In post 214, MVP wrote:"You're not voting anyone. If you're not gonna use your vote, you might as well as sheep my vote."
-L. J.
There's at least one flaw in that line of thought, unfortunately.
1) That quote doesn't reconcile the player who isn't eager to lob votes.
2) Withholding your vote is worlds apart from sheeping another's.
3) By holding your vote, you can't unknowingly sheep Scum or SK.
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 3:35 pm
by MVP
That's what sangres was telling you. So do the talking to him.
-L. J.
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 3:41 pm
by likeabauss
I hate all the dishing out of town reads. "Ur town. Town there. There. And there too!"
Keep that crap to yourself. Your town reads on D1 don't help other townies lynch scum today. All it does is setup scenarios and leverage plays for scum to start working on and lining up. If you want to help scum, keep it up. When you want to start helping town, start pointing out shady buggers and applying heat.
TIP is unique. Apparently his meta is so obviously transparent, that he gets sorted quickly and with ease (from those that know him.) At least two of those players are here, in separate hydra slots. Ill bet good money that they'll declare him town or scum before days end, and they'll be right. Not only would I prefer NOT to hang somebody that is so easily sorted (before them being sorted obviously), I'm highly suspicious of anybody who wants to hang that fellow. Its scummy as hell.
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 3:42 pm
by goodmorning
WELCOME TO THE NEW PAGE
OR SOME STUPID SHIT LIKE THAT
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 3:43 pm
by sangres
In post 65, JacobSavage wrote:What was the reasoning behind this? I've seen respectable players do it because they know the game is winnable if they do so.
In post 65, JacobSavage wrote:Honor, most third parties would rather see town win the mafia win plus there is always the chance that the town massively cock ups and they can win.
In post 222, MVP wrote:Nacho you bore me like watching paint dry or watching the Broncos winning games without me
Tim Tebow
In post 225, Wake1 wrote:3) By holding your vote, you can't unknowingly sheep Scum or SK.
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 3:45 pm
by Wake1
In post 227, likeabauss wrote:I hate all the dishing out of town reads. "Ur town. Town there. There. And there too!"
Keep that crap to yourself.
It generates discussion, reactions, and activity. Like this:
VOTE: likeabauss
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 4:19 pm
by sangres
In post 231, Wake1 wrote:It generates discussion, reactions, and activity. Like this:
Then why weren't you willing to sheep my vote on JacobSavage? Would that not of done the same thing?
A hell of a lot better than voting someone for a theory stance.
Counterpoint: Have you ever seen him not do that? I don't think I have.
In post 227, likeabauss wrote:I hate all the dishing out of town reads. "Ur town. Town there. There. And there too!"
Keep that crap to yourself. Your town reads on D1 don't help other townies lynch scum today. All it does is setup scenarios and leverage plays for scum to start working on and lining up. If you want to help scum, keep it up. When you want to start helping town, start pointing out shady buggers and applying heat.
TIP is unique. Apparently his meta is so obviously transparent, that he gets sorted quickly and with ease (from those that know him.) At least two of those players are here, in separate hydra slots. Ill bet good money that they'll declare him town or scum before days end, and they'll be right. Not only would I prefer NOT to hang somebody that is so easily sorted (before them being sorted obviously), I'm highly suspicious of anybody who wants to hang that fellow. Its scummy as hell.
In post 227, likeabauss wrote:I hate all the dishing out of town reads. "Ur town. Town there. There. And there too!"
Keep that crap to yourself.
It generates discussion, reactions, and activity. Like this:
VOTE: likeabauss
:badposting:
~Jekyll
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 4:41 pm
by MVP
One of my heads is mad at me because I haven't been posting. So I'm just going to start with what I gave them.
I like Jekyll.
<snip>
Regarding Cabd: It's hard to say. I think he's town. But although I like the SK discussion, he already knows what the correct answer is supposed to be. And he's already shown that the answer relies heavily on a player's experience and people can offer an appropriate response regardless of alignment. It's what he does with the discussion that I care about. Regardless, I like the way he turned RC's RVS into a discussion and it does look like he's trying to scum-hunt. I also like his reaction to Sakura trying to paint Hermy as a policy lynch, which unfortunately, is something one of my other heads wants (and we already know that head is town, it's quite the dilemma). Some stuff about Cabd that I'm just going to casually omit before he gets a bigger ego.
Apparently, PV gave an appropriate response on the first page before the discussion even started. I nearly missed that.
Wake: Will be vehemently in favor of breaking its neck.
This is a response I would have given, and apparently its because of my inexperience playing with SK's. It's a pretty forceful statement. It's hard to say whether this is coming from a town mindset of eliminating the extra nightkill or scum mindset of eliminating threats. Null.
Toomai: Doesn't see a reason for an SK to follow along.
It's a little bit of an open statement that reinforces Wake's. I like him for town for other reasons.
Wake: Leashing is now an incredibly bad idea.
It's hard to say if this is Wake's site inexperience and he's being stubborn (which I already know he can be).
Doctor Jekyll: Leash and kill upon deviation.
Apparently this is the correct answer.
JS: Responds to Toomai with an honor statement.
He joins the discussion but avoids the original question. He reinforces the idea of why it's probable for the SK to go along with the leashing. <snip> I would consider lynching.
RC: Depends on whether we can get scum to waste a bullet.
It's a bit open-ended, but at least we know RC is thinking about it.
She then goes off about some arsonist stuff. I don't know how to evaluate that. Very slightly town for me.
Also, any discussion about the SK after Cabd already showed the correct answer isn't useful to me. The responses will be tainted.
In post 173, MVP wrote:I love how none of my hydra partners posted after my last post.
Catching up.
-L. J.
Seeing as how I haven't even posted yet for who knows what reason, you should take it up with the other more active head.
In post 185, yessiree wrote:presuming that someone(TIP in this case) is town lies within the scum mentality
VOTE: likeabauss
Dat misrep.
*Skipping Tebow's wall. I can take it up with him in the QT.
In post 198, Doctor Jekyll wrote:I once saw a jester on another site do this exact thing over and over until he was lynched.
Only time I've ever been a jester, I actually told them to lynch me because I was caught scum. Too easy.
Also, after careful deliberation and the need to show proper homage to other sports, I've settled on being Pete Rose. The other sports I wanted were taken.
~Pete
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 4:47 pm
by MVP
We would eventually have to sync up.
You guys have no sense of creativity. The best way to play jester is fake a daycop report (guilty), happens to be correct, and gets nightkilled by scum.
-L. J.
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 4:48 pm
by MVP
Or play along like they've caught scum on Day 2 and just get the quick victory.
~Pete
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 4:50 pm
by Sakura Hana
I still like how I claimed Jester on my only Jester game and that got me lynched...
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 4:50 pm
by MVP
Wait, how does getting nightkilled help the jester?
~Pete
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 4:52 pm
by MVP
That's the joke.
/fluff
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 5:15 pm
by RadiantCowbells
I've been jester a few times. Last time I was jester I claimed cop equiv with a guilty and then it turned out my guilty was a macho doublevoter innocent child, so I got lynched asap.
Posted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 10:07 pm
by sangres
In post 233, Doctor Jekyll wrote:Have I ever talked at you about how much I hate this emoticon? I guess I learned my lesson after I lynched it incorrectly.
