BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[nomnomnom]

What's WF?
Also no I'm just making a cold read of how you'd be as a player that's all
Hmm... is this town trying to explain they've been slacking, or scum being scared of being caught for the wrong reasons

[Michael Scott]

scum being scared of being caught for the wrong reasons

If I had a dollar every game someone attacked me for this, I'd be having as many dollars as the games I've played.
Aaaaand no; I said a couple of pages ago I expected Dunnstral to be scumreading me - it was for these reasons.

[BooneyToonzExpert]

I'm trying a different style of questionining here, so bear with me.

BooneyToonzExpert

, if you were looking for a loved one within {Michael Scott, sore feet, JJH}, and a mortal enemy within {GeorgeBailey, RCEnigma, Titus} - who would you pick from either category and why?

-Cosmic

Love: sore feet (I want to be loved by SF. MS and JJH need to wine and dine a little more)

Mortal Enemy: RCE (Afraid to fight Titus and don't really know George)

[nomnomnom]

It also doesn't help that you push Dave @ page 74 and I think it's a bad push, regardless of my dave read.
Hm...

[Michael Scott]

Who do you think is a *good* push that isn't me?
Why is Dave a bad push?

[Krazy Katz]

Wf is white flag

[nomnomnom]

I'll detail this once I'm done.
I have 10 or so pages to go through so it should be quick.
pedit: nope, just said what I think you come off across as a player regardless of TM2020

[nomnomnom]

@page 78

Anywho WHO'S THE SCUMS, GUYS!?

We're kinda running outta time and I'd hate to flash lynch because we couldn't come together as a town in what was it like two weeks. ffs

Extremely scummy post.

[Michael Scott]

Do you townread jjh?

[nomnomnom]

Yeah so I'm more or less caught up, have to admit I skipped a few posts, happy to have caught up instead of dodging.

Here's my summary:
I think Auro's slot in this gamestate is scummy considering his character and the fact that it's beneficial for scums to let things go when you have someone like Vecna claiming a massive neg utility role
I think George is straight up scum, blatantly so for their interactions
For some reason chkflip's AtE feels extremely scummy, generally there is a clear reason why someone loses their shit but here it felt huh... kinda exaggerated for what it was.

Here are the slots I'm willing to call town right now:
V/M
Sore Feet
Fonz
RCE
Vecna
Dave
jjh
chronos
BTE

Rest I'm way too uncertain about to give an opinion.

I feel the majority of townies here would be willing to lynch George from what I've seen, so I'll consolidate there and see what happens
VOTE: George

[nomnomnom]

eeeeh you know the more I think about it the less I'm sure about my jjh townread
removing that slot from my townpile

[nomnomnom]

Willing to also reconsider my townread on BTE if george ends up flipping town

[Michael Scott]

[Michael Scott]

So you don't get the impression jjh is coasting?

[nomnomnom]

Actually that's why I just removed him from my townpile
He was active at the beginning but he could just be coasting through the claims and chaos as scum.
I think going on his slot is a bad idea anyway and that I prefer consolidating on George, sounds like a safe d1 lynch to me.

[jjh927]

What exactly do you expect me to be doing here?

[Michael Scott]

The gamestate Nancy is actively creating is one where most discussion gets drowned out and Nancy gets lynched at eod

That is not coached scum or powerscum or most varieties of scum

It's like you didn't read my clarification on what I meant by "coaching".

[nomnomnom]

What exactly do you expect me to be doing here?

Can you talk reads with me
I've noticed in my catchup there werent many of those

[Michael Scott]

I like George, no energy to case right now.

[BooneyToonzExpert]

Willing to also reconsider my townread on BTE if george ends up flipping town

Why is it impossible that we are TvT in your eyes?

[nomnomnom]

Willing to also reconsider my townread on BTE if george ends up flipping town

Why is it impossible that we are TvT in your eyes?

Intuition.

[Michael Scott]

She means you're definitely not SvS; if George is scum you're town and if George is town she'll reconsider you (Either SvT or TvT).

[nomnomnom]

The whole interaction feels odd, there something I can't describe with George's push on BTE that feels really wrong.
My heart tells me that this is what I should focus on, really. George is just scum.

[jjh927]

What exactly do you expect me to be doing here?

Can you talk reads with me
I've noticed in my catchup there werent many of those

I find I'm townreading a lot of people at the moment, which isn't totally abnormal for day 1 but just means no scum are standing out hugely atm. I might pick up and prod the people in my scumreads a little to see what happens but I can't make any promises rn.

Townier side is on the left:
Hard Town: Venus and Mars, Chkflip, The Fonz, Titus, Vecna, Krazy Katz, nomnomnom, Davesaz
Thought these were town earlier but haven't really thought much about them since: Sore feet, Conspire, Michael Scott
Lean town: BooneyToonzExpert, RCEnigma
Possible scum: Kakeguri Addicts, Chronos, George Bailey

[jjh927]

Btw, which hydra head is it that keeps talking about me coasting?