Am I going to lynch scum Boon who is giving me a ton to read and find his buddies off of
Or scum Bert who is posting theory
?
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 9:05 pm
by Drew-Sta
How sure are you on Bert, Molla? And why the certainty of read on him?
(A few hours away from doing more than phone surf)
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 9:14 pm
by BBmolla
I'm uncertain.
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 9:14 pm
by BBmolla
But I feel good because Bert's posts suck ass
*thumbsup*
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 9:15 pm
by Boonskiies
My reads are Bert/Cappuccino, molla could be up there, but it's a gamble to vote him.
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 9:16 pm
by Boonskiies
Sorry, *expresso.
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 9:37 pm
by Espressojet
There is nothing keeping us from lynching a confirmed scum! There is no night action. We can lynch them both, but first lets start with Boon, who is at this point basically a confscum! If we lynch him first, and he's the godfather, that's a free scumkill! Seriously, there's nothing to lose!
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 9:38 pm
by Espressojet
The only person who could possibly want to defend him right now would be his scumbuddy!
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 10:59 pm
by ZZZX
↑Drew-Sta wrote: This game is the shit. I just logged back on and have been laughing my ass off for the last ten minutes reading that whole exchange.
Boon, we need to play more games together. You're excellent value.
Give me a few hours and I'll have a look through and see if I can work out what happened from a scum-play. I actually thought Mr Ree was mafia, so need to have a good relook at things.
Dear goodness this is fucking good fun.
Basically sums up how I feel after waking up and finding game in day 2 lol
Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2014 11:17 pm
by ZZZX
I read but I have aquestion.
Why the **** did you lynch... >.<
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 1:05 am
by Honey bee
Espresso is definitely scum.
FOS's are scummy already, but fosing while you are wasting your vote on yourself sets my scum bells ringing. And if you don't think we're gonna get a lynch in a "while", then you really have no excuse not to vote with your suspicion.
Also looking at your iso, you never even bothered to vote anyone until after the lynch, yet you have like 50 posts in this thread and are pretty active, So I'm convinced. VOTE: Espressojet
Bert giving me scum vibes. The game I played with him he at least tried to care.
Drew-sta too. I don't feel like he came to any conclusions with all his questions, but it's only been a day so I'll give him a pass for now.
On other people I have no idea.
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 1:23 am
by Honey bee
oh my bad, Espresso voted boon after bert voted, the points still valid though.
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 2:58 am
by Drew-Sta
Prelude - we're at 7, meaning 4 mafia, 3 town I presume (two mafia roles, two teams, can't see there being more than two teams of two in the game).
Ok, have had a good read re the build to that lynch and then what has happened after.
Bert was, in many ways, the lynch-pin (lawl) to this. 176 gets Rubi at L-1. There was no real reason why, except, according to 118, he simply wanted to lynch someone. Hasn't done much since.
This sets the stage for Boon (our lovable hero) to hammer, and that's it.
Boon:
Spoiler:
Since RVS (I'm assuming his unvote denotes his exit of the phase) changes his vote from Bert, to Rubi, to Bert, to hammer Rubi, to George Clooney, to Bert. There's a focus here on Bert and Rubi. Now, I have NFI why, but either he's got a 'lynch all lurkers' thing going on, or he has an FOS for some reason not really stated (at least, not to me in his ISO). Bert has made it hard for himself with his posts, so Boon could be jumping on the wave here, but I'd like to ask Boon - why Bert?
Secondly, why not Nespresso, given you seem to have a FOS on him?
My issue with Boon here is he and Nespresso are bouncing off each other like two team mates. They're throwing mud at each other but not really analysing. Its got my curiosity. He's posting a lot of shit without a lot of method or meat to them. He's also doing a lot of selective scumhunting (he's made no attempt to look into ZZZX, Honeybee, BB, myself), and seems to have made a 'Oh well that sucks' tell in 204
To me, he is my prime candidate right now. He has a random playstyle, but in a game like this, random helps provide cover. Its a scatter tactic. People go 'Oh that Boon, he's just all cray cray'.
I don't. I think he's actually mafia.
VOTE: Boon
I like ya man, but I think you're one of them.
Honey bee:
Spoiler:
No real interaction except to fling mud at Bert, Nespresso and myself. Need more input. I will say:
Also looking at your iso, you never even bothered to vote anyone until after the lynch, yet you have like 50 posts in this thread and are pretty active, So I'm convinced.
This applies to you too, HB, so what's good for the goose is good for the gander.
Bert giving me scum vibes. The game I played with him he at least tried to care.
Same again. If you care, why not post more and do some actual analysis?
Also looking at your iso, you never even bothered to vote anyone until after the lynch, yet you have like 50 posts in this thread and are pretty active, So I'm convinced.
What has convinced you? I don't understand - he voted Boon, and then didn't change. You acknowledge he didn't change in a second post, but then maintain your point is still valid. What point?
Lazy analysis. Seems to be prod dodging more than anything. Not necessarily scum tells. Just problematic logic and play.
ZZZX:
Spoiler:
109 - why is there no white knighting? In fact, white knighting is probably what will lead us to scum? Finding out who is defending who will identify teams. This seems to me to be a deflection of tactics - something that will work for us is discredited in an attempt to discourage us from reading it as a tell.
Can you explain more about why you think there is no white knighting?
111 - either town tell or scum looking to play the VI.
234 - massive alarm bells for me. An attempt to get town cred by dismissing the previous lynch as 'dumb'.
Nespresso:
Spoiler:
Just... overload of posting. Seems to be spamming the game thread with zero analysis but an attempt to make himself look 'around' so noone can claim he is lurking. Can't say he is mafia, but can't say he isn't.
BBmolla:
Spoiler:
Appears certain Bert is mafia based on a feeling. Need more analysis. Previous experience makes me very, very wary.
tl:dr summary
mafia - I think Boon, Nespresso, ZZZX, Bert are mafia. I believe Boon is the one showing most.
I think Honey Bee is being lazy. I think Molla is null right now. I would flip between Bert / Molla depending on how much more they interact. My Bert read is mainly due to his blase attitude. It isn't pro-town at all.
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 4:00 am
by ZZZX
↑Drew-Sta wrote:Prelude - we're at 7, meaning 4 mafia, 3 town I presume (two mafia roles, two teams, can't see there being more than two teams of two in the game).
Ok, have had a good read re the build to that lynch and then what has happened after.
Bert was, in many ways, the lynch-pin (lawl) to this. 176 gets Rubi at L-1. There was no real reason why, except, according to 118, he simply wanted to lynch someone. Hasn't done much since.
This sets the stage for Boon (our lovable hero) to hammer, and that's it.
Boon:
Spoiler:
Since RVS (I'm assuming his unvote denotes his exit of the phase) changes his vote from Bert, to Rubi, to Bert, to hammer Rubi, to George Clooney, to Bert. There's a focus here on Bert and Rubi. Now, I have NFI why, but either he's got a 'lynch all lurkers' thing going on, or he has an FOS for some reason not really stated (at least, not to me in his ISO). Bert has made it hard for himself with his posts, so Boon could be jumping on the wave here, but I'd like to ask Boon - why Bert?
Secondly, why not Nespresso, given you seem to have a FOS on him?
My issue with Boon here is he and Nespresso are bouncing off each other like two team mates. They're throwing mud at each other but not really analysing. Its got my curiosity. He's posting a lot of shit without a lot of method or meat to them. He's also doing a lot of selective scumhunting (he's made no attempt to look into ZZZX, Honeybee, BB, myself), and seems to have made a 'Oh well that sucks' tell in 204
To me, he is my prime candidate right now. He has a random playstyle, but in a game like this, random helps provide cover. Its a scatter tactic. People go 'Oh that Boon, he's just all cray cray'.
I don't. I think he's actually mafia.
VOTE: Boon
I like ya man, but I think you're one of them.
Honey bee:
Spoiler:
No real interaction except to fling mud at Bert, Nespresso and myself. Need more input. I will say:
Also looking at your iso, you never even bothered to vote anyone until after the lynch, yet you have like 50 posts in this thread and are pretty active, So I'm convinced.
This applies to you too, HB, so what's good for the goose is good for the gander.
Bert giving me scum vibes. The game I played with him he at least tried to care.
Same again. If you care, why not post more and do some actual analysis?
Also looking at your iso, you never even bothered to vote anyone until after the lynch, yet you have like 50 posts in this thread and are pretty active, So I'm convinced.
What has convinced you? I don't understand - he voted Boon, and then didn't change. You acknowledge he didn't change in a second post, but then maintain your point is still valid. What point?
Lazy analysis. Seems to be prod dodging more than anything. Not necessarily scum tells. Just problematic logic and play.
ZZZX:
Spoiler:
109 - why is there no white knighting? In fact, white knighting is probably what will lead us to scum? Finding out who is defending who will identify teams. This seems to me to be a deflection of tactics - something that will work for us is discredited in an attempt to discourage us from reading it as a tell.
Can you explain more about why you think there is no white knighting?
111 - either town tell or scum looking to play the VI.
234 - massive alarm bells for me. An attempt to get town cred by dismissing the previous lynch as 'dumb'.
Nespresso:
Spoiler:
Just... overload of posting. Seems to be spamming the game thread with zero analysis but an attempt to make himself look 'around' so noone can claim he is lurking. Can't say he is mafia, but can't say he isn't.
BBmolla:
Spoiler:
Appears certain Bert is mafia based on a feeling. Need more analysis. Previous experience makes me very, very wary.
tl:dr summary
mafia - I think Boon, Nespresso, ZZZX, Bert are mafia. I believe Boon is the one showing most.
I think Honey Bee is being lazy. I think Molla is null right now. I would flip between Bert / Molla depending on how much more they interact. My Bert read is mainly due to his blase attitude. It isn't pro-town at all.
Because if you are town and are hard defended usually that would mean the person defending might be scum but with muiltiball I dont think that applies. Am I wrong?
also Town cred has nothing to do when lying within 24 hours of the day start. Half the votes on the wagon (including mine) were still rvs-ish votes. yet you guys went ahead and lynched.
Deadline in (expired on 2014-08-06 02:15:00)[/area]
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 9:26 am
by phokdapolees
Boonskiies had been playin' vengeball for years, there was no way this "mafia" nonsense could phase him. Unfortunately, he had been found to be taking steroids, and as such was banned from the AVAA (American Vengeball Association of America) for life.
Boonskiies,
Vengeful Townie
, has been lynched D2.
Boonskiies has (expired on 2014-07-25 16:30:00) to send me his choice of kill/no kill.
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 9:56 am
by phokdapolees
Boonskiies couldn't let his reputation go down like this, and found another cheater to take down with him.
Espressojet,
Red Mafia Godfather
, has been vengekilled D2.
It is now Day 3. Deadline in (expired on 2014-08-06 17:00:00).
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 10:01 am
by Bert
This is looking to be a short game.
Blue wins unless their godfather is lynched today or one of them is vengekilled by town.
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 10:02 am
by Bert
If we lynch the Red goon, blue auto-wins too.
Town's only chance is to lynch the blue GF today.
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 10:13 am
by Bert
It's not ideal for Blue to be obvious and quickhammer.
2/3 of the time they'll hammer a townie who can venge and make this game a coin-flip between a red or blue win.
Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2014 10:16 am
by Drew-Sta
Ok, so I need to reevaluate my reads. With Boon town, I had Bert, ZZZX and Nespresso (confirmed) as the others.
This game is the shit. I just logged back on and have been laughing my ass off for the last ten minutes reading that whole exchange.
