Experimental Role Mafia (GAME OVER!)

[DeathNote]

@MOI-
This is the post that made me vote havingfitz

Are there any good cases out there for scum? No one is jumping out at me atm.

His post just sorta... "jumped" out at me.

@Parama: Did you draw any conclusions from your faked daykill?

The better question is did

BBmolla

get anything out of his "fake" daycop?
@BBmolla- read this post please!

P-edit: Pops, what's your opinion of sword of omens? I don't really like his most recent post. It's making me itch, but I can't put my finger on why.

I know this wasn't directed towards me but I wanted to point out that no matter how odd his post was (because it gave me a weird vibe too) that sword got BBmolla to stumble a bit with the below quote:

Why did you jump back on Parama for no apparent reason?

I don't remember. I had some reason, I just can't recall.

UNVOTE:

Gimme a bit.

[DeathNote]

Oh right… then there is Hiraki. There is always… hiraki….

I never responded to Pidgey in 151 because
a.) I am not voting him anymore not to mention there wasn't a case to keep pressure with from me.
b.) He didn't give me much to rebuke. He attempted to justified his questioning because that is apparently what he thought I was voting for.

Now as for you poking at my posts for IIoA….

Thats a bit ridiculous as the game just started. What reason do you have to take my post as something that I am using to push for scum? Both posts you quoted may have started off with my just stating info but they had a purpose and weren't for fluff.

[Hiraki]

Thats a bit ridiculous as the game just started.

This really doesn't matter.

If I scumslip on post 5, is it different than scumslipping on post 1000?

In addition, only the first quote is. The second is far into your ISO and the game's ISO.

What reason do you have to take my post as something that I am using to push for scum?

Um. I'm not?

But I know when you post something it shouldn't really be bad.

and you're doing that thing where you do post things that are bad

Both posts you quoted may have started off with my just stating info but they had a purpose and weren't for fluff.

Really?

Didn't you just state this though?

What reason do you have to take my post as something that I am using to push for scum?

See MoI?

This is why DeathNote needs a bullet

but really doesn't.

[DeathNote]

This really doesn't matter.

If I scumslip on post 5, is it different than scumslipping on post 1000?

In addition, only the first quote is. The second is far into your ISO and the game's ISO.

That isn't the point I was making. You accused me of IIoA but the game had just started. Practically no information has been given at this point so what I was doing was simply getting into the conversation.

Um. I'm not?

But I know when you post something it shouldn't really be bad.

and you're doing that thing where you do post things that are bad

I have no idea what to make of this. To me, your posts never make any sense and I feel like you just hold a vendetta against certain players. Does that make you a bad poster?

Really?

Didn't you just state this though?

Uhh... no? You did. You critiqued a couple of my posts and I responded.

I just dont get you. Plain and simple.

[Hiraki]

Practically no information has been given at this point so what I was doing was simply getting into the conversation.

Did you notice that I only accused you of it?

I have no idea what to make of this. To me, your posts never make any sense and I feel like you just hold a vendetta against certain players. Does that make you a bad poster?

You asked me a question, I answered it. I guess this doesn't really make any sense!

Uhh... no? You did. You critiqued a couple of my posts and I responded.

Wasn't it odd that I said "this" and another quote appeared that I had already quoted before?

Gee, it's like the second quote had a new point.

LOL! That's impossible Hiraki! Only dumbdumbs would ever think about that!

[Amrun]

@Parama: Did you draw any conclusions from your faked daykill?

it wasn't for conclusions <___<

That's not what I asked.

[TWIN SWORDS OF DESTINY]

Votecount 1.5

MagnaofIllusion (2) bunnylover, Dramonic
Pine (1) Hiraki
Brizingre1 (2) hiplop, Vi
Pidgey (1) Parama
DeathNote (2) pappums rat, Malthusis
havingfitz (1) DeathNote
sword_of_omens (1) Pidgey
hiplop (0)
popsofctown (0)
Parama (4) MagnaOfIllusion, Brizingre1, FaerieLord, AurorusVox
Dramonic (0)
RayFrost (0)
I Am Innocent (1) RayFrost
Vi (0)
Hiraki (0)
FakeGod (1) Amrun
FaerieLord (1) Pine
Amrun (0)
AurorusVox (0)
BBmolla (1) sword_of_omens
pappums rat (0)
bunnylover (1) I Am Innocent
Malthusis (2) FakeGod, popsofctown

Not Voting (2) - havingfitz, BBmolla

Deadline is (expired on 2012-05-06 17:00:00)
With

23

alive, it takes

12

to lynch.

hiplop has been prodded.

[pappums rat]

@Pappums

– why do you assume Deathnote’s vote for pidgey is ‘random’ when I explicitly asked him to vote for a scum candidate?

'Cause he didnt really give any reasoning behind the vote.

ask me to explain these reads and I'll post a funny image* to avoid doing so
*image may or may not actually be humorous

I'll take a chance. Explain yourself.

The malthusis wagon seems not all that bad.

Why you voting Briz then? That was your first vote of the game and it certainly didnt look like RVS vote, and you havent talked about why briz is scum that much since then.

Oh, this is a good catch. Ignoring someone you think has a decent wagon on them and not voting that player while you still have your RVS vote on someone.

I'm pretty sure I've explained it to FaerieLord, who happens to be in denial.

Perhaps you could explain why I cant find your explanation?

Unvote
Vote: Vi

:gameofmafia: is not an explanation. And it doesnt come close to making up for ignoring a wagon you thought was good.

[Vi]

Oh, this is a good catch. Ignoring someone you think has a decent wagon on them and not voting that player while you still have your RVS vote on someone.

I'm... not entirely sure I understand what's scummy about this, ignoring for a moment that I don't cast RVS votes in general.

Also try reading the rest of the post you quoted.

[RayFrost]

Unvote, Vote: Brisingur

SHEEPING VI. (insert self-found daykill here - low-quality version of Vi's brilliant music taste)

Btw, according to what I remember of Vi's meta on me, my scum meta is to buddy Vi. Funny thing is this is true. So I'm trying to BREAK THE META TELL by buddying Vi when I'm town.

[RayFrost]

Alternative daykill music

[Vi]

The second one is only bad because it comes from a bad game. If you're going to microwave daykills at least make them good ones.

[popsofctown]

You have strange taste in music Vi.

[RayFrost]

I but attempt to learn from the master.

While we're here, are you of the same mind on the hiraki v deathnote stuff in that it can be summarized by "wordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswordswords"

P-edit: Same question to you pops.

Also, I am a fan of Vi's music taste. I even PM'd Vi about it once.

[Vi]

You have strange taste in music Vi.

You assume that I like what I just posted.

Most of the thread is wordswordswordswordswordsetc. and I'm basically looking for something better-than-random to look at.

[havingfitz]

Havingfitz

there's at least three people who people have put serious votes on

comment on them

please.

Which three have received serious votes? Assuming one of those serious votes you refer to is on the top wagon (at the time of your request); Parama...a quick ISO of him doesn't show much. I thought his analysis of who was town and scum was interesting considering he had FairieLord list as scum but he puts a vote down on Malth who I think had 1 post att. The rest of his posting is useless chaff.

So I think his wagon has some merit to it.

VOTE: Parama

Also...

mod, I'm v/LA until Sunday night. I'll be keeping tabs by phone but my ability to pore over content will be very restricted.

[dramonic]

Why is rayfrost riding Vi so hard? ._.

[RayFrost]

Few things:

1) I've been a fan of Vi for a while, so my daykill stuff and the like is just good naturedness on my part (just for perspective: Vi's been a part of basically every stage of my ms development, be it modding or playing in a game from each "era")

2) I actively stated I'm trying to ruin the meta Vi has on me in that when I'm scum I buddy by doing that exact thing as town.

3) Voices.

[RayFrost]

On the whole important things topic, why is magna scum, dram?

[dramonic]

His vote on Parama is BS, his reaction to my vote on him is BS.
"oooooh I'm towwwwwwn feeeeeeear meeeeeeeeeeee otherwise I'll OMGUS you" doesn't particularely phases me

[Parama]

dram, moi is third party
leave him alone for a day or two, he's probably gonna get killed n1 anyways

anyways I can't seem to get people to see why pidgey is obvscum so back to the othert obvscum

unvote, vote: malth

[RayFrost]

Hey parama can you link me to the post where you actually explained anything

Thanks

[MagnaofIllusion]

@Vi – So why isn’t pappums voting for you a scum-tell?

--

Btw, according to what I remember of Vi's meta on me, my scum meta is to buddy Vi. Funny thing is this is true. So I'm trying to BREAK THE META TELL by buddying Vi when I'm town.

So what I am seeing here is –

You are specifically going out of your way, as Town, to buddy a player of unknown alignment to break your scum meta of buddying Vi.

Again – you are acting in a manner as Town to make it more difficult to read your future games as scum?

My brain … it hurts

--

it wasn't for conclusions <___<

Yeah it was to fluff. Eat some rope why don’t you.

--

Dram makes me laugh. In that 'yup, completely useless like Shotty' sort of way.

--

like MOI's 119

I’d like you to express exactly what you like about Post 119

--

WRONG EHAHAHEAHAHA

Then who in Ray’s Post 219 isn’t Town and why.

--

Yes, and consequently got Pinescum down later.

Remind me … if Pine is scum are you voting him? Why aren’t you doing more to push Pine-scum?

Really?

Absolutely. He’s posting more content and thoughts than half this thread. Your attempts to undermine that by calling him terrible while simultaneously calling him Town stink to high heaven.

Here’s a list of players who have less than 5 posts and for all practical purposes no content to their ISOs –

BBmolla, having, FakeGod, pappums, Bunnylover, IAI, Malth.

How can you justify questioning Deathnote’s contributions while not saying WORD ONE about these players?

What does this post show?

It's IIoA.

Parama’s entire ISO is fluff and IIoA. Your point?

Sure, he has some good posts. Maybe Parama doesn't now, but will soon.

Oh, so you aren’t looking at Parama on the expectation of something to come but are dismissing Deathnote despite him actually having content (which you freely admit) now?

Dumb or scum again Hiraki?

If I scumslip on post 5, is it different than scumslipping on post 1000?

Of course not. Not please point me out the scum-slips you have seen.

--

The better question is did BBmolla get anything out of his "fake" daycop?

Read Post 42. Then read it again. Take five minutes away from the computer and read it again.

Now tell me if BB is claiming to get any results or not.

--

Cause he didnt really give any reasoning behind the vote.

Wrong answer. You’ve been here long enough to know that voting with giving explicit reasons does not mean it is a RVS vote.

[Parama]

Hey parama can you link me to the post where you actually explained anything

Thanks

I can't
Haven't made that post yet

May or may not make it in the future

[RayFrost]

MoI: I just like being friendly with Vi. In my last scum game I actively didn't buddy Vi, so the whole commentary about that is a bit of a joke. Did I mention I won that game? Fuck yeah.

But anyway parama's whole "OHEY YOU GUYS ARENT CONVINCED BY MY BRILLIANT NOTHING BUT A VOTE SO I WILL SWITCH TO THIS OTHER GUY INSTEAD" bothers me. A lot.

Unvote, Vote: Parama

LET THE VOTE ANALYSIS OF ME BE FILLED WITH CHANGES.