Mini Theme 2043: You've Got Mail - Game Over!

[BBmolla]

Creature is just pretty blatant genuine town but whatever makes you not lynch him idc

Why would you sacrifice yourself for Creature? You’ve both claimed VT.

I was going with the whole “Molla is scum but we don’t lynch him” mentality in addition

[Celestial Coordinates]

Creature is just pretty blatant genuine town but whatever makes you not lynch him idc

Why would you sacrifice yourself for Creature? You’ve both claimed VT.

I was going with the whole “Molla is scum but we don’t lynch him” mentality in addition

This still doesn’t really make any sense. You know your alignment better than you can be sure about anyone else’s. Wanting to die instead of another poster who is also claiming to be a VT, is anti-town.

[BBmolla]

The full mentality being “creature is town because molla is scum so let’s lynxh neither”

Holy fuck guys use your brain

[BBmolla]

I don’t want to die and it seemed like we might be heading towards lynching actual scum until people started voting me.

My big fear today was TiC/Koki getting me and creature lynched back to back, I’m content that if I get lynched it will instead result in an actual scumlynch assuming you fucks don’t argue yourself out of lynching scum

[Celestial Coordinates]

I don’t want to die and it seemed like we might be heading towards lynching actual scum until people started voting me.

My big fear today was TiC/Koki getting me and creature lynched back to back, I’m content that if I get lynched it will instead result in an actual scumlynch assuming you fucks don’t argue yourself out of lynching scum

I don’t think Kokichi is scum here. I’m assuming he’s telling the truth about being odd night mailman, since there logically has to be one in this setup and if he’s actually scum mailman, why does he ever lynch Cakes post-claim here, when Cakes would obviously confirm he is indeed town mailman? So it makes way more sense, if Kokichi scumread him from the claim/or it didn’t influence his vote. I think scum!Kokichi wouldn’t want to risk confirming Cakes.

[Celestial Coordinates]

Anyway, I think it’s critical that we don’t maj before Carca is replaced. We need that slot’s feedback on the Gamma message claim, before we proceed with the votes.

[Wisdom]

there is no setup guarantee that there is one town and one scum mailman
As such scum kokichi has no reason to be afraid of a town mailman flipping.

[Celestial Coordinates]

Gamma isn't conftown and his Thor associations are terrible we are lyncheroonieing him today thank you all for your time

[Celestial Coordinates]

Gamma isn't conftown and his Thor associations are terrible we are lyncheroonieing him today thank you all for your time

[Celestial Coordinates]

Gamma isn't conftown and his Thor associations are terrible we are lyncheroonieing him today thank you all for your time

[Celestial Coordinates]

The way gamma danced around calling himself conftown when there is no way gamma would know that rule and given the mod has explicitly stated the game is non-normal is just @_@

[Celestial Coordinates]

Like boys
And girls but the only girl left is my Hydra partner

I led on Thor D1 I am conftown let's murder gamma for being a chinsy bitch

Oh and I want to note that despite scumreading Thor the whole fucking game when push came to shove gamma was hiding behind the 'guilty' on Wisdom claimed by his top scumread after that person had already guiltied him and using it as an excuse to vote wisdom

Then when the tides we're shifting he hammered

So like, idk guys this is really easy

[Gamma Emerald]

The way gamma danced around calling himself conftown when there is no way gamma would know that rule and given the mod has explicitly stated the game is non-normal is just @_@

What rule? That UB can only back-up roles of its own alignment? I learned that in a past game, Creature was in it too, though given he’s probscum I have doubts of him backing it up. If Flavor were still alive I could get him to verify.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Fuwa Fuwa Time
No slipping away from me this time!

VOTE: TGP
Stop voting my mason buddy

Sheeping Those in Charge. Think that's town.
Willing to buy BBmolla and Shotaru as town also.

People should sheep me.

If you're sheeping TiC, anyone else voting the player you're voting wouldn't, by definition, be sheeping you.

Also, do you really think 70 comes from scum?

I disagree with how you think sheeping works.

How do you see it not coming from scum exactly?

Maybe it feels like there’s “too much effort” because I was trying a gambit?

Maybe?
I'm sheeping him more due to my reads, I don't find your slot townish and I find him townish.
I will generally agree I find you a bit more involved already than I would expect from you being town, but that might also be early game excitement. Either way you're still a fine vote at this juncture.

What do you think of Shortaru defending you for pointing out something stated in the ruleset? Is he daft for buying that, or am I daft for considering it NaI?

I think it’s odd he’s defending that after calling it LAMIST.
VOTE: shortaru
I also feel like his Wisdom push is kinda scummy after digging into his thinking

Well I’m not anticipating you doing research, because why would you? And what research have you done anyway?

I lost interest in discussing stuff with you about the time you claimed I would have no recent meta on you after agreeing my meta conclusion was right and being aware we do have recent interactions that could easily lead to me having more recent meta awareness of you. Also, when you said that Shortaru's case on me had merit.
You're not dealing with this conversation honestly.

I don’t think you’re approaching this honestly if the second you’re forced to provide specific backing for your read you clam up.
VOTE: Thor

That’s not what I said
VOTE: shortaru
Twisting my words is a scum play, plain and simple

VOTE: Thor665
I’ll wait a bit to vote TIC but I’m definitely leaning that way

@Ari I can get inactive, but you haven’t had time to read + talk with Bullet about the game so HE can help us see where you’re at?
Also I was thinking about switching to TIC earlier because something CC posted reminded me of another thing me and Ranmaru discussed, which was lynching the obvscum before the less obvscum. Problem was Thor had momentum then and I didn’t want to undermine the wagon while it had a chance.
VOTE: ThoseInCharge

Gamma if you vote Thor that's l 2 and Thor is significantly ahead of tic

It hit my criteria anyway (short was on TiC)
VOTE: Thor

VOTE: Cakez
Whatever, will switch to a Thor or Carca wagon is those come back

Yeah Thor is confscum imo
I think town Thor would’ve taken a step back and thought about whether I was trying to deceive or just working with what I had. I actually didn’t think it could have been that ongoing game, even with the added hint, as he got my play wrong there too, as I started off weak there. So like, either he’s really bad at gauging activity or he’s scum twisting the narrative in a way that honestly devalues his point as if I’m starting strong in that other town game, wouldn’t you have found TIC’s read the slightest bit wrong? No, because you saw a chance to mislynch me and bit the bait.
VOTE: Thor

VOTE: Thor665

Yeah it’s Carca
I sent her a message implying a connection between me and SirCakez since I picked up his role, along with a reference to a player who doesn’t play anymore that would function as the way to trace it to me, as afaik no one else has been in a game with Carcalilly and that player among us besides me
The fact she didn’t bring it up is sketchy as fuck imo
VOTE: Carcalilly

Fair
VOTE: Creature

My voting history. Never voted Wisdom ONCE. Check yourself before you wreck yourself, RC.

[Gamma Emerald]

Like boys
And girls but the only girl left is my Hydra partner

I led on Thor D1 I am conftown let's murder gamma for being a chinsy bitch

Oh and I want to note that despite scumreading Thor the whole fucking game when push came to shove gamma was hiding behind the 'guilty' on Wisdom claimed by his top scumread after that person had already guiltied him and using it as an excuse to vote wisdom

Then when the tides we're shifting he hammered

So like, idk guys this is really easy

And you also fencesitted like a mofo on the Thor vs Gamma debate D2, so claiming you led one day while omitting that fact is misleading as fuck

[Celestial Coordinates]

Wisdom claimed a guilty on Thor. Logic dictates they got it n2, but Thor says they took no action that night. That guilties Wisdom.

If you did something I was probably roleblocked.
Beyond that don't bore me.

You should clarify that? Tracker-type roles have that vagery of no result vs no visit, but yours is less confounded as it should clearly read no motion, which is a fair bit different than no result

Clarify with the mod fyi

I’m waiting for mod feedback but I’m prolly gonna lynch Thor because two guilties on one beats two guilties on two in terms of convincingness

Your posts

Also fuck you I didn't get to do shit D2 because these fucking clowns lynched town before I could drag the lemmings away from the cliff

[BBmolla]

[Wisdom]

gratz rc gamethrow together with your buddy
gamma is 1000% town here

[Gamma Emerald]

Wisdom claimed a guilty on Thor. Logic dictates they got it n2, but Thor says they took no action that night. That guilties Wisdom.

If you did something I was probably roleblocked.
Beyond that don't bore me.

You should clarify that? Tracker-type roles have that vagery of no result vs no visit, but yours is less confounded as it should clearly read no motion, which is a fair bit different than no result

Clarify with the mod fyi

I’m waiting for mod feedback but I’m prolly gonna lynch Thor because two guilties on one beats two guilties on two in terms of convincingness

Your posts

Also fuck you I didn't get to do shit D2 because these fucking clowns lynched town before I could drag the lemmings away from the cliff

Really
The first post is me explaining role interactions, so fuck off. The next two fair, but in that first of those two I was fairly skeptical of the result claim. The last one doesn’t really help your point at all lol

[Gamma Emerald]

As for D2 idgaf how much time you had to do things D2, fencesitting is fencesitting, end of story.

[ThoseInCharge]

Ehhhh.

VOTE: bbmolla

This is likely to get more traction than tic

Why are you willing to compromise at this stage of the game?

[ThoseInCharge]

Also why is Gamma still in consideration for being scum, why would he jump onto Thor putting him at L-2 when the wagons swang to him?

[ThoseInCharge]

Creature is just pretty blatant genuine town but whatever makes you not lynch him idc

I think I'm still leaning towards lynching BBmolla today, I think a hard townread on Creature is absurd at this stage of the game, and IME people underestimate how scummy this is

[Performer]

Votecount 4.04

Creature (1): Gamma Emerald
ThoseInCharge (1): BBmolla
Kokichi Oma (1): Wisdom
BBmolla (1): Kokichi Oma

Not voting (4):
Carcalilly, Creature, Celestial Coordinates, ThoseInCharge

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Day 4 ends on Dec 1, 2018 at 1117pm PST or earlier, if majority vote is achieved

-----------

Moderator notes: Not_Mafia replaces Carcalilly, please welcome him!

[Wisdom]

hi nm

sheep me pls