We're actually friends, but she is massively paranoid of me when she's town because I am fairly good at fooling her when I'm scum. On top of that, she usually posts in a way that rubs me wrong until I can figure out whether she's town or scum.
This is the only other game she's been in that she hasn't been rubbing me the wrong way.
This is the only other game we've been in where she hasn't been town.
Ergo, she's scum.
This is a lie for two reasons.
First, I'm not scum here.
Second, I was scum against him in Mafia Lottery, newbie 1539 and micro 402 and scum with him in NY 180.
he was SK in Mafia lottery...
No he wasn't. eyestott was 3P, he was town and I was scum, you were there, you should know.
I went back and looked for this game and it said house SK... now I gotta go back and look again...
Posted: Fri May 15, 2015 2:26 pm
by PeaceBringer
okay my memory sucks or twists something... now I got figure out what game house was sk... maybe it was one where I was scum and he was serial killer... Street Racer I think.
gotta go look...
I would love to blame it on my age but see my title...
If a Jester was lynched, the game would go on and not end.
Posted: Fri May 15, 2015 7:32 pm
by Mikazuki
Sorry for inactivity, setting up my new computer and it's taking forever.
I'll be back later tonight when I get a chance to read through prop0erly.
Posted: Fri May 15, 2015 11:03 pm
by McMenno
vonflare is logical
he must be scum
also there are 3 D1 wagons, and I'm not one of them
it's a miracle
I guess I can't get a wagon formed on vonflare so whatever.
why am I still voting Jeanne
VOTE: PeaceBringer
Posted: Fri May 15, 2015 11:59 pm
by Mikazuki
Not sure about PB's phishing, but I'm not liking his overall attitude and posts. That could just be how he plays though, I recently learned the hard way that not making sense in general is not necessarily always a scumtell. Closest thing I have to a scumread so far.
I feel like angry SW is giving me a town vibe, but I'm still far from certain on that.
House is... Meh. Could still go either way. His basis for scumreading SW is heavily meta based, but I know that they know each other well, so I can't say that he's being completely unreasonable. Vaguely reminiscent of town!House from our last game but too soon to say for sure.
Vonflare appears towny so far, seems like he's genuinely trying to get the game going and avoid unnecessary hangups while giving his opinions. Could be quite easy to emulate that behavior as scum though, but it feels quite genuine.
Not sure what to make of that cult discussion from earlier on, but nothing in particular catches my eye, might come back to that later. Most players haven't really posted since RVS-ish, don't really have an opinion on them.
VOTE: PeaceBringer
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 1:17 am
by SilverWolf
↑Marcrell wrote:Setup speculation might help but we won't have a lot of information without claims, which won't be good this early. VOTE: Silverwolf
If these vote tags are fucked up I put this in quick reply.
This is a bad vote. If my set up spec is bad what about Drixx's who pretty much has set up spec as his only content? It doesn't add up.
↑Kaerutsune wrote:We agree VOTE: SilverWolf
because deffo scum
This looks like RVS or another bad vote. Considering this is the first and only post by them in this game, I don't like it.
↑House wrote:What'x this? A Wolfie Wagon? VOTE: SilverWolf
Choo Choo!
This has been argued. My biggest reason for still being wary of House is he spend the entire argument trying to convince me and everyone else that he always scumreads me when we are both town and we always fight until we figure out alignments, etc. It's like he's trying too hard to use meta and not any reasons for anything I've done this game and I don't like that. Trying to emulate his town meta is a red flag for me.
Jeans and him can both be a bad alignment and not on same team with this set up...
Peacebringer spent the whole 1v1 here trying to egg it on and in particular trying to egg me on. His response to it compared to Vonflare's was exceptionally scummy. vonflare is at least trying to figure out alignments and making opinions based on game play and not trying to fan the flames or post nonnsense. There is a distinct difference here. I guess the nonsense part could just be a playstyle thing and not scum but the fanning the flames is scummy. He made no comment about House. Just me.
Still don't like Jeanne's only post here considering she's been active elsewhere. Scumread here also. I think Mika might be town and I think vonflare might be town. I don't like that I have more scumreads than townreads. That kind of sucks.
It's sad that there are 13 people in this game and most of them are null. Inactive games are terrible for town. That said, I'm not going to spend a lot of time pushing content at this point.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 1:26 am
by Maruchan
so i couldn't even stomach to read the house vs wolf argument through the past 6 pages, because it was so bad. You guys weren't playing mafia, you were having a headbutting contest over out of game feelings of dislike towards each other.
and i really don't like house's personality. at all. it's extremely hard to play with.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 1:29 am
by Belisarius
↑House wrote:We're actually friends, but she is massively paranoid of me when she's town because I am fairly good at fooling her when I'm scum. On top of that, she usually posts in a way that rubs me wrong until I can figure out whether she's town or scum.
This is the only other game she's been in that she hasn't been rubbing me the wrong way. This is the only other game we've been in where she hasn't been town.
Ergo, she's scum.
It was raining on Wednesday.
I looked out the window just now and noticed it was raining.
Ergo, it's Wednesday.
QED.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 1:39 am
by SilverWolf
↑Maruchan wrote:so i couldn't even stomach to read the house vs wolf argument through the past 6 pages, because it was so bad. You guys weren't playing mafia, you were having a headbutting contest over out of game feelings of dislike towards each other.
and i really don't like house's personality. at all. it's extremely hard to play with.
It might surprise you to learn then that House and I are friends.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 1:50 am
by Maruchan
well then
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 1:51 am
by Maruchan
Actually no not really. Me and Maestro have had some fantastic arguments while playing mafia together, even when we're of the same alignment and we both know it.
or we break the game by confirming each other's townieness through gameplay. XD
we still fight like brothers
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 3:17 am
by Bins
Can't... get... into this game... because... weird... emotional... fights...
I feel hypocritical saying that.
Meh.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 3:18 am
by Bins
Nah, I think I share the opinion that I wish I was Jester/Cult/some cool bastard thing.
Silverwolf being sad is... characteristic of her? I've never played with her.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 4:01 am
by Maruchan
↑Bins wrote:Can't... get... into this game... because... weird... emotional... fights...
I feel hypocritical saying that.
Meh.
I feel you. I couldn't comprehend the last 5 pages of game so chalked it off as unimportant quotewalls of rage.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 4:23 am
by Marcrell
I voted SilverWolf because the game was slowing down and nobody was postong.
I call this mission accomplished.
VOTE: peacebringer This is a vote I can get behind.
Wolf was definitely flailing back there, but I fell it could be town flail with House doing the meta thing and not budging.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2015 4:32 am
by PeaceBringer
Well that puts me at L-2 I think.
All over playstyle and realize how quick this wagon is and reconsider.
I learn things by being antagonistic and getting reactions.
I honestly am trying to sort out.
Silver's play was and is suspect to me for reasons stated
Vonflare on the other hand showed self to be strong town. A read so strong to me that doubt anything will take me off that read.
I think there is some thought that I am jester, nope, absolutely not. It would be an easy win condition for me though...
