FWIW, I think this particular setup is townsided but very random; there aren't enough swapping/chaos roles to make it worth trying to logic-solve them, so the best town strategy is to identify two scum and pile on. I have a feeling that 1NUW is balanced for a situation where there's a significant chance of any given player's role having changed.
I also think the basic idea of One Night would work much better if it
weren't
bastard, i.e. everyone knew for certain what their win condition was, and the information came mostly from investigative roles (perhaps scum can even be given daytalk!). That'd at least make it much clearer how to play to wincon, and might even cause actual scumhunting to be involved.
But this unique game was so worth the try!!!
