- - Jumped onto a bandwagon with his first post.
- Demanded less discussion
- Defended attacks against him by saying they don't make sense
Mini 309, Mordor Mafia--Game over!
Forum rules
I don't know who's scummier - MoS or Masterchief. MoS gave a final vote with no reason and then a terrible excuse the day after. Masterchief has claimed he has a Power Role that can be confirmed at night. I can't think of what could do this that wouldn't have already been used by N_Lich. Can you please explain, Masterchief? I don't want to fish, but something like this is too vague and unkown for me. He then makes posts calling for a lynch... but not specifying on who. He's still voting for MoS. Masterchief, do you think he's scummy? I feel like you're trying to avoid saying his name, and I have no idea why. Also, he's
Unvote, Vote: Masterchief
, at least for now.- Mastermind of Sin
- Mastermind of Sin
-
Mastermind of Sin
- Cassandra Complex
- Cassandra Complex
- Posts: 15163
- Joined: October 30, 2004
- Location: Sleeping with the Godfather's Daughter
- Contact:
At least I didn't give you a fake excuse to try and win you over.ubertimmy wrote:I don't know who's scummier - MoS or Masterchief. MoS gave a final vote with no reason and then a terrible excuse the day after. Masterchief has claimed he has a Power Role that can be confirmed at night. I can't think of what could do this that wouldn't have already been used by N_Lich. Can you please explain, Masterchief? I don't want to fish, but something like this is too vague and unkown for me. He then makes posts calling for a lynch... but not specifying on who. He's still voting for MoS. Masterchief, do you think he's scummy? I feel like you're trying to avoid saying his name, and I have no idea why. Also, he's
- - Jumped onto a bandwagon with his first post.
- Demanded less discussion
- Defended attacks against him by saying they don't make sense
Unvote, Vote: Masterchief, at least for now.
Permanent V/LA.
- Masterchief
- Masterchief
-
Masterchief
- I got a role
- I got a role
- Posts: 588
- Joined: April 30, 2006
- Location: North Carolina
- Contact:
stikey said:
HE SAID SOMETHING ABOUT NIGHT CONFIRMING! I asked to elaborate and now your accusing me for having a powerole! I don't think anyone here except for cop or doctor or mafia even have a power role. I was jsut asking to eleborate on his night confirming thing because I didn't understand what he meant.Can-do. Can we hear more about this ability to be confirmed at night, or was that an idea that you've ditched at this point? I mean, if we truly are in a lynch-or-lose situation, then this stay of execution could be a fatal blow to us if you're lying.
Show
[u]People I Want To Kill In A Mafia Game[/u]
1. Primate
2.Twito
3.Kelly Chen
4. IH
5.Shadow Lurker
6. ubertimmy
[u]People that are cool to play with[/u]
1. Thok
2.STD
3.Glork
4.ubertimmy
1. Primate
2.Twito
3.Kelly Chen
4. IH
5.Shadow Lurker
6. ubertimmy
[u]People that are cool to play with[/u]
1. Thok
2.STD
3.Glork
4.ubertimmy
Again...
This post pre-dates anything I wrote about night-confirming. You're really floundering at this pointMasterchief wrote:Also, I can't prove my innocense UNTILL WE GO TO NIGHT. We've spent the whole time griping about how i've messed up. So I can't prove I'm right untill it's night and we stop griping about my mistakes AND ACTUALLY DO SOMETHING. Thank you for your time and attention.
"Sure, his arguments can be considered compelling, but when taken out of context, so can urine." -- Atticus
I agree. I just do not understand what Masterchief is playing at. I'll give it a go:
@Masterchief: The bolding in the post from you:
Sorry, but you need to get your head round this question if you do not want to get lynched.
@Masterchief: The bolding in the post from you:
implies you CAN prove your innocence tomorrow. So we are all very interested if you have a role that enables this. Maybe not a doc or a cop. Or maybe a doc or a cop. There are lots of roles in mafia.Masterchief wrote: Also, I can't prove my innocense UNTILL WE GO TO NIGHT.
Sorry, but you need to get your head round this question if you do not want to get lynched.
-
-
TheEyeOfMordor Goon
-
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 400
- Joined: September 10, 2005
- Location: Iceland
Yep, I think that´s a lynch.
SpamWise hammared Masterchief according to my calculations.
The Town quickly comes together after the death of Lloyd. MoS quickly came under suspicion. But the arrival of Masterchief changed the situation. Almost all as one the Town closes on him and offer him up for lynching. The High Commander impaled his victim with his spear and promptly examined his victim. Unfortunately, Masterchief was an
Please send a no action PM if you do not intend to use your night action.
SpamWise hammared Masterchief according to my calculations.
Votecount
Masterchief(5):stikey, MoS, ubertimmy, evilandy, SpamWise
MoS(1):Masterchief
Masterchief(5):stikey, MoS, ubertimmy, evilandy, SpamWise
MoS(1):Masterchief
The Town quickly comes together after the death of Lloyd. MoS quickly came under suspicion. But the arrival of Masterchief changed the situation. Almost all as one the Town closes on him and offer him up for lynching. The High Commander impaled his victim with his spear and promptly examined his victim. Unfortunately, Masterchief was an
Orcish Labourer/townie
. It is now Night 3, send choices in by Monday. Please send a no action PM if you do not intend to use your night action.
In the name of Mark Lazarus....
-
-
TheEyeOfMordor Goon
-
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 400
- Joined: September 10, 2005
- Location: Iceland
- Mastermind of Sin
- Mastermind of Sin
-
Mastermind of Sin
- Cassandra Complex
- Cassandra Complex
- Posts: 15163
- Joined: October 30, 2004
- Location: Sleeping with the Godfather's Daughter
- Contact:
-
-
TheEyeOfMordor Goon
-
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 400
- Joined: September 10, 2005
- Location: Iceland
To be honest, I think that whole day was pretty poor. Masterchief was well out of his depth. Are there not rules about newwbies joining more advanced games as replacements?
I'm also a little unhappy about the vote counting and how the last two lynches happenned. Both were due to apparent miscounting. Maybe noone is to blame about that, or maybe it wasn't accidental afterall.
I'm going to re-read, but pay particular attention to anyone who was on both lynches. A good bet that scum was on both.
I'm also a little unhappy about the vote counting and how the last two lynches happenned. Both were due to apparent miscounting. Maybe noone is to blame about that, or maybe it wasn't accidental afterall.
I'm going to re-read, but pay particular attention to anyone who was on both lynches. A good bet that scum was on both.
- Norinel
- Norinel
-
Norinel
- Not Voting (3)
- Not Voting (3)
- Posts: 1684
- Joined: March 2, 2003
- Location: My computer
Nope. I have an innocent result on someone else, which I'll hold onto until that person or me is likely to be lynched.stikey wrote:Let me guess, Norinel: you investigated Starkmoon?
For those keeping score at home, that'd be Stikey, MoS, and ubertimmy. But I find it an interesting thing to propose when mafia have yet to kill anyone on either lynching bandwagon. So now everyone left has been on one (Me on c_d, everyone else on Masterchief), and we can't just compare quantity there.evilandy wrote:I'm going to re-read, but pay particular attention to anyone who was on both lynches. A good bet that scum was on both.
- Norinel
- Norinel
-
Norinel
- Not Voting (3)
- Not Voting (3)
- Posts: 1684
- Joined: March 2, 2003
- Location: My computer
Is there any reason to reveal it at this point? Not giving scum an easy target and getting more info by how people discuss the guilt of the innocent are reason enough not to.evilandy wrote:Do you have resons for holding out on us and not sharing the information?Norinel wrote:Nope. I have an innocent result on someone else, which I'll hold onto until that person or me is likely to be lynched.
Well I guess we will know soon enough and there is no hurry.Norinel wrote:Is there any reason to reveal it at this point? Not giving scum an easy target and getting more info by how people discuss the guilt of the innocent are reason enough not to.
At the moment I'm most suspicious of Spamwise, MoS and Stikey. It would be good if we have an innocent on one of those.
Here’s my list of suspicions:
1. MoS
2. Stikey
3. Spamwise
4. evilandy
5. Norinel
Norinel is at the bottom only because no one has counter claimed cop. I think that MoS and Stikey are mafia together, maybe with one of evilandy and spamwise. But, since I’m not sure which, I’ll vote for who I think is scummiest – MoS.
If Norinel can clear MoS or Stikey, then I'll have to seriously think a bit. If he can clear me, well, nothing I don't already know. If he can clear evilandy or spamwise, I don't think it helps us too much.
1. MoS
2. Stikey
3. Spamwise
4. evilandy
5. Norinel
Norinel is at the bottom only because no one has counter claimed cop. I think that MoS and Stikey are mafia together, maybe with one of evilandy and spamwise. But, since I’m not sure which, I’ll vote for who I think is scummiest – MoS.
Vote: Mastermind of Sin
If Norinel can clear MoS or Stikey, then I'll have to seriously think a bit. If he can clear me, well, nothing I don't already know. If he can clear evilandy or spamwise, I don't think it helps us too much.
- Mastermind of Sin
- Mastermind of Sin
-
Mastermind of Sin
- Cassandra Complex
- Cassandra Complex
- Posts: 15163
- Joined: October 30, 2004
- Location: Sleeping with the Godfather's Daughter
- Contact:
care to explain your vote? Anyone can just give a list of suspicion, but it doesn't mean anything unless you give reasoning. I'm sure I could supply the reasoning for you, but I'd like to know why you yourself decided I was the scummiest. It will be a good thing to note once we start looking at other people as scum.
Permanent V/LA.