I'll try and remember what I had, I don't have the quotes I wanted to reply to but so be it.
-I usually scumread A50 at some point in the game so I'm not going to bother sorting him unless we're both alive on day 3 or so.
-I share Tchill's confusion as to why DrDolittle is scum.
-The fact that DVa and Brighteyedfish join DrDolittle wagon without any comment is kinda bothering me.
-I'm not a fan of policy lynching because of someone's reputation. I am in favor of punishing stupid behavior instead of calling it "too scummy to be scum".
Not sure if I forgot something but there ya go
Town pool: Gamma, Tchill, OkaPoka, Joey maybe
I'm not really super worried about someone yet so I'm just going to vote here until someone explains to me why DrDolittle is scum
Sorry lol. I didn't like that back and forth between you and whoever it was. Seemed unnecessary.
Do you think that back and forth was Town vs Scum?
And why would okapoka be the scum side of it?
Tchill, would you mind answering this still? I don't think you did.
I think it could have been. Just seemed kinda pointless. Oka is just giving me weird vibes atm. I'd rather not lynch him unless I'm sure he's scum because if he's town I think he'll be a good asset.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 3:09 am
by Tchill13
It's just a wagon. I'm not hopping on DDL. very odd my wagon didn't grow after I self voted lol... That's intriguing. DDL is probably town. I haven't found scum yet but I'll let someone know when I do.
What do you think about kokichi ? About drdollittle and his wagon? people on it etc, i wanna hear you
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:31 am
by PenguinPower
As I said, I am fine sorting kokichi as scum as a baseline. His posting hasn't done anything to change that.
DDL hasn't done enough for me to form an opinion. I find nothing wrong with a wagon forming on him - though it is interesting that Tchill/Kokichi wagons didn't take off like DDL did.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:45 am
by Joey_
Can you further develop on the koki baseline, what makes koki's content enough to be called a scum baseline? you really think hes scum until proven otherwise, what makes you that confident so early on?
You say you don't have enough to read drdolittle, but you think its fine if people vote him.. isn't that a bit contradictory? Or do you acknowledge people could get genuine reads from content you deem insufficient personally?
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:55 am
by PenguinPower
In post 234, Joey_ wrote:Can you further develop on the koki baseline, what makes koki's content enough to be called a scum baseline? you really think hes scum until proven otherwise, what makes you that confident so early on?
It's based on my previous games with him, not his content alone in this game. Though, he is starting out quite similar.
In post 234, Joey_ wrote:You say you don't have enough to read drdolittle, but you think its fine if people vote him.. isn't that a bit contradictory? Or do you acknowledge people could get genuine reads from content you deem insufficient personally?
How is that contradictory? Wagons by themselves provide information, and we are at the beginning of the game. I find nothing wrong with a wagon reaching L-1 in the first few pages, regardless of how I feel about the slot at the time. Hence my previous comment on the tchill/kokichi/ddl wagons.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:02 am
by Joey_
Ah, that's what you meant by fine with the wagon
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 7:12 am
by Almost50
@ALL: Many of you are asking why Dolittle is being wagoned, and I say it's because he's living up to his name. Now unless he tries to act like DrActuallydosomething or DrTryabiyharder I don't think I want to move my vote off him. I find it intriguing he has gone back to the shadows since he started being voted.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 7:40 am
by DrDolittle
In post 237, Almost50 wrote:@ALL: Many of you are asking why Dolittle is being wagoned, and I say it's because he's living up to his name. Now unless he tries to act like DrActuallydosomething or DrTryabiyharder I don't think I want to move my vote off him. I find it intriguing he has gone back to the shadows since he started being voted.
guy its been like 15 hours since my last post. here's what i've done. I went to sleep at 1. got up at 10:30. Went to BK to get some chicken nuggets, quickly checked ms at work. i'll get to this tonight.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 7:55 am
by Radja
In post 237, Almost50 wrote:@ALL: Many of you are asking why Dolittle is being wagoned, and I say it's because he's living up to his name. Now unless he tries to act like DrActuallydosomething or DrTryabiyharder I don't think I want to move my vote off him. I find it intriguing he has gone back to the shadows since he started being voted.
I've never played with DrDolittle so I'm not familiar with how he tends to play. I'm more bothered by BrightEyedFish who also hasn't contributed much but has hopped onto that wagon without commenting on anything that's happened.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 8:04 am
by Tchill13
Lol yeah I'm not liking this DDL wagon or ppl trying to push it through too much at all atm.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 8:18 am
by Nako
I agree that there were suspicious votes, but I think those can be early distances.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 8:25 am
by skitter30
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 9:19 am
by Tchill13
VOTE: sephiroth
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 9:36 am
by DVa
In post 241, Nako wrote:I agree that there were suspicious votes, but I think those can be early distances.
What do you think of Sephora?
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 12:19 pm
by Sephiroth
I'm here.
Town pile: { Tchill, Radja, Kokichi, Joey }
Null Pile: { BEF, PP, A50, nako }
Scummy Pile: { okapoka, drdoolittle, dva }
No reason to put the -1 on unless Drdoolittle doesnt post tonight as promised so VOTE: okapoka[/b] instead.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 12:20 pm
by Sephiroth
whoops.
VOTE: okapoka
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 2:10 pm
by OkaPoka
so dva and nako are buddying each other, likely at least one is scum
almost50 may be a liability wrt how he is treating the dr dolittle wagon
bes just outta nowhere hopped on dr dolittle wagon
