Mafiascum.net

In post 608, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 587, Flavor Leaf wrote:I would like to note the potential danger of me seeing Alchemist's posts, immediately getting happy, wanting to vote NPOM with them, and then I remember Day 1.

I kinda doubt we see a repeat performance of Ben’s wagon.

This aged well.

NPOM I found it really easy to push on you because at times it felt like you just weren't paying attention to the game.

Like, you'd come in and declare nothing was happening when was there plenty of interaction going on, your weird push on BM was bad (I was amazed SB got elimmed there instead of you.) and overall you really tanked your credibility at crucial moments.

If you say so, nobody's perfect.

I'd say it was one of my better games.

oh damn, rereading scum thread, Alch called the Neapolitan after Outer brought up options with it.

Nice one.

Also, thanks for modding, TGP.

I push people to sort them, it doesn't mean I think they are lock scum.

In post 2128, Rannygazoo wrote:Hey, if you want to put me on E-2, I'll self-vote. NPOM may have broken tradition but I believe in the old ways.

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p12386971

damn, we should have done it.

Oh we lost this? LOL

Let me just say to all yall policy elim haters: you may want to consider hopping on the wave 0.o

I'm fine with PE actual actions, not just for people being new, etc.

NPOM we make a good team. I'll give you one free scum pocket so we can keep playing well together

Also titus may need a duster from the sheer amount of lint she collected in flavor's pocket

In post 2228, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I'd say it was one of my better games.

Except for the confusing claim bit I had you as lock!town. It’s that claim and that two PRs did it not one. I was pretty sure on Outer just ugh this game was confusing

In post 2233, superbowl9 wrote:Let me just say to all yall policy elim haters: you may want to consider hopping on the wave 0.o

big agree i had someone quickvote someone in a recent game and i was like "lol this person's reads do not match up with the speed of this vote why are we allowing this"

That’s what I thought about Titus’s hammer!

Hi I reviewed this game.

Hi mastina

congrats to scum, but i have to say awful town performance. On Day 3 (and even moreso Day 4), OWER->FL was a no-brainer and then we would have had at least 1 mis-elim to try and hit Alch. A cleansweep for mafia there is unforgivable. But as I said on Day 3, with the numbers as they were, we needed the masons to play ball to have a chance.



mafia more or less killed all the right people at the right time though, to their credit. And it's funny looking back I was dead right about OWER originally - he did that open-hammer gambit because he was confident in his experienced scumbuddies.

...I was trying.

Sorting through fake claims and real claims takes time and not having hyperposting.

Yep.
I still prefer FL lynch over Titus.

Why did you guys eliminate the only TI claim without CC?

FL and Outer were lock scum. It doesn’t matter if we did them first or last. A loss is a loss, whether there’s 1 or 3 left.

I think the lesson of this game is to kill the obvious Scum first.

I appreciate being fear killed and all, but I would say that both Johnny and Math (at times) played better than I have on any game on this forum with the one exception that Koba remembers well. An important part of playing Town in my mind is being able to convince others to do the right thing. In that, we failed miserably. And Scum just did very well. Flavor showed convincingly why dominating the conversation and controlling the game state are so important as Scum, and the Team really ran the game and the Masons couldn’t sufficiently counter it. I don’t think figuring out Titus’ alignment was easy btw - I think Titus made mistakes because of an inherent belief that she was likely to be right more often than not. That didn’t work out this game obviously, but I’m sure it does over the long-run.

This was a bit depressing to read to be totally honest - I was really rooting for us to get our acts together in time but it just didn’t happen. Hopefully I get to play with some of you again soon enough.

@Battle Mage I think you’re being overly critical of the Masons. Like I said, an important part of the game is to be able to convince people that you are right. You had the game mostly figured out - just like Johnny and Math for example. But you also made mistakes - if I remember correctly, you revealing your role *hurt* your credibility more than it helped for example when you were trying to avoid having NPOM executed. If anything, it gave the Scum more room to throw misinformation out there. Waiting to reveal your role on a later Day could have made the difference there.

Anyway, onto the next one.

In post 2247, Andresvmb wrote:I think the lesson of this game is to kill the obvious Scum first.

I appreciate being fear killed and all, but I would say that both Johnny and Math (at times) played better than I have on any game on this forum with the one exception that Koba remembers well. An important part of playing Town in my mind is being able to convince others to do the right thing. In that, we failed miserably. And Scum just did very well. Flavor showed convincingly why dominating the conversation and controlling the game state are so important as Scum, and the Team really ran the game and the Masons couldn’t sufficiently counter it. I don’t think figuring out Titus’ alignment was easy btw - I think Titus made mistakes because of an inherent belief that she was likely to be right more often than not. That didn’t work out this game obviously, but I’m sure it does over the long-run.

This was a bit depressing to read to be totally honest - I was really rooting for us to get our acts together in time but it just didn’t happen. Hopefully I get to play with some of you again soon enough.

Hey if you’re interested can you PM me what I could do better? Always looking to improve my town game