Mafiascum.net

Ok now I'm not pushing a lurker now I'm pushing scum

Crisis averted

RCEnigma, do you scumread BooneyToonzExpert solely for sending out the barbs, or do you have other reasons? Why do you think BooneyToonzExpert admits to sending the barbs out in the first place if he's scum?

-Cosmic

Sorting and is exhausting. They're both town from tone. Content-wise: I read through chkflip's case and I think a lot of the reasons there (the LAMIST and shading anyone who scumreads her) is actually town-indicative or NAI for Mars. The Vecna progression I don't really see as scummy; could just be her changing her mind.

Hey, , if you had to order everyone into a quick shotgun reads list, do you think you could manage that for me please? Reasons aren't necessary; I just want to see where your reads are at.

-Cosmic

@page 30
VOTE: Auro

@page 32
VM/Xtoxm feels extremely TvT

@page 39
Bad feeling on george, scumlean

I'm trying a different style of questionining here, so bear with me.

, if you were looking for a loved one within {Michael Scott, sore feet, JJH}, and a mortal enemy within {GeorgeBailey, RCEnigma, Titus} - who would you pick from either category and why?

-Cosmic

Page 50:
feeling more confident on my scumread of my Michael Scott scumread

In post 2208, nomnomnom wrote:Page 50:
feeling more confident on my scumread of my Michael Scott scumread

I hope you're feeling alright, Nomo.

Anyway, where or which posts do the bad-George feelings stem from?

-Cosmic

Page 54:
Davesaz striking me as town just from a tonal standpoint, probably a mistake but whatever
reminiscent of TM2020
pedit:

In post 955, GeorgeBailey wrote:There's probably something beneficial to town for Vecna's role. I don't see why a role would be so blatantly anti-town. Maybe people who are cured get some sort of buff?
It's possible there's a doc right now who's reluctant to claim because they'll probably get NK'd.

In post 957, GeorgeBailey wrote:With a bunch of nulls, probably. I TR like 4 people right now.

In post 965, GeorgeBailey wrote:

Town

Jjh927, Venus and Mars
Krazy Katz, Auro

Null:

Vecna, Titus, Sore feet, Mechanic, The Fonz, Conspire, BooneyToonzExpert, Davesaz, Chronos
Chkflip, Kakeguri Addicts
nomnomnom

Scum

The lucky 4 gets a "nice" from me in a consecutive post

Extreme redflags on these posts considering that the TRs given were on top posters. Feels like scum "having to give" TRs if that makes sense. That's the impression I got reading this.
That and that mechtalk doesn't inspire me confidence.

page 55:
Really liked the hardstance of Fonz on Vecna's role, seems like Town trying to avoid a disaster
Just a lean though, wouldn't surprise me that scums are giving halftruths here

Yeah, I'm feeling less confident on too, but I have another question for him: Pregame, what impression did you have of how picks would work? That they would affect alignment/role, or both?

VOTE: GeorgeBailey

-Cosmic

Page 56: shows why I scumread Michael Scott
this need to wagon Expert comes out of nowhere.
He also brought it up when I first started catching up again in the late page 20s and instantly dropped it in favor of jokes.
This feels like either town without any conviction, or scum pretending to push something, and giving Auro's character this is probably the latter

Are u roleplaying as taly now conspire?

Vecna also probably town out of all this, honestly.

In post 2206, nomnomnom wrote:@page 39
Bad feeling on george, scumlean

In post 2208, nomnomnom wrote:Page 50:
feeling more confident on my scumread of my Michael Scott scumread

Did you skip the 40s or did you read 10 pages in 6 minutes?

Lots of fluffposting in there or thorough posts that I didn't read.
I just post what I think is relevant. If I don't post anything about certain pages it's that I don't have any strong beliefs.
I'll post a summary anyway.

In post 2213, nomnomnom wrote:giving Auro's character

What is my character as town?

Eh, actually, I want Dave to answer my questions before I look for a vote elsewhere.

VOTE: Davesaz

-Cosmic

In post 2218, Michael Scott wrote:

In post 2213, nomnomnom wrote:giving Auro's character

What is my character as town?

I probably imagine you don't give up an attempt to wagon someone that easily as you did early on.
Just strikes me as scummy.

Page 65:
Calling it right now, this BTE wagon is lynchbait and lead by scum.

I will concede that I've not been thinking much about this game, I am "coasting" in a certain sense in that I'm doing things without really paying much attention.
Conviction is something I can easily fake as scum, the lack of it at this stage of the game shouldn't be AI.

I was nearly mislynched as part of the *same* hydra for similar reasons in a previous game, btw.

In post 2221, nomnomnom wrote:I probably imagine you don't give up an attempt to wagon someone that easily as you did early on.

You haven't noticed that I was treating a lot of my pushes similarly this game? I've been <creating wagons - seeing what happens - move to another> pretty rapidly.
Your assessment of me is accurate, but not at this point of the game - it often happens a while later in games.
Is WF what you're basing this off of?