Flea, you either trust Yin mechanically here, or you don't. You keep giving me mixed signals; you seem to not trust it in instances like 2197 yet for things like your Tanner vote, you give off the impression it is one of the primary reasons for your read.
pedit: ???
Posted: Sat Jul 10, 2021 4:54 am
by clidd
It's just a theory (not that I think she's scummy or anything like that).
In post 2200, Ircher wrote:Flea, you either trust Yin mechanically here, or you don't. You keep giving me mixed signals; you seem to not trust it in instances like 2197 yet for things like your Tanner vote, you give off the impression it is one of the primary reasons for your read.
pedit: ???
I am trying to determine if Yin is mechanically good for a solve here, and I need more evidence to investigate. So far, all roads lead to Tanner.
My vote there is locked.
Posted: Sat Jul 10, 2021 5:10 am
by Tanner
i find it very unlikely that you think "all roads lead to tanner", when (1) chara is considered a criminal by yin too, (2) you had a tinfoil on chara specifically, (3) you had a townread on me during day one, which you didn't have on chara, (4) have you read any of the second half of day 1, seriously. no shade to chara, but if the two of us were the only people that could be voted today, i don't think anyone (other than you/robert apparently) would agree i'm a better flip there.
this feels like a desire to get specifically me out of the game rather than any genuine read. either salty scum or a condemner. which makes me wonder, why did flea say "the 3p"? i know yin claimed there's 3 factions, but the 3rd faction (if they even exist, which i'm not sold on) could be a second scumteam.
I figured it would probably be either Norwee or Ydrasse is scum could NK. So no wonder Ircher was adting that way.
So, I don’t know what criminal/non-criminal are exactly within the context of this game but I think it’s pretty damned obvious now that me/Ydrasse are town and Ircher is confirmed town.
She's doing more trying to solve yin/yang than scumhunting, which I don't think benefits us. Others may be guilty of it too, but I expect tweet to have insightful scumhunting thoughts.
She says I'm town which is silly cause I've barely been playing
Uhhhh let's see, Robert... what was i townreading him for earlier in the game... basically it was some of his early play. But granted, his play as a whole has been bad and he sat Ircher.
Also Robert why exactly are you voting Tanner when you aren't sure about how important the criminal business is? And you also spent most of your time on the criminal business but didn't think to question it's importantance until after you left. a little bit confused about that
Posted: Sat Jul 10, 2021 7:26 am
by Morning Tweet
This is like a whole ass wagon on Tanner which is incredibly bizarre to me. Like even for scum to do -- surely they can't expect that to gain traction? And the Tanner votes happened yesterday too
In post 140, Yang wrote:I'm a mage and I don't need a staff. My magic comes from my irrational hatred of Tanner.
In post 356, Amy Dunne wrote:If Yin and Yang don’t know who the scumteam is, what is their exact purpose in this game besides obviously entertaining us?
Actually:
Yin
?
Yang
?
My purpose is to make sure Tanner is either eliminated or nightkilled whichever he doesn't prefer. Well. That's one of my purposes. For sure.
i was gonna bring this up the other day in reaction to Tanner being a criminal but forgot. Now im wondering if robert/flea's pushes on tanner and tanner being a criminal and yang saying this stuff might be connected somehow
Posted: Sat Jul 10, 2021 7:44 am
by Amy Dunne
In post 216, Infinity 324 wrote:I've faked a "someone else carry me" mindset before as scum I think? It doesn't seem too hard if you feel not confident in your ability to fake scumhunt
In post 561, Infinity 324 wrote:Because I don't really see a reason for scum!him to make the push on datisi. I still don't understand why he wanted to townread datisi when he didn't know who datisi was, but it's enough for me to townread him for now.
This back and forth flipflopping on Robert seems weird. I’m not convincing this is SvS.
Posted: Sat Jul 10, 2021 7:53 am
by Flea The Magician
In post 2204, Tanner wrote:i find it very unlikely that you think "all roads lead to tanner", when (1) chara is considered a criminal by yin too, (2) you had a tinfoil on chara specifically, (3) you had a townread on me during day one, which you didn't have on chara, (4) have you read any of the second half of day 1, seriously. no shade to chara, but if the two of us were the only people that could be voted today, i don't think anyone (other than you/robert apparently) would agree i'm a better flip there.
this feels like a desire to get specifically me out of the game rather than any genuine read. either salty scum or a condemner. which makes me wonder, why did flea say "the 3p"? i know yin claimed there's 3 factions, but the 3rd faction (if they even exist, which i'm not sold on) could be a second scumteam.
I point you to 2171 or whereever my Yin solve is in this area.
Posted: Sat Jul 10, 2021 8:07 am
by Amy Dunne
In post 1546, Infinity 324 wrote:I don't see how my ircher read doesn't add up? The narrative of say he's gonna play this game differently --> plays differently by doing nothing still makes zero sense to me as scum, even if he doesn't want to play scum he can at least give a couple reads or something.
This post makes me think that scum would probably only push Ircher to save Infinity. I think scum weren’t likely on his wagon perhaps saw him as easy later miselimbait?