Mafiascum.net

Obviously, early D1 reads. Not based on much.

Town:
KainTepes - didn't read his crumb, but don't think scum be stupid enough to crumb something to get them kicked out of game
Xanth - gut
Comm - his responses to heat seemed town
Vifam - gut
Pepchoninga - gut

Murky middle:
Skelda
Uzi
Fuzzy
PerV - lurks as town early, lurks as scum early. classic PerV
James - may be the best mafia player in the world. don't care. don't need to put others down to prove it. good play will be noticed here and will speak for itself.

Scum:
Tywin - after reading Comm, Tywin seems scummy for call out of Comm
Kyouko - 1 shot cop claim seemed legit to me. multiple one shots would make sense in large. backtrack seemed scummy to me

BTW Tywin, did you see Comm's claim?
If so, why are you still voting him?
-Ali

Also SlySly, can you show me where Kyouko backtracked?
-Ali

Also when it comes to Pep, the reason why Me and Grey are SRing him is mostly because we don't like how he's poking at James but he doesn't want to lynch James today.
-Ali

In post 227, Land of Xanth wrote:Also SlySly, can you show me where Kyouko backtracked?
-Ali

In post 16, ssbm_Kyouko wrote: I'm also a 1-shot cop so our roles directly conflict therefore I must destroy you
VOTE: James3

In post 34, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:yeah LoX there can only be 1 1-shot cop

In post 38, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:No I didn't take his claim seriously nor is my claim serious, it was a joke vote

Sly, why are you still voting James?
I am assuming you want to PL them?
-Ali

In post 228, Land of Xanth wrote:Also when it comes to Pep, the reason why Me and Grey are SRing him is mostly because we don't like how he's poking at James but he doesn't want to lynch James today.
-Ali

Im Poking him, while still applying pressure. He seems to be very sure in what he does. Tho for now it is not resonable to lynch him, considering we might be wrong.

Tho Comn's role makes a bit more sense with this game in particular. I do doubth there are 2 cop roles tho. A watcher or any other investigative role possible, but not another cop.

I kinda doubth that both of those roles are town.

Exactly why we think you're scum <3.
With that said, got any other reads?
A read list with explanations would be c00l
-Ali

In post 230, Land of Xanth wrote:Sly, why are you still voting James?
I am assuming you want to PL them?
-Ali

Just making a point that players here can't always be read by classic means. I'll play scummy af and James can use all his brilliance to point out my scumminess and his greatness for spotting it, then he can watch me flip town and call my play out as bad. Mislynches happen D1 all the time and town very often finds a way to win. When I flip town, I guarantee there will be scum on my wagon. Wagon analysis, imo, is plenty valuable.

Call it PL if you must, but it really isn't. James very well be scum trying to hide behind the mechanics of this game. That's why he's at the bottom of my murky middle. His claim sets him up to coast to D3 and that's plenty of time for others to gain attention while he tries to slide into the shadows after he's known to be, at best, basically VT.

I'd gladly support a lynch of my current SRs or basically anyone in the murky middle, where Gamma also belongs. I realized I left him out of my reads.

In post 226, Land of Xanth wrote:BTW Tywin, did you see Comm's claim?
If so, why are you still voting him?
-Ali

Not caught up, but saw this after hitting last page. I'm not voting him? I unvoted right as he ninja'd me with the claim earlier today. Look at the vote count from mod. I unvoted before you did? Have you not read the thread at all?

In post 162, Land of Xanth wrote:

In post 161, Tywin Lannister wrote:Smh UNVOTE:

Tywin, what do you make of Pepto saying James is not the Lynch today but continuing to poke at him?

-G

Grey read the thread, so why aren't you Ali? Wtf?

In post 234, Tywin Lannister wrote:

In post 226, Land of Xanth wrote:BTW Tywin, did you see Comm's claim?
If so, why are you still voting him?
-Ali

Not caught up, but saw this after hitting last page. I'm not voting him? I unvoted right as he ninja'd me with the claim earlier today. Look at the vote count from mod. I unvoted before you did? Have you not read the thread at all?

Ah. My mistake. Misread the votecount then. It happens, right Tywin?
-Ali

In post 236, Land of Xanth wrote:

In post 234, Tywin Lannister wrote:

In post 226, Land of Xanth wrote:BTW Tywin, did you see Comm's claim?
If so, why are you still voting him?
-Ali

Not caught up, but saw this after hitting last page. I'm not voting him? I unvoted right as he ninja'd me with the claim earlier today. Look at the vote count from mod. I unvoted before you did? Have you not read the thread at all?

Ah. My mistake. Misread the votecount then. It happens, right Tywin?
-Ali

smart ass! Also, read page 7. I have to read 8 through 10 now.

In post 204, TheFuzzylogic99 wrote:I hope that neither one are actually cops...

Perv.....
I would ask why you would vig me but it obvious.... everyone loves to kill FuzzyLogic even when I am town. Cant remember was I scum our last game?

Can you enlighten the rest of us please?

In post 237, Tywin Lannister wrote:

In post 236, Land of Xanth wrote:

In post 234, Tywin Lannister wrote:

In post 226, Land of Xanth wrote:BTW Tywin, did you see Comm's claim?
If so, why are you still voting him?
-Ali

Not caught up, but saw this after hitting last page. I'm not voting him? I unvoted right as he ninja'd me with the claim earlier today. Look at the vote count from mod. I unvoted before you did? Have you not read the thread at all?

Ah. My mistake. Misread the votecount then. It happens, right Tywin?
-Ali

smart ass! Also, read page 7. I have to read 8 through 10 now.

IT'S JUST A PRANK BRO!
In all seriousness that was a good response because if you jumped on me for that would be concerning because you tend to misread things a lot.
-Ali

In post 212, James3 wrote:

In post 211, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:ToS doesn't have the best reputation so he may just be blindly carrying some of his bad or in this case, controversial habits over.

Again, my tactics are not representative of ToS, and they in fact caused much consternation while I was there.

Though yes, they are as terrible as everyone says.

So if 'always claiming immediately' is your meta, and you claim it isn't normal for ToS to do, what exactly do you do it for? What is gained? Kyouko said you did it in a newbie game as Doctor too, so what could possibly make claiming any role worth it over the obvious drawbacks? Explain, because this still hasn't been answered. What is the reason to claim in your first post, aside from 'always doing it?'

He prob just likes to do it lol

I respect that tbh

God I just noticed how cringeworthy that meme was.
I am never saying that shit again.

Vifam, got anything else to add to the game?
The majority of your posts are talking about James.

-Ali

I'm on my phone rn I got you in the am

In post 206, Land of Xanth wrote:{Tywin Lannister, ssbm_Kyouko}
{James3, CommKnight}
{KainTepes, TheFuzzyLogic99, Skelda, SlySly, Gamma Emerald}
{LilUziVert, Zekromaster, PeregrineV}
{Vifam}
{Pepchoninga}

Not posted yet

:
Narna
Harp

-G

That was close, my heart stopped when I thought Alisae was actually TRing me, he never TRs me

In post 199, CommKnight wrote:

In post 197, ssbm_Kyouko wrote: Comm why are you rolefishing for a fuller claim from him if you have the ability to check his role yourself?

1.) That'd be a major waste of my role.
2.) He's already outed himself, if there's more to his role, then he should claim so when he's being called out.
3.) He's scum.

1.)Would you believe him if he made a new claim that he said was his full role? If not I don't see how it would be a waste of your role.
2.) Do you think that would be beneficial to town?
3.) What makes you so sure? You could prove he was fakeclaiming by checking his role, and if he doesn't give you a result that indicates he had a town-motivated reason to claim 1-shot cop you could lynch him then.

In post 215, SlySly wrote:

In post 81, Land of Xanth wrote: Move on from James and find someone else to vote, because the only people with any notice for killing a claimed cop on d1 is Scum.

Not true. He's a 1-shot cop. He could screw up his one shot. He's not a big loss. If his claim is true and we lynched him, big deal. It would be worth it not to listen to his snippiness for the entire game. I'd be willing to lynch him just so the rest of the game can be fun.

------------

In post 85, Land of Xanth wrote:

In post 80, James3 wrote:

@MOD Is this game bastard?

This game lives in Theme Park. Abandon preconceived notions.

------------

In post 104, Tywin Lannister wrote:I want to hear from both him and James, since I haven't seen an explanation as to why he'd claim on his first post when he's a 1-shot cop

Not reading the game pings my scumdar.

This entire post is scummy af.

This guy admits to wanting to policy lynch a cop claim, admits to thinking it will flip town, but wants to lynch there to 'make the game fun.' Fun for who? Scum? If you were town, you'd be actually scum hunting instead of trying to policy lynch someone you TR.

Oh, and then he goes on to throw shade on me randomly by saying I don't read the game (which wouldn't be AI regardless), even though I have almost twice as many posts as him. Misrep much? Also, what possibly would make you think I wasn't reading the game when the OP was made? You're clearly just making shit up just to 'look' active and see what sticks.

VOTE: Slysly

In post 245, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:That was close, my heart stopped when I thought Alisae was actually TRing me, he never TRs me

But I am TRing you because so far your actions seem very town motivated.
-Ali

In post 235, Tywin Lannister wrote:

In post 162, Land of Xanth wrote:

In post 161, Tywin Lannister wrote:Smh UNVOTE:

Tywin, what do you make of Pepto saying James is not the Lynch today but continuing to poke at him?

-G

Grey read the thread, so why aren't you Ali? Wtf?

Ever been a hydra?

The last post marker is based on the account, not the browser. That means if he reads up to 100, then I come in and read up to 200, his next visit will start at 201, not 101.

-G

In post 248, Land of Xanth wrote:

In post 235, Tywin Lannister wrote:

In post 162, Land of Xanth wrote:

In post 161, Tywin Lannister wrote:Smh UNVOTE:

Tywin, what do you make of Pepto saying James is not the Lynch today but continuing to poke at him?

-G

Grey read the thread, so why aren't you Ali? Wtf?

Ever been a hydra?

The new post marker is based on the account, not the browser. That means if he reads up to 100, then I come in and read up to 200, his next visit will start at 201, not 101.

-G

Fixed.

-G