28 pm
by Zar
Ah I see, so she was indeed Ninja SK
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 3:33 pm
by Nuwen
↑Zar wrote:Nuwen what was that batshit claim you came up with?
Just a batshit claim. My real role was investigate-immune possessor-thingy (where possession caused Parama to be the perpetrator of the scum kill). Two-man team.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 4:40 pm
by Zar
well it should be nominated for best role claim, frankly.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 4:47 pm
by Zar
↑Zar wrote:you would have died shos, she was a serial killer >_>
TRAITOR
no wait you were unkillable. >_>
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 4:56 pm
by Magua
Oh, this got unlocked before Flay got back to me about unlocking it for me. In retrospect, I probably should've gone with hasdgfas. Oh well.
Meh.
Being a bodyguard beloved princess is why I was so eager to claim a protective role. Wanted to get shot.
Game was meh. Would never have guessed that it was a 9v2v1 with a survivor thrown in. Happy with my calling of Yos and Zar as town. Sad that shos got lynched, especially given Nuwen's reactions to him in the thread, but as I said in the Dead QT, I'd probably be pretty suspicious of charter based on Nuwen-who-was-fakeclaiming-not-seeing-him-as-a-threat.
Still maintain that Vi's "I-don't-know-what-my-role-does" claim was bad and should feel bad, but can't overly much blame Zar for trusting his report. I would've gone for a third Mafia member over a bulletproof-and-essentially-all-but-investigation-proof-SK-in-a-game-that-already-had-a-survivor as well, had I lived.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 5:28 pm
by Magua
Other things:
Setup, as near as I can figure out, was this:
Mafia (2)
- Furcolow (some form of rolecop?)
- Nuwen (Investigation-Immune Tracker-Framer)
3rd Party (2)
- shos (Bulletproof Ascetic Survivor)
- Vi (Bulletproof Tracker-Immune SK)
Town (9)
- Hiraki (Doctor)
- Yosarian2 (assuming he's not lying about his role, limited vig)
- Zar (Tracker)
- charter (flavor cop)
- Elmo TeH AzN (flavor cop)
- kanyeknowbest (flavor cop) [1]
- Parama (jailkeeper)
- UberNinja (flavor cop)
- Magua (Beloved Princess Bodyguard)
Investigative-wise, the town got hosed and the non-Town got hosed only if they actually fakeclaimed, which they had pretty much no reason to actually do. As near as I can tell, only one person had a role that required them to fakeclaim (Nuwen), and that person was investigation immune. Vi's role arguably required them to fakeclaim[2]...but only upon the fifth kill, so, yeah. The real point for the scum being that it was a Vanilla-less game, and only Furcolow had a power that was at all claimable as a town power. Taking the flavor cops out, town's only other investigative role was a tracker...who all the killing roles were essentially immune to, and town had one hidden miller for (Parama). So, yeah.
Yeah.
Protection-wise, the town had (as near as I can tell) a doctor, a bodyguard, and a jailkeeper, plus both third parties being bulletproof. This is where I feel the Mafia, in particular, got shafted.
As near as I can tell, the dreams/omens/what not were provided by springlullaby and not by any Town roles during the game (...and were the only even possibly useful investigations in the game, which is....yeah.)
[1] kanyeknowsbest had springlullaby broaden his role in response to UberNinja dying.
[2] I am amazed that springlullaby didn't think about the fakeclaim situation before the game started (as none of the scum received one as part of their role), and then after the game started, handled the fakeclaim situation in such a way that, given the incredibly large number of flavor cops the game had, had any of the scum actually made use of, would've doomed them.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 5:42 pm
by Magua
Other other thing:
Survivor is a terrible role. Bulletproof survivor is even more terrible...er. Literally would've been a better setup in pretty much every way imaginable if shos' role had actually been a Mafia goon, IMO.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 5:47 pm
by Magua
Finally, the only things I don't know are:
- What the Demotic script was supposed to mean.
- Why Zar's track of Furcolow failed N1 (but at this point I would not be surprised if Furcolow was also some form of investigation immune)
- Where the dreams/visions (eg, Hiraki's vision) came from (assuming springlullaby)
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 5:55 pm
by Nuwen
Furcolow's ability was a rolecop/block combo. Bits of his PM are in our QT.
Posted: Sat Jul 21, 2012 6:00 pm
by Magua
↑Magua wrote:Finally, the only things I don't know are:
- What the Demotic script was supposed to mean.
Should've read Vi's spoiler about communication-with-springlullaby better (I skipped it originally as I knew Vi's role from collecting the PMs).
El-oh-el.
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 1:08 am
by Zar
Not exactly excited that all the antitown elements were untraceable, but meh.
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 1:09 am
by Zar
UberNinja wasn't a Forensic Investigator?
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 1:55 am
by Vi
↑Zar wrote:you would have died shos, she was a serial killer >_>
TRAITOR
No, I think Survivor and SK can win together.
But it would have been kind of hard to get shos to think of voting No Lynch in LyLo without either him thinking about it or me telling him. Me telling him means there's a good chance that shos-playing-Town would just vote me for the effort.
LOL Magua was a B.Princess. Wasn't that Katsuki's slot?
Although I kind of like the B.Princess/Bodyguard duality.
Vi's role arguably required them to fakeclaim[2]...but only upon the fifth kill, so, yeah.
Again making clear that fake flavor claim != fake role claim.
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 1:55 am
by Nuwen
↑Zar wrote:Not exactly excited that all the antitown elements were untraceable, but meh.
I wasn't immune to tracks if I submitted the kill myself, and I asked Spring how the possession ability would resolve if tracked:
SpringLullaby wrote:Possession and NK are considered independent abilities.
If Nuwen is blocked using possession, both the kill and the possession will be blocked.
If Nuwen is tracked using possession, Nuwen will be tracked to Polypheme Desroches, but not to the victim.
If Polypheme Desroches is blocked while possessed, the kill will fail.
If Polypheme Desroches is tracked while possessed, they will be tracked to the victim.
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 1:59 am
by Zar
So the visions revealed Shos, Nuwen and The Mummy, i think?
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 2:01 am
by Vi
↑Magua wrote:Still maintain that Vi's "I-don't-know-what-my-role-does" claim was bad and should feel bad
Um. Magua. I was surrounded by
extremely confirmable, unique, and flavorful roles
, not to mention
the mod explicitly telling everyone that the mummy was implicated in the N2 kill
. "Bad and should feel bad" is pretty much the only option. I believe the phrase I gave s-lully on N4 was "I hope nobody notices me surfing to victory on an invisible tsunami of bullshit", because THAT WAS THE ONLY THING I COULD DO. I respect that you were able to see through it - and thanks for dying when you did - but don't hate.
Also, this is my 10,000th post onsite. I am now a member of the No-Life Club.
Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 2:04 am
by Zar
Yeah, this is a SK deja-Vu of 1308 ._.
Next time some sort of death scene flickers an inch of your flavorful role you will die in the pits of hell Vi