In post 2229, CheekyTeeky wrote:For "not knowing who I am" to be town spewy, you have to know only town don't know who they are right? I didn't see it as a tell because I assumed noone had flavour. Now that we've seen a scum role PM we know that scum know that only town have not been given flavour. I don't know if it implicates chic or not but I think going down the route of a sky/McMenno lynch will show if there's something behind my reasoning plus give us good associatives on Chick, Tor, TW/jingle and other people mentioned in the Sky ISO.
Actually, if anything I think it's worse for the Chick slot than the Sky slot, and even then it's a really weak reason to suspect them.
When I looked at my role PM my reaction was more along the lines of "Huh, I don't have flavor. I wonder if that means something special for my character." When I look at ThePorkensFormerlyKnownAsPlayer's it looks more like "Oh hey, town doesn't have flavor. I might be able to grab some cred off of that." I don't think that Chick's post looks like it's designed to be a towncred grab more than a talking point, though, so I'm not inclined to scumread her for it atm.
I agree with you that Menno hasn't been particularly gamesolvey since his entrance though, and definitely approved of the pressure you were putting there until you backed off on the wagon.
The NancyDrewganate wagon, on the other hand feels pretty gross. Thor's vote there is both telegraphed and expected, but the rest of it doesn't leave me feeling like any of those players really expect it to flip scum.
CT and EJ both sound like they expect a townflip there and simply don't have anywhere else to push right now. Menno doesn't strike me as having a good read on the gamestate, and what amounts to a policy lynch on his counterwagon is pretty NAI in light of that. Toogles and Flick are outright sheeping.
And that's the only wagon we've got. For a wagon based around IIoA and derp, there's surprisingly little in the way of what looks like derpBussing (Not poorly executed bussing, but rather the bussing of a plyer who appears to be locked in derpmode). I'd expect at least someone from NDS's scumteam to throw them under the bus here when Thor came calling for the wagon, and 0% of the votes look like they might be that.
And, if Nancy's teammates aren't bussing, they're equally not trying to direct the wagon away from her. There have been two pushes outside of NDS today, Toog's attempt to resurrect my Buj wagon and CT's attempt to wagon Menno.
Also of note, none of NR, Chick, Mala, nsg, and, until very recently me, have been posting substance today. Chick and Mala are virtually V/LA and have been for a while. NR is being NR. I actually forgot nsg was playing this game until I looked at the player list, and she's definitely posting enough IIoA herself to make that slot suspicious as all hell. RR has been mostly setup speccy himself.
Outside of Thor (Full on deathtunnel, whether right or wrong) and CT (Probably wrong by my reckoning but at least trying), Gamma, a player known for his low effort posting style, has been one of the most active in actually attempting to sort people's alignments. There are plenty of suspicious players, but no one is willing to draw the attention to themselves required to get the game moving again.
