Posted: Sat Aug 20, 2016 7:41 am
________________________________________
It just reads like scum interacting with each other. Even though scum have daytalk, they can't ignore each other in the main chat. It seems forced.
The mix-up would make it seem like your recent point against him doesn't hold water. Do you still not like Tier from your interaction with him on page 2, or is there something I'm missing here?In post 210, pistachi0n wrote:I still don't like tier. Granted, I mixed him up earlier--I still don't like him though.
...did you forget 141/144?In post 208, Accountant wrote:do you have a readslist or a general idea who is scum
In post 139, ChaosOmega wrote:*shrug* Baa.
VOTE: pistachi0n
Tier, did you have an ulterior motive calling pist town in 92?
which prob means there is scum here? idk let's read on
What do you currently think about pist?In post 144, ChaosOmega wrote:pist - wasn't on my radar at all until Tier's 137; sheeping the read with no other insights on my endIn post 141, Accountant wrote:Chaos tell me your scumreads with explanations
---
Who's your biggest scumread so far, Accountant?
This chaos thing hasn't done anythingIn post 203, ChaosOmega wrote:Carey: Who is your top scumread that isn't me?
Lycan: In post 156, you said the pist wagon pissed you off. Can you explain what exactly pissed you off about it?
pist: What do you think about Tier now? Also, any thoughts on the speedy wagon that built on you?
I find this interesting. Let's get back to this later.In post 217, Accountant wrote:I'm not comfortable voting him atm - whenever I try to make an internal case on him or try to "get" where he stands in my mind and why, it feels very vague and fuzzy. That's a sign that I'm conceptualizing his play incorrectly.
Let's stop doing interactive tells before a flip tyvmIn post 225, pistachi0n wrote:It just reads like scum interacting with each other. Even though scum have daytalk, they can't ignore each other in the main chat. It seems forced.
It's still all you.
In post 38, ChaosOmega wrote:Lycan: why keep your vote on Tier?
Mick: why ask to move the game along without contributing to moving it along yourself?
In post 51, ChaosOmega wrote:Mick, what are your thoughts on Umlaut and Lycan?
In post 139, ChaosOmega wrote:*shrug* Baa.
VOTE: pistachi0n
Tier, did you have an ulterior motive calling pist town in 92?
In post 144, ChaosOmega wrote:BBT - didn't like 35, looked like he wanted to show he was town by his desire to advance the game, but voted a person with a naked vote as their only post and who wasn't the leading wagon without questioning any player...BBT is voting leading wagons and hasn't really contributed anything yet, doesn't move the needle either way for meIn post 141, Accountant wrote:Chaos tell me your scumreads with explanations
Carey - no real content or effort to figure out the game state (aside from 91), and then the last third of his posts have been a push on me because I'm a lurker, which is easy to push without providing useful content
pist - wasn't on my radar at all until Tier's 137; sheeping the read with no other insights on my end
---
Who's your biggest scumread so far, Accountant?
In post 155, ChaosOmega wrote:I'm gonna word this kinda vague because of site rules.
After I questioned him in 51, I saw that he was posting in another game. After further research, I'm more willing to lean it towards null due to flaking out. Still don't like 35 due to the previous reason, and I still want to hear what BBT thinks of the game.
In post 203, ChaosOmega wrote:Carey: Who is your top scumread that isn't me?
Lycan: In post 156, you said the pist wagon pissed you off. Can you explain what exactly pissed you off about it?
pist: What do you think about Tier now? Also, any thoughts on the speedy wagon that built on you?
In post 205, ChaosOmega wrote:Who said it's content? It's helping me determine who I think is scum. If the answers don't strengthen my read and help me form a case, why say anything about it?
In post 207, ChaosOmega wrote:As for what I've asked so far, I've said I didn't like Mick's answer to my 38, and my follow up there wasn't responded to before he replaced out. Lycan's answer didn't do anything for me one way or the other. Umlaut's response to 112 made sense to me, so did Tier's to 139 after I reread 137. Your answer explained why you shifted off Umlaut, and here we are.
In post 228, ChaosOmega wrote:The mix-up would make it seem like your recent point against him doesn't hold water. Do you still not like Tier from your interaction with him on page 2, or is there something I'm missing here?In post 210, pistachi0n wrote:I still don't like tier. Granted, I mixed him up earlier--I still don't like him though.
...did you forget 141/144?In post 208, Accountant wrote:do you have a readslist or a general idea who is scum
In post 31, CareyHammer wrote:Oh, my God! You suck!In post 27, Lowell wrote:Ah, good to be back
*stretches*
Let's test out these sea legs.
VOTE: carey
Yah still work. Let's play, ladies and gents.
VOTE: Lowell
In post 46, CareyHammer wrote:My vote was the classic ploy of "voting for the first poster." Nothing moreIn post 44, Ümläüt wrote:I guess it is kind of a reach, but hell if I have anything more solid to go on right now.In post 42, Accountant wrote:It's reaching at best and a misrep at worst to interpret Carey's first vote as "purporting to be serious".
If Carey had just laid down a naked vote I'd assume his vote was random; if he said something ridiculous I'd assume his vote was random; but instead he quoted me and then voted me. Via the maxim of relevance it's reasonable to infer that the two are related and that contained in the quote is an actual reason for his vote. So either it was a serious vote or at the least he wanted someone to think it might be.
At any rate his second vote doesn't seem like he really wants the game to progress out of RVS, which is as good a reason as any for a vote on page 2.
In post 60, CareyHammer wrote:In post 59, Ümläüt wrote:@CareyDo you have any actual reads yet, even weak ones?
@LowellWhat particularly pings you as newbish about Accountant?
no
In post 72, CareyHammer wrote:In post 69, Lowell wrote:I also 100% agree with Tier's #66, and don't like acct's 'aww shucks' response in #67. Looks like acct is trying to pocket carey there and got caught out. I'll have to rethink that newb read I had.
As if I were pocketable!
In post 91, CareyHammer wrote:I can't tell who to scumread yet. One of Tier and pista
In post 126, CareyHammer wrote:Activity Overview
PM Username First Post Last Post Elapsed Time Posts V/LA Ends
Lowell Aug 10, 07:36am Aug 16, 02:53pm 0 days 2 hours 10
BlueBloodedToffee Aug 16, 10:48am Aug 16, 12:38pm 0 days 4 hours 3
Ümläüt Aug 09, 05:36pm Aug 16, 12:36pm 0 days 4 hours 25
SnarkySnowman Aug 08, 05:39pm Aug 16, 10:46am 0 days 6 hours 6
pistachi0n Aug 09, 06:10pm Aug 16, 10:09am 0 days 6 hours 7
Accountant Aug 09, 06:18pm Aug 15, 06:16pm 0 days 22 hours 29
CareyHammer Aug 09, 10:04pm Aug 15, 03:29pm 1 day 1 hour 7
ChaosOmega Aug 10, 04:48am Aug 15, 06:42am 1 day 10 hours 5
TierShift Aug 09, 09:51pm Aug 15, 03:28am 1 day 13 hours 17
Lycanfire Aug 10, 12:54am Aug 15, 12:48am 1 day 16 hours 10
ConManMick Aug 09, 10:38pm Aug 11, 10:19am 5 days 6 hours 7
PM Selected
In post 127, CareyHammer wrote:I don't trust anyone who posts less than me. Vote for Chaos.
In post 161, CareyHammer wrote:Care to share with the rest of the class?In post 159, BlueBloodedToffee wrote:Alright, I'm caught up!
I have some town reads, some null reads and some scum reads.
Man, I'm so good.
That is literally every word Carey has ever said. How about a detailed list of who you think is the scum and why?In post 244, CareyHammer wrote:In post 38, ChaosOmega wrote:Lycan: why keep your vote on Tier?
Mick: why ask to move the game along without contributing to moving it along yourself?In post 51, ChaosOmega wrote:Mick, what are your thoughts on Umlaut and Lycan?In post 139, ChaosOmega wrote:*shrug* Baa.
VOTE: pistachi0n
Tier, did you have an ulterior motive calling pist town in 92?In post 144, ChaosOmega wrote:BBT - didn't like 35, looked like he wanted to show he was town by his desire to advance the game, but voted a person with a naked vote as their only post and who wasn't the leading wagon without questioning any player...BBT is voting leading wagons and hasn't really contributed anything yet, doesn't move the needle either way for meIn post 141, Accountant wrote:Chaos tell me your scumreads with explanations
Carey - no real content or effort to figure out the game state (aside from 91), and then the last third of his posts have been a push on me because I'm a lurker, which is easy to push without providing useful content
pist - wasn't on my radar at all until Tier's 137; sheeping the read with no other insights on my end
---
Who's your biggest scumread so far, Accountant?In post 155, ChaosOmega wrote:I'm gonna word this kinda vague because of site rules.
After I questioned him in 51, I saw that he was posting in another game. After further research, I'm more willing to lean it towards null due to flaking out. Still don't like 35 due to the previous reason, and I still want to hear what BBT thinks of the game.In post 203, ChaosOmega wrote:Carey: Who is your top scumread that isn't me?
Lycan: In post 156, you said the pist wagon pissed you off. Can you explain what exactly pissed you off about it?
pist: What do you think about Tier now? Also, any thoughts on the speedy wagon that built on you?In post 205, ChaosOmega wrote:Who said it's content? It's helping me determine who I think is scum. If the answers don't strengthen my read and help me form a case, why say anything about it?In post 207, ChaosOmega wrote:As for what I've asked so far, I've said I didn't like Mick's answer to my 38, and my follow up there wasn't responded to before he replaced out. Lycan's answer didn't do anything for me one way or the other. Umlaut's response to 112 made sense to me, so did Tier's to 139 after I reread 137. Your answer explained why you shifted off Umlaut, and here we are.In post 228, ChaosOmega wrote:The mix-up would make it seem like your recent point against him doesn't hold water. Do you still not like Tier from your interaction with him on page 2, or is there something I'm missing here?In post 210, pistachi0n wrote:I still don't like tier. Granted, I mixed him up earlier--I still don't like him though.
...did you forget 141/144?In post 208, Accountant wrote:do you have a readslist or a general idea who is scum
That is literally every word chaos has ever said. How about a detailed list of who you think is the scum and why?