Btw, I still think GuiltyLion is scum, and if we do included a third, he would be my pick. I don't buy his excuses for not doing "more because of the nature of the setup". I know it must suck to have this kinda meta used against you if I'm right, Hobbes, but you're the one who provided the self-meta lol
Also, his push on me is something he kinda needs to do as scum since he knows it's gonna be near impossible for him to budge my read on him.
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 2:01 pm
by GuiltyLion
In post 2225, Hel wrote:I don't buy his excuses for not doing "more because of the nature of the setup"
I mean idk, I did a solid amount of scum hunting D1, proposed a pool and was pleased that Ico put two of my three in it, caught scum with one of those two. and partner hunted (badly) yesterday, got another pool with two of my three suspects in it and agree with the execution and likely pool today. There weren't really many critical competing wagons moments outside of D1 and I was more active when that was happening.
I'm not sure what else more you'd expect me to be doing, the game's on a decent course even despite not finding tea yesterday. and I've largely agreed with the momentum of the town so far. Ico as our Beloved Port Authority is keeping the harbor running smoothly, and Alisae is kind of just rolling over which makes me think it's good odds that we're right and e's scum.
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 2:07 pm
by maxwell
In post 2224, Hel wrote:That's a good point. We could include Not Known I guess since he's spewed not!Daughter, although I'm pretty sure he's town anyway.
I've decided to just accept that I was super wrong on him and that my suspicion was all based on emotion.
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 2:18 pm
by Alisae
I am not shipping copper if maxwell is
ship: Wheat
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 2:19 pm
by Alisae
i feel like its too risky for the both of us to be investedgated.
I would rather be flipped and have maxwell be inspected then to have both of us be inspected
i just get a bad gut feeling about it
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 6:06 pm
by Iconeum
would this be a good time for me to decide on stuff?
or you guys wanna keep discussing?
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:07 pm
by FakeGod
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:16 pm
by Menalque
In post 2222, Hel wrote:Still think we should be just investigating Datisi + Moment. Adding someone and then getting tea would be a really annoying result. We should check them both on their own at the free price of no tomboy daughter information given away.
In post 2222, Hel wrote:Still think we should be just investigating Datisi + Moment. Adding someone and then getting tea would be a really annoying result. We should check them both on their own at the free price of no tomboy daughter information given away.
Why would this be annoying?
We learn one of A, B, or C is scum.
We execute A, and investigate B again.
If A was innocent, we execute B or C depending on how the last investigation went.
We win (assuming TD wasn't among those three... which I do assume)
Yeah this, exactly this
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:17 pm
by Menalque
In post 2230, Iconeum wrote:would this be a good time for me to decide on stuff?
or you guys wanna keep discussing?
I’m bored, I wanna see a head rolling on the floor
The invest pool should really be 3 people not 2 if we’re doing (datisi, moment) as part of it
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:19 pm
by Alisae
throw in username as an inspect for the shits and giggles tbh
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:21 pm
by kuribo
In post 2234, Alisae wrote:throw in username as an inspect for the shits and giggles tbh
In post 2234, Alisae wrote:throw in username as an inspect for the shits and giggles tbh
Game ends when you die anyway you scum fuck.
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:22 pm
by username
And this ain't the day to fuck with me Alisae
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:33 pm
by Moment
I'm essentially prod dodging here, although I've skimmed.
Maxwell proposing himself along with me and Datisi seems like an attempt to poison the well and potentially get one of us on the chopping block tomorrow instead of likely just him. A rather uncharitable interpretation, but the one that most immediately jumped to mind.
Investigating me and Datisi is still a stupid decision, but including Maxwell would be moreso. I would not comply with it.
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:34 pm
by Menalque
In post 2238, Moment wrote:Maxwell proposing himself along with me and Datisi seems like an attempt to poison the well and potentially get one of us on the chopping block tomorrow instead of likely just him. A rather uncharitable interpretation, but the one that most immediately jumped to mind.
What happened to your maxwell TR on D1?
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:35 pm
by Menalque
In post 2238, Moment wrote:Investigating me and Datisi is still a stupid decision, but including Maxwell would be moreso. I would not comply with it.
Also, why?
This makes like zero sense
If tea turns up, we’re flipping maxwell first anyway
If no tea then we’ve removed the next obvious suspect and we haven’t reduced the pool the TD is in
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:36 pm
by Alisae
why go for an invest of 3 today when after today's lynch and investigation, you only have 2 flips left after the d3 flip
seems like it would be better to just go invest 2 people today tomorrow invest 1 person tomorrow
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:39 pm
by Moment
Haven't been able to give this game much time so you're still getting loose thoughts.
If Alisae is scum, with the way he's playing I would expect that he already knows - or thinks he knows - the TD. Also, if Alisae is scum then I would guess Maxwell isn't, simply because I would expect Alisae's buddy to also be playing in a very low-effort manner given the (theoretical) impending 2nd scum lynch.
The point I'm trying to get to in a roundabout manner is that I'm wondering if I'd rather vote Maxwell today. There is certainly an element of recency bias in this.
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:40 pm
by Menalque
In post 2241, Alisae wrote:why go for an invest of 3 today when after today's lynch and investigation, you only have 2 flips left after the d3 flip
seems like it would be better to just go invest 2 people today tomorrow invest 1 person tomorrow
In post 2238, Moment wrote:Maxwell proposing himself along with me and Datisi seems like an attempt to poison the well and potentially get one of us on the chopping block tomorrow instead of likely just him. A rather uncharitable interpretation, but the one that most immediately jumped to mind.
What happened to your maxwell TR on D1?
Day two happened.
All reads grow "stale" with time and with more information. I'd say the same thing regarding Hel. I'll try to give you a better answer when I get the time.
In post 2238, Moment wrote:Investigating me and Datisi is still a stupid decision, but including Maxwell would be moreso. I would not comply with it.
Also, why?
This makes like zero sense
If tea turns up, we’re flipping maxwell first anyway
If no tea then we’ve removed the next obvious suspect and we haven’t reduced the pool the TD is in
Are we
decidedly
flipping Maxwell first anyways? The basics of it are that I think Datisi is town but I couldn't say the same about Maxwell and I'd rather simply investigate a suspect alone than potentially be in a guilty pool with him.
In post 2241, Alisae wrote:why go for an invest of 3 today when after today's lynch and investigation, you only have 2 flips left after the d3 flip
seems like it would be better to just go invest 2 people today tomorrow invest 1 person tomorrow
Because if tea then mechwin
actually no no ur right but i should probably remind you that even if you flip 2 scum, scum just needs to identify the TD correctly and they win.
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:53 pm
by Menalque
In post 2244, Moment wrote:Are we decidedly flipping Maxwell first anyways?
Yes, unless someone gives a compelling counter argument for why there’s not scum on the umlaut CW to notscience
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:54 pm
by Menalque
In post 2245, Alisae wrote:scum just needs to identify the TD correctly and they win.
Yes, I’m aware
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 7:56 pm
by Menalque
In post 2244, Moment wrote:All reads grow "stale" with time and with more information. I'd say the same thing regarding Hel. I'll try to give you a better answer when I get the time.
Okay, but I’d still like to know what was making you TR him on D1 in the first place. Because I had him as more likely to be scum and changed it round because you said you thought he was likely town, and now I want to know what the reasons behind that defence of him were so I can decide if they’re still compelling
Posted: Tue Jul 21, 2020 8:05 pm
by Iconeum
In post 2238, Moment wrote:I'm essentially prod dodging here, although I've skimmed.
Maxwell proposing himself along with me and Datisi seems like an attempt to poison the well and potentially get one of us on the chopping block tomorrow instead of likely just him. A rather uncharitable interpretation, but the one that most immediately jumped to mind.
Investigating me and Datisi is still a stupid decision, but including Maxwell would be moreso. I would not comply with it.
there shouldn't be no harm in me saying this because it's clear you aren't the TD
IIRC you were very strongly opposing the Day 1 inspect as well
