We Didn't Playtest This | Game over, everyone loses

[copper223]

Minus the tree stump, her vote is irrelevant.

[BBmolla]

Just read Toon's claim

lame

[Magua]

If Jackel is a town tracker I will eat my fucking hat.

Jesus Christ.

(The real irony is that every single person who is voting Peregrine has at least a 50% chance that they're voting a role that is stronger than a tracker.)

[Boonskiies]

Prodge

[Drixx]

What's the rational choice of lynch here? Most all of us apparently have very odd names for our roles, and thus that is weak evidence that Jackel may have been lying; however, he also could have just simplified his role down to what it does. After all, when I claimed, I claimed what my role did ... not the name of it or the name of the ability it gave me.

So the question is whether weak evidence is enough to risk getting rid of a tracker ... and it is further compounded by not at all knowing what PV's role might be or really anything at all about PV other than he's been a lurksack in this game and made an apology post to mods and gave the reasoning. I think he's been put on the replacement list for this game, so he can't come and claim and the slot is currently empty.

So do we want to lynch a claimed tracker or an unknown awaiting replacement?

(I didn't realize how long it had been since PV posted when I said that we should lynch him because he'd continue to just lurk going forward ... that doesn't really hold any water with the realization that he is well past the force replace time).

unvote

VOTE: Jackel

[BBmolla]

If Jackel is a town tracker I will eat my fucking hat.

Jesus Christ.

(The real irony is that every single person who is voting Peregrine has at least a 50% chance that they're voting a role that is stronger than a tracker.)

Gua you're town as fuck

Who should we lynch

[Drixx]

Prodge

Stop it. I know for a fact that you can be an annoyingly effective PITA to scum. Your lurking this game is either alignment indicative or bad form. Apply yourself!

[BBmolla]

2. I do not believe Jackal's claim.

Like?

Why put doubt on the wagon if you don't believe the claim? I don't get it

[BBmolla]

Before we all run off with Jackel votes into the sunset. there's now some issues that are on the table. Which I'll try to mull over the particular implications of what's going on.

Regardless of Drixx's answer, I was going to question BBmolla's claim to be a miller to one specific faction mafia. Because, that's just not how it works (apparently that works for Drixx). I wanted to know if Marquis's possible results could account for BBm's version of his miller claim. Like, for instance, if Marquis were told exactly what faction his target would be, instead of the general sense of "guilty/not guilty" which would cast doubt on BBm's claim. Mine already does, but I'm BP and it's possible cops / BPs won't quite mix there. But then, if originally I was a BP in a 13p mini, and the mods adapted it as I have explained, then why not do the same for cops?

So now I'm not sure what to think.

I've read this three times and I don't udnerstand what you've said

can you clarify

[Marquis]

VOTE: Jackel

Dan I'm still not discussing this today.

[Marquis]

I would also like conditional credit for drawing attention to Jackel first. The condition being that he flips scum. Otherwise, please only remember that post in which I expressed my thoughts about the simplicity of his roleclaim being a red herring mislynch in the setup.

[Drixx]

I would also like conditional credit for drawing attention to Jackel first. The condition being that he flips scum. Otherwise, please only remember that post in which I expressed my thoughts about the simplicity of his roleclaim being a red herring mislynch in the setup.

How do you manage to balance sitting up on the top of the fence like that? Doesn't the barbed wire hurt?

[ActionDan]

he's just kidding around. I'll vote jackel before deadline.

[LucianRoy]

Jackel is probably better than Pv, even though I feel like both would be probable mislynchs.
VOTE: Jackel

[Cerberus v666]

Drixx is the BP isnt he

Why are we lynching him

Right?????? Crazy people here. It's like you're trying to believe everything simultaneously, and then when you realize some of it is lies, you arbitrarily just pick something to not be true.

Lucian shoot copper

No.

fine

shoot Jackel

copper just keeps leading shitty wagons

Agreed.

Here, will be here till end of the day, not especially happy with major wagons, but I'll vote for whichever is needed to guarantee we get a lynch today. Using Molla's power is probably stupid overall.

[Cerberus v666]

Hmm. how long do we have? 2 hours? Vote count?

[Cerberus v666]

Oh. I just realized the deadline tag in every post from the mod apparently updates itself! SO we have 8 hours. I was trying to count the hours from the last time the mod posted. Alright, so, not nearly as bad as I thought it was, especially for all of you to be so silent.

[Oranje Crush]

VOTE: Jackal
PV looks like a scum compromise, don't touch it.
WHO SHOULD I VOTE?

[Oranje Crush]

TOMMOROW WE MASS CLAIM!
(Come at me scum tonight, I'll thank you for it.)

[Narninian]

VOTE: PeregrineV

because I don't want to lynch a claimed investigator day freaking 1.

[VysePresident]

So, yay.

-

I'm leaning Peregrine over Jackel, but honestly, I think both wagons are bad. (In effect, I'd prefer a shot in the dark to a meh lynch.)

(Apparently, it's already decided on Jackel.)

-

Is Lihin really not an option? Show of hands please, who would prefer Lihin over the other two?

- I'd still like opinions on Lihin, thanks!

-Why the heck is BRantz's claim supposed to have ConfTown'd him? As things stand, I literally do not care about his claim at all, bar the frustration.

-Why is it that the only people I can get to push Copper & Bulba are Copper & Bulba?

-For all my distrust of Bulbasaur, I will say that pushing back against Copper's 'case' more eloquently & rationally than I feel like doing is an excellent way to buddy up to me. I'll lynch you last.

-@Bulbasaur - That said, I

really

want that read progression from you, particularly in regards to myself. If you need to chat it up with Bulba, fine, but please get back to me on this.

-P-Edit - @Cerberus - (We have roughly nine hours as of the time of this post. The votecounts use a clock that automatically counts down, so they're accurate whenever you look at them.) P-Edit 2: Never mind. (Also, it's probably more like 8 & 1/2 by now.)

-I'm going to try and do a vote count. I may not make it back alive. (I honestly kinda want to just walk away from the thread.) P-Edit 3 - Done! I'm going to put it in it's own post, though.

[VysePresident]

Jackel (11) - Bulbasaur Commonwealth, Marquis, Drixx, Lucian, Lihin, Magua, Copper, BBMolla, Ogzin, Om, Orange

PV (5) - Dan, Cerberus, Vonflare, Death, Narnian

[VysePresident]

Oh yeah.

VOTE: Jackel

[VysePresident]

L-1, and all that.

[Cerberus v666]

hmm. ugh.

Vote: Jackel